Alright, I better give a bit more of my input on this stuff.
Regarding Aegislash
Branflakes325
First of all, the blade forme's front sprite has an error on the right (our left) edge of the blade. It's too flat and doesn't match the rest of the sprites. I'm going to assume this was just a mistake.
So the shield's handle is wrong on both of them. On the shield forme, it should be visible under the arms and above the blade, something like this:
Paste the arms on top of that and it'll be correct, although you may want to edit . On the blade forme, the handle is at completely the wrong angle. I didn't add in the arm, because last time I did it took forever, and you'd probably do a better job anyways, but here's how it should look.
Both of those are kind of rough drafts, feel free to edit slightly, but try to keep the points where it connects to the edge at the exact same place as at the front of the shield. Anyways, I PMed you about why this is correct a few days ago, but I'll copy-paste some of it here so others can see it too.
Hide
Watch this video. While it provides a good reference for multiple angles, specifically see seconds 40-43, where there's an aerial side view.See the handle? It connects directly to the line patterns on the front of the shield.
Also, if you watch the video really closely when Aegislash changes forme, at about 15 seconds and 58 seconds, you can see that the blade is actually inserted in the shield's handle. This was barely noticeable in my version of the sprite, but it's definitely something to account for.
Third, the shield forme's left arm, the one that's hidden underneath the right arm, it looks like it hasn't been changed from when the official artwork was used as a reference. I know it's mostly obscured, but it's still noticeable.
Alright, this is probably the most subjective change, but I honestly still think that my original version of the arms were just overall better. To bring up the reference images again:
I just feel like your version still has the wrong shape of the arms. They need to be thicker in some parts, with the thickness changing more gradually, and et cetera. I actually think it would be easier to edit my version of the arms to make them ideal than to edit yours, they just seem closer to what they look like in-game.
Anyways, I'm going to be gone from tomorrow to New Year's Day. I'll still have (limited) internet access, but I'm not going to be able to do any spriting. With that happening, and now that we've got this new fancy approval list, I think I'm going to share some of my future plans for the project.
First of all, I plan to redo Aegislash's animation when it's ready. Of course it gets high priority, given that it's already been animated, and it happens to be my favourite Gen VI Pokémon.
Mawile's revamps are about 80% done, the changes really look a LOT better so far, but at this point it may not be done for a decent while longer. Also, nobody had better edit it at all, because that thing is like a child to me, my original contribution to the project, and I'm EXTREMELY proud of having created it all on my own. When I do post it, if you have any issues, feel free to let me know, but PLEASE don't fix it yourself. I don't care about Aegislash or Mega Scizor or the rest though, go crazy.
The remaining ones I want to animate are Mega Ampharos, Zygarde, and Goodra. I've been looking forward to those three for quite a while, and it seems that they may be nearing completion soon. Of course my other two static sprite creations, Mega Aerodactyl and Scizor, are on the "eventually" list too.
Also, I've got a holiday present for everyone. I'll post it soon. 0u0
EDIT:
Branflakes325 said:Here's an updated aegislash:
Everything's done except the blade forme's left hand on the backsprite. Last time I did that it was a total pain to get right, and I literally do not have the time to fix it right now. But yeah, don't try changing the position of the handle, because it really needs to match up with the frontsprite.
If you watch this video again, at about 0:19 when Aegislash uses Shadow Sneak, you can see that the left hand goes significantly farther to the right than the sprite originally showed, with the fingers being somewhat longer as well. If the hand is changed to fix the current handle, it'll be in the right position.
And yeah, 'course I'm going to re-animate this myself. My original sprite's already been pretty much replaced, but I'm still determined to contribute to my favourite new Kalos Pokémon.