Prosecutor Godot said:Donphan's niche as a bulky spinner is not nearly enough to justify it's higher usage over Terrakion, Landorus-I, Keldeo, Latias, Kyurem-B, Starmie, Deoxys-S, Tornadus-T and Bisharp. There are just so many better ways to remove entry hazards than using a Donphan. Excadrill, while more frail physically, has better special bulk, more power, isn't slow as all hell, and a Mold Breaker EQ that comes in extremely handy for dealing with Levitate users like the most common pokemon in OU, Rotom-W. It also has 8 resistances and 2 immunities, which especially with an Air Balloon will give Excadrill plenty of opportunities to spin hazards. Starmie is the fastest spinner in the game barring Sand Rush Excadrill, and while it struggles to get through the most common ghost type in Aegislash it still is super fast, and harder to revenge kill than a Donphan. Hell, even Tentacruel is an option that lot of utility in it's decent speed, typing, special bulk and utility in Knock Off + Toxic Spikes. That's just Rapid Spinners; that doesn't even get into the amount of Defoggers which can also function as a better wall than Donphan. Mandibuzz, Mega-Scizor, Latias, Skarmory. All of which, unlike Donphan have reliable recovery as well as much better options to support their team.
Secondly, stop acting like Donphan can use 252 EVs in every stat, as well as Earthquake, Rock Slide, Rapid Spin, Knock Off, Stealth Rock, Seed Bomb, Roar, Ice Shard, Play Rough and Toxic in one set. Donphan needs each one of those moves either for utility or to not be walled by another top threat (Ice Shard, Gliscor/Landorus-T. Seed Bomb, Rotom-W. Rock coverage, Charizard-Y/Talonflame). If it runs Adamant, then it's 2HKOed by top threats like Banded Talonflame and if it goes bulky then it becomes incredibly weak and becomes setup bait for a variety of pokemon that don't mind it's weak, uninvested coverage moves. Donphan is also pathetically frail on the Special side and is almost useless against teams that mostly uses Special attackers. As much as I'm shitting on Donphan right now, it's not completely useless. It has good utility in it's Physical bulk and movepool but it should only be used as a last resort if absolutely no other method of removing hazards work for a SR weak team. UU is in desperate need of more viable spinners right now, which is why I'd really like to see Donphan, Tentacruel and Forretress drop; there are much better options in OU for all 3 that aren't going to be a huge liability a good chunk of the time.
For the person who posted the Rock Polish Donphan set..just no, Landorus-I still does that much better.
Well obviously it is enough to justify it, or whats ur explanation for its high usage? Further more, 90% of the other pokes u mention that dont get high usage fill COMPLETELY different roles and cannot be used as a comparison.
And no there is no better way to remove hazards than donphan, there are other ways yes, but Donphan has a combination of traites that make it unique in its role, if u need these traites there is no better choice than donphan. Then the stupid excadrill example. Excadrill has more offensive presence yes, but it has no bulk whats so ever, so if u need a bulky spinner neither excadrill nor starmie are an option. Excadrill might have more resistances on paper but most of them are of no importance. The most important among them probably beeing his flying resistance which doesnt help him in the least because all common users of flying type attacks (talonflame, mega pinsir, Starraptor) have coverage moves to ohko excadrill while donphan can stop every single one of them. On the other hand his weaknesses are against types that are EVERYWHERE!! Ground/Fighting/Fire are virtually all over the place.
And seriously what business does donphan have with rotom-w? Its a rapid spinner, hazard setter and physical tank. Rotom doesnt block rapid spin, doesnt remove hazards and attacks on the special side so what business do they have with each other? Exactly, none.
Some defoggers might rival Donphan on first sight, Skarmory for example. However, they are defoggers not rapid spinners. And defog has quite a few disadvantages over rapid spin that might keep ppl from using them. Bisharp and the removal of ur own hazards are the 2 most important.
Its true that donphan cant use all the moves it might want to have, but seriously it doesnt need all of them. If ur afraid of beeing setup fodder for sweepers, use roar. If u want to fuck up spinnblockers use knockoff, if u want to hit certain threats hard go for the corresponding coverage move. Also donphan doesnt care if it gets walled by certain threats because ITS NOT A SWEEPER. Aside from spinning and hazard setting the most donphan wants to do is to check/counter some physical threats. Teams with mostly special attackers are rare at the moment and even against such teams donphan can still do his 2 major jobs, setting up hazards and spinning. And while we are talking about sub par special bulk, excadrills isnt much better, the difference is so small it hardly matters in practise both get 1 shot by strong special attacks... oh wait, donphan has sturdy and cant be 1 shot like excadrill.