I'm going to have to go with Gen VI. When I see the Pokémon battling, it feels like I'm seeing them as they really are for the first time. It feels like the anime in the best possible way.
The Dutch Plumberjack said:Lol I'm still deciding whether I should vote for genII or genIV :X
Not bashing genVI though. The thing about graphics is they're relatively unimportant, therefore they just have to be pleasant and functional, and it's most important there are no eyesores about them - then it doesn't matter that much if you're playing on a NES or an HD gaming pc. Case in point is the (imo) monstrosity that is genV, where they tried to do more than the DS could handle, which resulted in (most notably) those horribly blurry back models. GenIV was done a lot better; they knew what the DS could do and rolled with it, which resulted in pleasant colours, pleasant sprites and whatever. Of course it's quite spartan compared to genVI, but that gen is on a 3DS rather than on the DS - if they had tried to make 3D models on the DS, it would've failed horribly.
(and tbqh, XY is not exactly ocarina of time 3D. sorry.)
I do agree that in the end, graphics don't really matter. And yeah, Gen V did bite a little more than they could chew.
I do disagree with that last statement. Mainly for two reasons:
1) The graphics in
Ocarina 3D and the graphics in
X and
Y were approached differently in style.
2)
Ocarina 3D had the advantage of taking a much smaller (and originally less detailed) world meant for the Nintendo 64 and updating the graphics for the 3DS.
X and
Y had to make models for 700+ Pokémon (including alternate forms and gender differences) complete with battle animations in addition to Kalos, various clothing for the characters, and cutscenes. That's a lot of stuff to put in there. And also to be fair,
Ocarina 3D still kept elements of Hyrule a little polygon-y (Hyrule Field's hills show this the worst, along with the "stairs" to Kakariko Village).
Sorry about that rant. I've put hundreds of hours into both games and I think they both look amazing.