bludz said:So this might be a little controversial but I wanna stir the pot. I've actually started to think that Mega Altaria is the "best" mega evolution in OU currently (I guess there are different ways to define this).
While Mega Metagross (the titleholder for a while now) has all it needs right from the start - fantastic stats, a great ability and great coverage, it really only has 2 sets with some different coverage options. It's a tank/sweeper/wallbreaker all rolled into one, but it's only an offensive mon really. That's not taking anything away from it - it has plenty of advantages over Altaria, particularly speed - however it you really only need to prepare for a few different variations of Metagross which is admittedly still quite difficult.
Mega Altaria can be many different things, and on top of that has one of the best defensive typings in the game and a great movepool. It checks (and can counter most of these threats if bulky) Zard X, Zard Y, Mega Gyarados, Latios, Garchomp, Mega Lopunny, Keldeo, Mega Sableye and that's only A+ rank in the viability rankings and up (er I threw in Mega Gyarados I guess). This actually relieves a major constraint when teambuilding since it usually takes 2-3 slots (if not more, heh) to check this range of pokemon, and on top of that Altaria is versatile enough to fit in with pretty much any team. Just as an additional note, the mixed wallbreaker set is quite underrated and has very few good switch-ins.
Anyway what are your guys' thoughts?
While I do agree that Altaria is one of the best mega evolutions in OU at the moment, I think that its true effectiveness doesn't really go past its defensive capabilities. That is to say that its offensive capabilities are not that great. I also believe that a strong contender for "best mega" at the moment is Mega Scizor.
There are a few reasons why Altaria's offensive presence is underwhelming at times. The main reason is that each set has plenty of checks/counters, and it is also not that hard to scout because it doesn't have the raw power to punish bad switchins (Return not 2hko'ing Chansey on the special set scout; Slowbro not taking too much from Hyper Voice). For the DD 2 atk set there is Slowbro, Ferrothorn, Skarmory, Scizor, Venusaur, Amoonguss, Unaware Clefable, and Talonflame. For the 3 atk Roost set there is Celebi, Jirachi, Chansey, Clefable, Venusaur, Mew, Slowking, and Talonflame. Both of these lack Heal Bell and thus lose a ton of the defensive capabilities that Altaria has otherwise. As for the mono attacking set pretty much any fairy resist walls it so I won't go into detail here. I definitely agree that its a defensive monster and an extremely useful support pokemon with Heal Bell, but it really is not that great of an offensive pokemon in this metagame.
Mega Scizor is a pokemon that truly fills multiple roles in just one team slot, and in general it is very viable in the current ORAS OU metagame. What really makes Scizor so good is that it has incredible bulk and a strong offensive presence at the same time. It doesn't even need to use different sets to achieve these multiple roles, as the bulky SD sets accomplish all of that. With natural bulk and investment it can wall a huge portion of the metagame, as many things that can't hit it super effectively fail to 2hko. It can wall pretty much any physical attacker with the impish set, can even wall some Thundurus and Raikou sets with spdef sets, and it also tears holes with the SD 3 atk set. In addition to all of this, it has access to U-turn and Defog which makes it a valuable support pokemon. Scizor can be a sweeper, wall, support mon, or all at the same time if it needs to.