Tagging
Slayer95, as I am being barred from placing Medichamite on Mawile, which is incorrect behavior.
MaestroDeSWAG said:In BH, Ates were limited in the way that they were because anything can run fakespeed. Here I'm fairly certain nothing can.
Only Pikachu and Raichu get both moves, and they can't have them at the same time.
MaestroDeSWAG said:Yeah, it is, however, I think you may have actually been right about losing water typing anyways. Though I definitely think it shouldn't, but whatever.
Ghoul King, I know it's a little late, but could we possibly readdress this? No mega evolution changes primary type, therefore neither should this. Primary type actually, as far as I know, is pretty much consistent in every evolutionary line even. It's not even just mega evolution, for the record, so, I feel like we can't say, "well, just because they haven't yet doesn't mean they won't," after 6 generations.
No.
thesecondbest said:Just ban atespeed. No need to ban dnite then. Linked added choiced clause instead of banning all scarf users, this would be smart too tbh.
That assumes Extreme Speed is the intrinsically unhealthy component of the meta. It also assumes that Dragonite is not, in fact, insanely versatile and powerful. It can validly run Pidgeotite, Blue Orb, Aggronite, Loppunite, Mewtonite X, and in all honesty probably various other Mega Stones like Banettite. It's not
just an impressive abuser of -ate Mega Stones.
Chopin Alkaninoff said:I understand that -atespeed is a problem, but I don't believe banning Espeed is the right solution. Espeed is fine and perfectly competitive, it's not Chatter broken. If Espeed is broken, we would've ban it from BH, STABmons or Inheritance (as I said in my previous post some pages ago).
I'd prefer if we discuss, -ate clause or something. Sure, you guys probably want banning espeed, but you'll be the first one to do so. If other metas doesn't ban espeed, why should MNM ban it? It means the move is fine. Only the abuser isn't.
An -ate clause isn't going to fix the problem. If you are restricted to one Pokémon with -ate, it'll be Dragonite sweeping teams still.
Talpr0ne said:Any reason why Galladite isn't D-Ranked? It is almost completely outclassed by Metagrossite, which gives greater overall bulk(slightly less physical, but more special bulk), more speed and effectively more attack factoring in Tough Claws.
252+ Atk Galladite Snorlax Return vs. 0 HP / 252 Def Sablenite Blissey: 220-259 (33.7 - 39.7%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
252+ Atk Tough Claws Metagrossite Snorlax Return vs. 0 HP / 252 Def Sablenite Blissey: 249-294 (38.2 - 45.1%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
Charizardite-Y should also be C-rank since it is basically a poor man's Red Orb, since it doesn't add Fire type, and generally Desolate Land>Drought. It isn't a "why would I ever consider this" situation like Alakazite, Galladite and Abomasite though. It can be paired with some Houndoominite Pokémon if you're feeling really gimmicky, and if you're already using a Red Orb it is a suitable substitute, unlike the D-Rank stones which are competing with multiple other Mega Stones.
Inner Focus is a great Fake Out stop, while Charizardite Y is
different from Red Orb, not flatly worse.
The council is still working through the Dragonite suspect and the question of what to do about Smeargle.