I got the game earlier this week and am up to chapter 15. I'm playing as a Fennekin with a Treecko partner. :)
Here is a smattering of my thoughts:
--
Having previously played
PMD: Blue and
Darkness before, (skipping over
Gates to Infinity), I appreciated how familiar the game's mechanics and AI were. The one thing that muscle memory has failed me was the inclusion of 'push' being the default behavior for moving onto a partner's square rather than swapping. That's led me to wasting a lot of Belly points.
--
I've heard that
PSMD was challenging, and, compared to the other two games, I'd have to agree. I wouldn't say it's
Nintendo Hard, though.
In general, there is a lot more strategy and planning involved. For instance, in the other
PMD games I've played (given that I skipped over
Gates), I could spam the default 'A' attack for most of a dungeon and save my PP for times that I really needed it. Now that the default A attack deals only 5 damage, I had to strategically manage the PP of my Pokemon's moves. No longer could I run through a dungeon without needing a single Elixir!
There's a lot more planning required for non-storyline dungeons, too! I was skeptical when the game gave me level 50+ Pokemon from missions when my team was barely level 20, but it seems the developers knew what they were doing. I could take those high-level Pokemon on a romp through a regular dungeon, but they would be inaccessible later if I wanted to clear a dungeon with a 'Super Difficult' difficulty, and those high-level Pokemon were pretty much needed to finish those missions.
--
I'm pretty far into the game's storyline, and I will say that it hasn't quite impressed me yet. Other people have said that the story is slow to start, and I definitely agree with that. The first half of the game's story was very saccharine. I mean, it brought a smile to my face, but it lacks the depth the other
PMD games played have. I appear to be at the 3/4ths mark and only now are tensions starting to increase!
Granted, this being a
PMD game, I am expecting some delicious twist where a Pokemon assumed to be malevolent is benevolent and vice versa. :P If that's the case though, it seems to really take its time.
--
The 'connections' system is
way more elegant than the old 'recruiting' one! There's no pressure to keep a Pokemon alive in a dungeon, and there's no need to manage recruit repeats. It appeals a lot more to the collector. :)
--
Some dribs and drabs:
- I really like being able to rename the protagonists and team--especially since the prompt for the team name was a little confusing to me.
- I hope I don't exhaust the left shoulder button on my 3DS like I did my right! @_@ I'm able to play the game with a broken right shoulder button, but I'm afraid the game will break my left one given how I need to press it for every attack.
- There was one instance where a Machoke used Seismic Toss and took out a Sandshrew that was on the dungeon floor (not my teammate), taking it out and evolving into Machamp from beating a fellow dungeon Pokemon. That was an interesting interaction of game mechanics.
- Do the decisions you make actually make a difference? I selected the option that my partner could be annoying at times, and that seemed to influence his behavior for the next day in the story.
- I squeed at the PMD: Red/Blue reference I got upon completing Ninetales's rescue mission. :D I know there are a lot more references out there, but this one was delightful.
Edit:
Spoilers
- Can certain 'unbeatable' bosses be beaten? Jirachi and Entei (first time) seemed exceedingly powerful (healing 160 health in two turns!?), and seem to require my characters being beaten for storyline reasons.
- Yep! Chapter 16, suddenly, everything's going amok! Twists, evil, and a huge increase in seriousness. :P Maybe a bit too jarring a change in mood. Let's see.
- Woah, you get the Legendary Beasts as tagalongs. :D Stuff is really intense now. But the ramp-up is a bit too sudden.
- Chapter 20: There we go! There's the double-crossing and plot twists I expect from PMD! I was expecting Nuzleaf to be controlled by Dark Matter, but now I'm not sure if it's really his own volition. :P
- Wow, everything after the Yveltal fight is pretty awesome. :D The soundtrack is impressing me! But it's rather narmy to see a Fennekin headbutting an opal sphere. The ending is very traditional of JRPG-style games, what with an Eldritch Abomination boss with multiple stages in space. Bring lots of Reviver Seeds!
Also, did anyone else notice the 'thank you' in the whiteness of the light after your character's partner strikes the true core of the Dark Matter?
Edit:
Okay! Credits have rolled, and I'll provide some non-spoilery comments. My characters were at level 27. I took my time, talking to everyone, exploring nooks in dungeons, doing as many missions as the storyline allowed me to fit. I like how the developers ended the main storyline! I've noticed in
Blue/
Darkness that the game was primarily about the player character, but it's nice to see the partner getting equal attention! I'm sure this'll be developed on in the post-game, though!
Hoopa is very useful to have in those solo dungeons. You can smuggle the Djinn Bottle in to get around the 'no teammates' clause!
Edit: Okay, now that I've had a day to get my thoughts in, I'd rate the game a solid 8.5/10. It satisfied my expectations, but there were parts I thought could be improved.