I'm gonna be totally honest, I was planning to drop the matter of ogre but I only feel obligated to respond because these are some of the worst arguments I've ever seen on a VR thread. I want to sort of apologize in advance, but also still go through with it because I can't just not respond to the ridiculous points. RANT BEGINS HERE
hexandwhy said:Uhh, how is MMX or Waterceus easier to justify on a team? Heck, I never see Waterceus.
They have far more unique niches than ogre
hexandwhy said:252 Atk Arceus Extreme Speed vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Kyogre: 135-160 (39.5 - 46.9%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
So it has about 38% chance to KO at +2 after SR and that's if kyogre is at full. Plus no boosted water spout. Sounds crappy to me.
hexandwhy said:I'd say that the damage isn't so bad, because it means that Kyogre can revenge kill at least two Arceus/Ray in a game, and that's nothing to scoff at.
?_? Do you know what revenge means? You have to come in after it's KOed something and take it out. With arceus that almost guarantees it's at +2, ogre can't beat that. It doesn't even KO after SR with origin pulse so at the very worst Arceus goes down and Ogre can't switch back in on SR (in a perfect 1v1 scenario where ogre doesnt miss and arceus doesnt get good rolls)
hexandwhy said:Geoxern can't set up on Kyogre, because it would take tons of damage from a STAB water move in rain.
Ogre cannot revenge it which is a scarfer's job. Plus it can take Origin Pulse after SR so if water spout is too weakened Xern can just Geo up and KO ogre. But yeah my point was how it fails to actually beat boosting sweepers
hexandwhy said:And if your team has no checks to both Arceus or Geoxern, you should probably revise your team.
Again, ignoring the point that ogre just kinda sucks against a good portion of the meta
hexandwhy said:I don't really see how MMX or Waterceus might do any better.
I almost quit here .-. they do totally different things than ogre, the difference is they do them way better
hexandwhy said:Gira-O = dies to Ice Beam.
Actually ice beam does half and at worst if all you can do is eq+sneak you only need slightly above average rolls so it cant switch back into SR. It was just an example of a water resist that can check ogre though, certainly not a reliable switch or anything.
hexandwhy said:I don't recall a team with Deo-A ever peaking the ladder, but it dies to e-speed so no big.
Why does it need to peak the ladder for it to be good? That's a total non sequitur. Anyway, it's just another example of something that can beat it. Plus, kyogre doesnt get Espeed and if you were seriously suggesting that Deo-A dying to a totally different Pokemon's extremespeed means it's irrelevant as a check to Kyogre then I suggest you reevaluate what you know about this game.
hexandwhy said:How does offensive Yveltal beat Kyogre? Life Orb Sucker Punch?
yes
hexandwhy said:"Zearom" takes a ton of damage from Ice Beam.
It also outspeeds and OHKOs. That's what a check does. What's the issue with this.
hexandwhy said:Blaziken is eww, and it dies to Origin Pulse/Surf, that any Kyogre should carry.
And it can outspeed and do a crapton. Just another thing to list.
hexandwhy said:Kyu kind of can be revenge killed by many other stuff, as 95 speed isn't god tier, and it doesn't have the best bulk ever.
"Primal Groudon can be revenge killed by other things that aren't Kyogre, 90 speed isn't god tier and it's weak to Earthquake. Therefore it isn't a Kyogre check" No seriously what this is so dumb
hexandwhy said:"...how worthless against Arceus spam." I think fainting at least two Arceus isn't bad.
In your unrealistic perfect scenario, sure
hexandwhy said:"...it needs its unreliable OHKO move to work..." Yeah, let's just drop down Klefki to B, shall we?
Yeah! Klefki doesnt have good defensive typing and prankster and 2 moves that work together to make you less likely to get an attack off than do nothing/hit yourself at all! Totally same thing as a 30% move that could make your scarfer useless!
hexandwhy said:And unreliable it may be, using a team of 6 Scarf Kyogres with Sheer Cold will probably net you more wins against people like HunterStorm, than most teams used by people of 1700 rating.
Well maybe this is true because ladder sucks and hunter is good. But the fact remains that unreliable strats like that aren't what you rank high. By your logic, Liepard should be S rank because full prankster swagger teams /could/ win if you get lucky.
hexandwhy said:Relying on hax also means that you can beat people who are more skill than you, if RNG serves you well. Relying on skill means that you lose if your less skilled, or your team has a bad match up.
This may very well be the worst quote of the lot, I shouldnt have to explain why, but oh well. Luck strats aren't what are considered more viable. Viability comes from trying to use good teams to win on skill. Luck is an entirely different plan, but the unreliability makes it less viable. This is why it's a viability ranking. Certain strats can work with luck, such as using sheer cold or klefki, but they're not reliable in the long run. Viability is determined by two good players of equal skill. We're talking good scenarios here, not "this is a good strat for shitty people". 6 Ogres or 6 quick claw walrein or whatever isn't reliable, isn't how we rank. Luck in cases such as this is not a boon.
hexandwhy said:And yeah, Groudon isn't on every team, and that's a good justification for its use.
It's still a very common S rank that has a massive impact on Kyogre's viability, why not list it?
hexandwhy said:If P-don was banned in AG, Scarf Ogre will probably be S Rank, or at least A+.
I doubt this very much but it's theorymon anyway so no good way to prove anything
hexandwhy said:It does show that Kyogre is cold countered by one Pokemon, but it's a revenge killer, what can you expect? It's supposed to clean up weakened mons, late game.
Yes, and I don't see how losing to a very common and good S rank could possible effect its viability. In fact, having a poor matchup versus every single S rank in the tier probably just goes to show how
manly it is, and we should rank it even higher.
hexandwhy said:Also,
252+ SpA Kyogre Ice Beam vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Primal Groudon: 131-155 (38.4 - 45.4%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
252+ SpA Kyogre Ice Beam vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Primal Groudon: 93-110 (23 - 27.2%) -- 55.8% chance to 4HKO
Groudon isn't that bulky, a few SR damage and it'd be scared of the 2HKO on the switch in.
Great! If I get this perfect scenario and predict right every time I can eventually break through it! I bet they don't have SR up either so I can still use full power water spout while I'm at it! Yes, Ogre gets through eventually, but the matchup still really sucks and in a competitive setting the Pdon user can capitalize on that. Prediction goes both ways
RANT OVER
Drayden8437 said:I'll just say that quite some pokemon stated by you aren't even used towards the higher ladder, those are : Zekrom, Scarf Kyu-W, Blaziken (Blaziken doesn't outspeed with the speed boost unless jolly). The common ones (except CM Arceus Formes, they lose 1v1 however) such as Ekiller, Physical Arceus Formes, Gira-O, M-Ray are all either checked or countered by Yveltal (Lugia stalls out everything ~LLW). And that is quite reasonable for a mon in B+. Also, Geo Xern can't quite set-up on Scarf-Ogre, if you were talking about using geo on the switch-in, that's another case all together.
I agree that it doesn't do too well against Ekiller Spam teams and will be able to take out only one Arceus. B-but everything has its limitations.
[252+ SpA Kyogre Origin Pulse vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Arceus in Rain: 282-333 (74 - 87.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO]
I don't have much to say in response to this since it isn't incredibly stupid, but high ladder doesnt equate to viability, nothing I listed was below B rank with the exception of the C+ Blaziken. The fact that all the mons lose to Yveltal kinda helps but still doesn't mean that they're any worse checks to ogre (oh and also most of those don't really lose to yveltal like KyuW and Zekrom and arceus if it's offensive yveltal). And idk that it's taking out one arceus fsr, it has a good chance to die to 2/+2 after sr and can't deal with boosted arc at all making it a liability in general
Also, I didn't even list all the ogre checks, there's also Latios/as, Dialga, Palkia, regular Tina, Lugia (full health can stall with multiscale), Skymin, and Ditto. C+ and up. These are not reliable switch-ins, most lack recovery, and with the proper coverage Ogre can do well against them. But once it's locked in these are all totally acceptable checks that are only serving to prove that ogre is not too hard to check offensively. All of this being said I wouldn't mind a simple drop to B where ogre would fit in much better than it does in B+. I'm not overly concerned with its ranking. But that post triggered me.
Sorry for taking up so much of this thread with what I thought was a fairly obvious nomination (I mean not that there aren't good arguments for ogre, just that those weren't it)