vonFiedler said:Oh, I forgot, video game storytelling is all about collecting audio logs now. Forget creating a gripping atmosphere and stringing the player along with intrigue, or the rising tension leading up to said plot twist. No, clearly the better half of the game is the one where badly modeled npcs exposit the whole plot then send you on just as many fetch quests only this time with no more plot, nothing interesting to learn, and no more fascinating characters.
Anyway, I think at this point it's clear that we got a fundamentally different experience from the game- you talk of all this mystery, intrigue and discovering new things- this was a complete non-factor for me, and consequently I found the first half of the game to be an ocean of tedium. I played this game expecting the same kind of experience that I would get out of a classic novel- where the situations that arise in the narrative challenge me to contemplate various concepts in new ways. This experience is met in the later stages because the fact that you have a decent idea of Rapture's story gives you a more complex and nuanced pool of content to think about, and the game is imo effective in pushing you into exploring these ideas. Also idk how you can say there's no plot or nothing to learn when you have the main character changing in a very significant way and off the top of my head you learn about the power struggle that went on in Rapture, something that is only barely touched on in the first half of the game
vonFiedler said:You're "reflecting" on the events of the first half because the interesting collection of story bits becomes a cohesive whole right at the halfway point (and then dries up). Arguing that the second half is better for this is like arguing that reading sparknotes is better than reading the actual book.
As I mentioned above, you're seriously misrepresenting the game by saying there's nothing new in the second half of the game, there's a
lot of interesting new content to be found. As for the whole reflections thing, first of all no I'm not reflecting because there's nothing more to learn, that is objectively false and I just gave you an example why, it's because as the game progresses into its later stages I'm more and more able to engage in this reflection due to their being more content available to me. As for your sparknotes analogy, that's a shitty analogy and you know it. I mean just look at some of the novels listed in your signature for instance. It takes all of 5 minutes to come up with a couple good reasons why Brave New World is better off being fiction and not an essay- you could even write an essay discussing this if you like irony flavoured tedium, that seems like a
relatively easy essay to write. But I'm sure you'd agree that that novel's strength lies in the "reflection" it provokes
vonFiedler said:Fuck, googling "2nd half of bioshock" turned up more than one result bitching about it. I hadn't even really considered that given the statement the twist makes about game players blindly following linear orders, the 2nd half has the newly awakened protagonist still blindly following linear orders.
yeah fair enough