Q10jj34eeDnK said:My Nominations:
Azumarill: A+ to S
Belly Drum sets are a nightmare. It makes it one of the best, if not THE best setup sweeper in the metagame. Because of Aqua Jet, it kills a lot of the metagame too. It doesn't have many flaws at all and is great if you need a good offensive partner.
Bisharp A+ to S
It's by far the best revenge killer in the tier. It's able to kill almost the entire metagame if played right. Not only that, but it's also the meta's best Pursuit trapper, and a great Swords Dance sweeper too.
Ferrothorn A+ to S
Ferrothorn is definitely the best Stealth Rock setter in the game. It has an excellent defensive typing, excellent defensive stats, and it has Iron Barbs. Because of its low Speed and high Attack, Gyro Ball hits incredibly hard too.It tanks many things in the metagame and is a good option for almost any team.
Landorus-Therian A+ to S
It's maintained the most used Pokemon in the metagame for the past few months, and for good reasons too. Choice Scarf sets are devastating, it's an excellent Swords Dance attacker, and it's a very good Stealth Rock setter. 145 Attack is also amazing and if you combine that with either Choice Scarf or Swords Dance, it's a monster. It also has good coverage and it works well with VoltTurn cores.
Weavile A to A-
Compared to other sweepers in the metagame such as Landorus-Therian, Talonflame, Garchomp, and Mega Lopunny, Weavile just isn't that great. It's flaws are just too crippling to make it A. It gets walled pretty easily, and its frailty makes it super hard to use. 4x weakness to Fighting and Stealth Rock weakness isn't doing it any favors either.
Garchomp-Mega B to B+
Why is this so low? It has excellent defenses, a good typing, and it's a good Stealth Rock setter. It's also a good Swords Dance sweeper, and even without Swords Dance, it hits incredibly hard. Also, it's one of the best stallbreakers in the meta too.
Okay, while some of these have a leg to stand on, most of your nominations are seriously lacking in value. I'd first like to say that from what I've observed, Azumarill's best set is choice band. While belly drum is not bad by any stretch, it can't reliably sweep unless all faster water resists are removed, and even then, fat, fast pokemon such as tankchomp can eat an aqua jet and usually KO back if Azumarill has taken some damage while setting up, which between BD recoil and just plain attacks it usually will have. Bisharp, while obviously an extremely potent force in the metagame, is still shut down by what is arguably the best offensive mon in the tier, Keldeo, and struggles to set up consistently with the abundance of bulky ground types in OU. Sucker Punch causes way to many mind games for Bisharp to be considered the "best revenge killer in the tier"
Your ferrothorn nomination is, in my opinion, easily the most flawed out of this bunch. Ferrothorn is obviously an important and good hazard setter in OU, but it being the "best" would imply that ferrothorn is definitively better than other hazard setters such as Heatran, Landorus-T, garchomp, and skarmory, which is debateable in the case of most of these and outright false in the case of others. Despite generally being a solid answer to bulky waters, it fails to stop keldeo, unlike celebi and amoongus, and is also horribly crippled by burns. Furthermore, lack of reliable recover also is a major downer that keeps ferrothorn from switching into threats like Kyu-B and Latios reliably. On a related note, those same dragons can simply run HP fire and quickly run through ferrothorn is one or two hits. No, ferrothorn is definitely not S rank material and likely won't be unless fire type moves become much less common.
Your last three nominations, while not being as "out there" as the first three are still horribly short and are rather poor arguments, especially in the case of Weavile, which still remains a very potent threat due to its ability to easily run through Garchom and Lando-T, some of the most common pokemon in the metagame. I suggest you try to do more upper level play before brazenly suggesting that certain pokemon are bettor or worse than they really are and refuting the knowledge of upper level contributors and players.
Edit: Bisharp is not the best Pursuit trapper in the tier. In fact, it's not really that good at all when it comes to trapping because some psychics, like alakazam and starmie, can outspeed and easily OHKO it. Weavile and Choice Scarf or Band Tyranitar are generally better options overall.