HumbleSpaceMan said:I actually haven't met a lot of chatot's while playing on showdown and I've always won when playing against them so I don't think it's even close to being a huge threat and as you mentioned 123 Spa is mediocre at best. But the fact remains that Chatot will pretty much always fire off a Chatter.
Again as you mentioned Machole has DP but it's much slower even with as scarf, anyways ghost's are kinda mandatory with all the normal spam. Other mons like Confuse Ray mons(lol) can be taunted. Chatot however always gets a confusion in. Sub+Lefties sets can just wait for you to hit yourself, then roost the damage. If you don't have a faster pokemon at that point of time and no strong priority, then the match depends purely on luck. Which is imo uncompetitive.
To repeat Chatot is in no way broken. It has several counters and it's stats aren't great. But it can end up being uncompetitive especially with t-wave or sticky web support.
As it happens, scarf Machamp is 1 speed slower (still oustpeeding Arceus by 1 point, which is nice because), while machoke has 70 extra speed with a scarf. Not all confuse Ray can be taunted, either- magic bounce does exist, although that has a ton more opportunity cost because you aren't dealing damage at the same time.
As far as strong priority goes, however, on most offense that is pretty much required, and stall can afford to run blissey, which takes about 0 from confusion damage or uninvested chatter (you aren't running sub+roost on a set with nasty plot), while regenvests like Slowking can pivot in and out basically for free.
That's not even getting into the king of TS stall, mr mime.
To me, uncompetitive is a decent argument, but one I'm not sure is valid. For instance, confusion has only a 50% chance of immobilizing you, while serene grace shaymin-s has a 60% chance on a similarly powered attack. Not only that, but shaymin-sky is also faster, has leech seed for subseed, and can fit its main attack and boosting into one slot (seed flare), but isn't even close to banworthy. The best chatot set is probably sub plot chatter boomburst, which is an excellent stall breaker and not much else. Notably, offense destroys it, which in an ubers based metagame is huge.