Welcome, ladies and gentlemen, to Scarf Critiques OM Submissions, the critically acclaimed TV show you've never heard of (coming to your TV screens soon)! It's your host SW, the host with the most, the man with the plan here to run us through our contestant's concepts! The participants with the best ideas wins the prestigious honor of having their concept realised as a fully-fledged OM!* So let's waste no more time and get started.
*(May or may not be true)
Our first concept is actually 3 grouped into one package. There's gmfc's MnM AG, insaneguy1083's MnM BH and, last but not least, HeatEdgeSword's MnM Doubles! Let's first familiarize ourselves with these 3 Mix & Mega-themed metas:
gmfc said:Mix and Mega
ANYthingMON GOES
An off-shoot of Mix and Mega BH, MnM AMG allows players to use any pokemon in the current teambuilder, while still keeping true to what makes MnM popular. This essentially gives any mon the option to hold a mega stone, without the option of changing the pre-mega's ability, moveset, or having maximum EVs like in BH. This potentially includes megas for: ubers, unreleased mons, non-fully evolved mons, post-mega forms, post primal-forms, Ultra Necrozma, and any other form changes that exist due to in-match effects.
Examples:
Potential Threats:
1)Mega Rayquaza: Dragon Ascent, Pinsirite, Salamencite, Altarianite, Lucarionite, Red Orb
- The King of Megas, Mega Rayquaza could possibly retain his crown; having access to Dragon Ascent allows him to mega and still hold an item, while Pinsirite, Salamencite, and Altarianite would make him the premier espeeder. Although, if Espeed spam isn't your cup of tea, Lucarionite/Red Orb would make D.A./V-Create two of the hardest hitting STABs in the meta.
2) Primal Groudon/Kyogre: Lucarionite, Primal Orbs, Choice Items
- Of course, Primal Groudon and Primal Kyogre can run Lucarionite/Red Orb/Blue Orb and hit harder than before, however the main side effect of allowing any and every mon, is that they also aren't required to run a mega stone. Case in point, Porge is able to use it's Scarf+Water Spout set from ubers with Primodial Sea, while Pdon could run Rest and Chesto Berry due to his lack of recovery.
3) Zygarde-Complete: Sablenite, Aggronite, Lucarionite
- If MRay is the King of Megas, then Zygarde-C is undoubtedly the King of Bulk. There isn't much else to explain, Sablenite makes him one of the bulkiest mons in the meta, while Aggronite turns him into a defense stallworth with a much better typing to sport; and if bulky offensive is more your style, Lucarionite should suffice.
4) Arceus: Altarianite, Pinsirite, Primal Orbs, Diancite, Lucarionite, Lopunnite, Sablenite, Plates
- Last but not least, perhaps the most versatile mon in Ubers, Arceus continues the trend by being viable with virtually every mega stone. He can espeed spam; he can run both bulky and hyper offensive sets to perfection; he fits like a glove on any stall team; and because his formes are hardcoded for multitype, he can use a bit of trickery to turn the tides of a battle.
Potential Clauses and Bans:
1) Clauses: At the moment, things would still lean closer to MnM/Ubers rather than say Anything Goes or Balanced Hackmons
- Ubers Clauses
- Mega Stone/Orb Clause (only one of each stone on a team)
2) Bans: Again, leaning closer to MnM with a few exceptions
- Baton Pass, Shadow Tag
- Beedrillite, Gengarite, Kangaskhanite, Mawilite, Medichamite
- No Pokemon at the moment
3) Unbans
- Electricify: Heliolisk itself may not be good
- Blazikenite: I feel as though this stone needs to be tested, quickbanning if deemed broken
- Pidgeotite: Interested to see how potent this stone can be, suspect test worthy
- Mega Rayquaza: While the power creep may lessen his impact, this is still MRay afterall, he could be a threat even without a stone. Suspect Test worthy.
Questions for the Community:
1) Is MnMAMG a good name?
2) Any potential threats that I missed?
3) Should Mega Rayquaza be rebanned?
4) Should the meta lean towards Mix and Mega, Balanced Hackmons, or Anything Goes? (In the sense of banning philosophy)
5) Should banned stones be allowed on their native users? (e.i. Mega Kangaskhan holding Kangaskhanite)
Thanks for your time!
insaneguy1083 said:Mix and Mega Balanced Hackmons
Metagame premise:
All Pokemon (regardless of forme) can Mega Evolve and use most moves they usually don't get. Basically a mashup of Mix and Mega and Balanced Hackmons (duh).
Potential bans and threats:
Primal Groudon has proven once again to be too powerful for the playing environment, and as such has been banned from Mega Evolving (unless being a Red Orb Groudon) in my preliminary MnM BH banlist.
Aggronite Zygarde-Complete, after calculations, has shown that its tremendous bulk combined with stellar typing makes it so that even super effective hits from powerful Pokemon (such as Lucarionite Mewtwo-Mega-X or Lucarionite Primal Groudon) cannot OHKO it unboosted, and in general is too bulky (complex ban, because regular Zygarde-Complete is far from broken and sets like Sablenite can be beaten by things like Glalitite Boomburst coming from Kyurem-White), and as such has been banned.
This also follows the Balanced Hackmons (and to an extent Mix and Mega) banlist, so Psychic Surge, Shadow Tag, Gengarite, Mawilite, Medichamite, and Beedrillite has been banned, however Blazikenite was unbanned, due to Speed Boost being somewhat bad even in Balanced Hackmons, and the existence of Spectral Thief as well as Prankster Haze. All Pokemon banned from Mega Evolving in regular Mix and Mega have been unbanned from using stones.
No Pokemon other than Primal Groudon is banned from Mega Evolving, though Gyaradosite Regigigas after testing has shown to be a great threat and a possible suspect is in order.
Questions for the community:
Is it boring and stale at the moment due to everything viable being either very bulky or very hard-hitting?
Has Unaware, Fur Coat as well as RegenVest (Regenerator + Assault Vest) lost their niche?
Will we see some previously rarely used Pokemon get some new usage?
What Pokemon that is viable in regular MnM is still viable here?
Is this mashup OM "too broken" per say?
Will pre-Mega abilities be a key part of teambuilding in MnM BH?
Should Gengarite be unbanned or is trapping still too much for now?
At the moment, different Arceus formes can Mega Evolve and retain their assigned typing, for example, Lucarionite Arceus-Ghost is Ghost type instead of pre-Mega where it is Normal type. (Due to a bug on ROM, which has not been fixed yet.) Should it be kept as a feature or removed as a bug? Does it make the metagame more fun?
HeatEdgeSword said:Mix and Mega Doubles
(I'm entirely aware that mashup om can't be accepted and it's available in ROM (which still follows Mix and Mega clause), so take this as an echo ban list change proposal if you will.)
Metagame premise: Almost every Pokemon can mega evolve with almost every mega stones (or orbs) with the usual limit of one Mega Evolution removed, now in Doubles (Ubers) format!
Clauses: Doubles Ubers clause (Meaning Dark Void is banned while Mega Rayquaza and Baton Pass are allowed), Mega Stone / Orb Clause (only one of each stone on a team)
Banned Stones: Beedrillite, Blazikenite, Gengarite, Kangaskhanite, Mawilite, Medichamite, Pidgeotite
Pokemon that can't Mega Evolve: Arceus, Deoxys-A, Deoxys-N, Dialga, Giratina, Groudon*, Ho-Oh, Kyogre*, Kyurem-Black, Kyurem-White, Lugia, Lunala, Marshadow, Mewtwo*, Necrozma-Dawn-Wings*, Necrozma-Dusk-Mane*, Palkia, Rayquaza*, Regigigas, Reshiram, Slaking, Solgaleo, Xerneas, Yveltal, Zekrom, Zygarde with Power Construct.
* indicates that this Pokémon is still permitted to hold native Mega Stones.
Potential Bans and threats:
Magearna is easily one of the best Pokemon in Doubles Ubers thanks to Soul-Heart, which boosts its Sp. Attack every time a Pokemon faints. With more Pokemon in the field, it’s much easier for Soul-Heart to activate. Also, Trick Room can solve its speed issue while supporting other slower Pokemon. An experienced player definitely will not let Magearna Mega Evolve first in Mix and Mega Doubles so it can rack up the boosts from Soul-Heart, and then mega evolve for more firepower after obtaining enough boosts.
While I would disallow Magearna from mega evolving, I decided it would better to see it in action first before taking any action.
Red Orb and
Blue Orb are even better in MNM Doubles as they now can support partner with the primal weather. Again, it’s better off seeing them in action first before doing something.
Jirachi serves as a redirector in Doubles, it can safety scout setup sweepers such as Zygarde and Xerneas with Follow Me. With the help of the mega stones, it gives Jirachi more bulk and even changes its type… at the cost of Serene Grace and berry recovery. Still, it’s definitely something that should be approached with caution.
Unbans in MNM Doubles:
Electrify only affects one Pokemon at a time and there’s only one mega stone with an Electric-type immunity ability, making the move far more tolerable there.
Shadow Tag is unbanned as the main users, Mega Gengar and Gothitelle are far more manageable in Doubles Ubers. Which also means Gengar can mega evolve with Gengarite there.
One of
Deoxys Speed’s main appeal is setting up entry hazards. However, the demand of entry hazards isn’t exactly high in Doubles, so it’s permitted to mega evolve in Mix and Mega Doubles. Helps that the main culprit that's unrelated to entry hazards, Pidgeotite is still banned.
One thing that makes
Dragonite busted in Mix and Mega is Multiscale. Since it can be double targeted, therefore making it much easier to deal with in MNM Doubles, Dragonite is permitted from mega evolving… and it’s better off mega evolve as soon as possible.
Pheromosa isn’t particularly threatening in Doubles, so it’s allowed to mega evolve. Even with some astonishing benefits, doubt that it will be banned from mega evolving in the future.
And in case you miss it,
Mega Rayquaza is allowed in Mix and Mega Doubles due to following the Doubles Ubers clause.
Questions about the community:
What else would you like to add? Should restricted mega stones like Blazikenite be unbanned? Do you think it's a good idea to permit Slaking and Regigigas from mega evolving there?
After some thought, here's what I had to say:
these 3 collectively share the problem of being a mash up OM so right off the bat they would be rejected, but im sure people already know that. In the case of the first two though, there are a host of other issues such as them being near-impossible to balance. As metas like Shared Power have taught us when everything is so dangerously powerful achieving true balance is like a pipe dream. Then there's also what QT mentioned earlier, how at times they go against the rules of the metas its created from. In MnM AG's case thats allowing things like Ash Greninja mega evolve and in MnM BH's case its how Arceus is handled.
My rating: BAN/10
--
Not looking good so far... Let's see if our next contestant can wow the crowd with their idea:
Cloud9 NxtLvl said:Eh, why not?
Random Typemons~
Metagame premise: A pokemon's typing is randomly switched each turn depending on the moves the user has. For Example, if a Mega Sableye had Knock Off, Will-o-Wisp, Recover and Toxic, it's typing could be changed to either Poison/Fire, Dark/Fire, Dark/Normal, etc, on the next turn of play, and is consistently randomized until the user switches out or the match is ended. However, a pokemon will always start off in its original typing whenever it is brought in for its first complete turn.
Potential bans: OU clause would apply; there will be additional bans of Mawilite, Medichamite, Tapu Lele and Kartana for their incredible base power and powerful coverage options that can work with any move they run. Protean may also be banned for now until we figure out how it would work with the type randomization.
Threats:
Kyurem-Black: Being an amazing wallbreaker with amazing coverage moves on both the physical and special spectrum, as well as a reliable recovery might just push Kyurem-Black over the edge at first.
Ash-Greninja: Choice Specs plus its standard 4mss is still incredible to utilize as a wallbreaker and revenge killer, but changing typings out of the move it's locked into may help the opponent.
Chansey: Chansey is already an amazing special wall in its own right, and the addition of an extra defensive typing like water and poison could be the centerpoint of stall archetypes in this meta.
Celesteela: Celesteela also has incredible defensive utility in its base typing, and having Protect to stall a turn out may change its typing to a way that it would be harder to kill in this meta; escaping Magnet Pull Magnezone for instance.
Questions for the community:
How would this affect pokemon that change typing upon Mega Evolution? (Mega Pinsir, Mega Gyarados?)
Would stall become too much for this metagame?
How would you want Protean to work with the type changes?
Their feedback was:
While it's a unique idea, my biggest qualm about this is the RNG part of it. Introducing yet another luck factor would suck for a competitive format as it takes less control away from the players, and ultimately have a bigger hand in which player wins, disregarding skill. I was thinking maybe have the type you change into be controlled in some way by the player (EG. have a higher chance of transforming into the type of any moves they've used in the past or something). This sort of reminds me of
Protean Palace from last gen. Perhaps think about taking that over? You have a sort of similar concept here.
My rating: COULD BE GOOD WITH SOME IMPROVEMENTS/10
--
Things are looking up for our contestants. Perhaps Tuthur1's upcoming pitch can impress our otherwise unwavering host?
Tuthur1 said:First of all sorry for my bad english.
Shedmon
Metagame Premise: Every Pokémon has only one HP and a second ability which is Wonder Guard.
Bans:
- Safety Goggles because they make Sturdy and Magic Bounce broken, as well as invalidating weather teams.
- Focus Sash, Protect, Detect, Spiky Shield, King's Shield, Baneful Bunker, Mat Block and Endure because they allow you to scoot for your opponents moveset and will prevent bait and lure which are the key of this metagame.
- Confuse Ray (and all Confuse inducing moves) because they are basically OHKO-moves in this metagame.
- Mold Breaker, Teravolt, Turboblaze, Photo Geyser, Moongeist Beam, Sunsteel Strike and Core Enforcer because they invalidates Wonder Guard which is the center of this metagame and will make every game decide on a speed tie between 2 Choice Scarf Basculin.
- Stealth Rock, Spikes and Toxic Spikes are obviously banned since they kill you upon switch-in.
Potential Bans:
- Sturdy and Overcoat are 2 of the best abilities in this metagame. Depending of which ability Forretress has, it has different counters and check. Moreover it has only one weakness and immunity to Poison and Sandstorm. It has access to Sandstorm as well as moves to hit almost every Pokémon immuned to Sandstorm (Struggle Bug for Zam, Flash Canon for Clef, Bulldoze for Groudon, Hidden Power [Water] for Heatran, Gliscor and Tyranitar, Hidden Power [Fire] for Aboma, Ninetales, Ferro, Steela Mamo and Snowslash, and Rock Slide for Mandibuzz, Rayquaza and Sigilyph). The only Pokémon it can't touch are Lickilicky, Golduck, Drampa and Kyogre, which can't also beat it if it's a Sturdy-version.
- Skarmory is a worst Foretress but still good.
- Magic Bounce is one of the best Abilities in this metagame, moreover Sableye only has one weakness: Fairy. Fairy coverage is really rare because there is no hidden power fairy. The best way to deal with Sableye-Mega is weather which has a lot of counters in Overcoat, Mamoswine, Sandslash-Alola, Magic Guard, Primal Groudon and Kyogre).
- Thanks to its wonderful ability in Magic Guard and 2 unusual weaknesses in Poison and Steel, Clefable is a centralizing Pokémon which needs dedicates check. However it struggles to hit every Pokémon it is suppose to beat in one set.
Unbans:
- OHKO moves since every move is already an OHKO-moves.
- Ubers and Mega-Rayquaza
- Baton Pass
Potential Threats:
- Sandstream and Snow Warning
- Leech Seed
- Toxic
- Corrosion
- Will-O-Wisp
- Pokémon with immunities to common strategies (Mamoswine, Sandslash-Alola, Magic Guard, Magic Bounce, Overcoat, Poison Heal, Cloud Nine, Primal Weather, ...)
- Magnet Pull (removes a lot of immunities to Sandstorm and Toxic)
- Sturdy
Questions for the community: What do you think should be banned or unbanned ? Will this meta be fun ?
Without any hesitation, I immediately responded with:
To quote the commonly rejected metas list:
- I Sure Love Ability X: All/Some Pokemon get X ability over their normal abilities. Metas where X = Poison Heal/WonderGuard/Prankster have been rejected.
Allowing mons to retain their original ability also wouldn't save this IMO since it'd create situations where certain Pokemon with enough unique traits would warp the meta (like Forry).
My rating: ANOTHER BAN/10
--
Another post bites the dust. Let's hope our next user stands more of a chance:
icecat said:Rule Break
Metagame premise:
You follow the OU banlist, except you are allowed to break a rule clause once.
1. If you break a clause that includes a banned ability or move, you can only have one copy of that ability or move, but you can use it repeatedly. The pokemon with the banned ability or move must be nicknamed whatever the banned ability or move is.
2. If you break the no uber clause, you can have one uber pokemon only if its uber usage statistic is under 3.41% (the threshold for UU). Same applies for mega pokemon that are uber.
3. If you break sleep clause, you can cause up to two of your opponent's pokemon to sleep at the same time instead of one, and all you pokemon with a sleep inducing move must be nicknamed "Sleep" in order for it to put a second pokemon to sleep.
4. If you break species clause, you are allowed any number of duplicate pokemon.
Pokemon that aren't breaking rules can't have nicknames.
Potential bans:
1. OU banlist (minus the one exception)
2. Endless battle clause
Potential threats (but you only get one):
Low usage Ubers: Palkia, Lunala, Blaziken, Zekrom, Mewtwo, Landorus, Solgaleo, Deoxys-D, Reshiram
Trapping abilities: Dugtrio, Gothitelle, Wobbuffet
Moody: Bibarel, Glalie, Octillery
Baton Passers: Scolipede, Smeargle
Double Sleepers: Amoonguss, Breloom, Smeargle
Minimizers: Clefable, Muk-Alola
OHKO users: Gliscor, Suicune, Nidoking, Mamoswine
Questions for the community:
Is this too close to OU?
Does this sound fun to play?
Are the different rule breaks balanced enough?
My response was:
This sounds like a pain to successfully code and sort of unfun to play if you ask me. The reason why a bunch of these rules are set in place is because they introduce uncompetitive aspects into the game. Like Moody, what's fun about praying to get evasion boosts? Same for OHKO moves, Minimize, BP, STAG, Arena Trap and sleep moves. The only rule that doesn't sound unfun to break would be the Uber one, but then it'd just be a budget Follow the Leader / Godly Gift. In short, I agree with DrPumpkinz above (in retrospect I just copied what they said, rip).
My rating: KEEP OU CLAUSES/10
--
And there it is, folks! Unfortunately many of our contestants today are heading home empty-handed... But don't let our host put you off! Continue to submit and there's a chance we'll review your concept! Tune in to Scarf Critiques OM Submissions every week*! Until next time, stay safe and godspeed!
*(Definitely won't be every week)