Turns out I'm posting this update exactly a year after starting this thread, convenient how that works out.
Changes are kinda light on this update though, I think that's a first here. In cases with a closer vote, the actual arguments given were taken into consideration since not everyone was able to elaborate on their votes, though this ultimately did not shift the vote in most cases. There is one slightly preemptive change I'm making though, namely Kommo-o, since a number of us feel the nominated C rank is actually too low for it. Feel free to nominate it down if you disagree, though try to avoid nominating on other stuff that was just voted on this round unless you have a
really good argument for it. Otherwise if I've made a mistake or something looks wrong, feel free to let me know!
We also didn't split the C rank this time because we don't think it's large enough to justify splitting a rank for ultimately niche Pokemon. However, there are some of the VR council who are in agreement for splitting it so if there's enough support for it we'll consider reworking C rank in the next vote.
Hippowdon: A -> A+
Hide
cant say: agree. this is basically meta defining atm
chemcoop: Agree, Hippo is a meta game defining mon that forces you to run super effective z-moves or give up a moveslot on something like Thundy-T to taunt lead Hippo. A+
DragonWhale: A+
greilmercenary9: Probably the best dedicated supporter in the entire meta with the bulk to check many different types of attackers depending on the specific spread. It can also choose to give up some utility to run Ice Fang, which makes it more of a wall than a supporter but also means that it can 1v1 more than half of the top 15 mons depending on the set. Easily A+ material. Don't leave home without a Hippo check.
NOVED: this is kinda tough for me. i dont think hippo is really that much better than A rank, but it is a incredibly strong start for offense teams. you need a good plan to deal with this on every team or else you just get tossed around. A+ seems fine.
Psynergy: This was my nomination but I don't think there's anything more I can add to this anyway. This is long overdue, Hippowdon is everywhere and it's just such a reliable Stealth Rock setter in a meta with so many powerful cleaners.
Solerme: Solid answer to high ranked mons such as MMence, MBlazi, CharX. Great support for the team. Yeah A+
Theorymon: Yeah
Mega Kangaskhan: A -> A-
Hide
cant say: disagree. i don't know if it's because I use kang-weak teams or I run into kang weak teams when I use it, but I think it's still super strong
chemcoop: Stay A. Kinda blows through balance with a combo of PuP/Return/Fire Punch/EQ. Not as strong as it was in ORAS obviously, but still a strong breaker with solid bulk and coverage. Also provides a great support role for other mons with paralysis options in Secret Power and Rock Tomb for speed control.
DragonWhale: A
greilmercenary9: This might be the toughest call this time IMO. However, I agree with SoLerme that there is a tendency to swing the pendulum a bit too far based on how things have most recently changed, and Kangaskhan, while not being what it was in ORAS, is still a huge threat. The biggest problem Kangaskhan has in USUM is that it no longer has the initial power to be really elite at being both anti-offense and anti-defense at the same time: AoA sets really miss the power that this thing had in 6th gen when focusing on coverage and priority over boosting, while PuP sets can still blast through walls efficiently but are very hard hit by 7th gen's less effective Sucker Punch and base 100 speed continuing to look less impressive, especially when going full speed means not investing in Kangaskhan's solid bulk. Each has 4MSS since Kangaskhan has a solid movepool, too. Despite this, it can still operate effectively in both roles; it can be hard to tell which set the opponent is running in Team Preview, and the coverage is wide enough to tech fairly efficiently to suit your team. PuP sets are probably the most defining and the best set IMO, but looking at the A and A- tiers as currently constructed, I still think Kangaskhan is a bigger threat (especially at Team Preview) than anything in A- and is on par with a lot of stuff in A. I do think the two other A megas (Metagross and Mawile) are better in this meta, but Kangaskhan is no slouch.
NOVED: I havent used or seen enough of this in the current gen to really make a solid call, but that probably says something in itself. i do think mega kang has a lot more potential than ppl give it credit for but A- is probably a fine fit.
Psynergy: Also my nom, I realize I may be underrating Mega Kangaskhan but I'm just not a fan of its current ranking. It's a great mon, I've got no issues with that, but I don't feel it holds up as well for an A rank threat.
Solerme: It needs more support and it's obviously not as broken as it was, but it's still strong and worth a spot in the As imo. I think that there is a bias that makes it seem less strong since it was so strong before, but i don't really feel like putting this mon that has a huge (like really huge) movepool, two priorities, good stats and a fantastic ability (well one and a half if we consider scrappie) with other A- mons.
Theorymon: Sure, A-
Primarina: A- -> B+
Hide
cant say: agree. not much reason to use this over fini outside perish song and/or torrent z move + jet
chemcoop: Inferior Fini at this point in the metagame. Still sees usage on TR builds, but otherwise Fini is definitely the better special Water/Fairy. B+
DragonWhale: B+
greilmercenary9: Primarina isn't a bad mon, but Tapu Fini is significantly more versatile/splashable, and as a result Prima is becoming more reliant on TR to stand out (as others have mentioned previously). The rise of Torrent Gren has hurt it as well, since Gren's much higher speed means it's much easier to reliably fire off attacks, especially when in Torrent range. Even Azumarill, which has fallen in usage throughout 7th gen (for good reason), can give it nominal competition for a slot since it is somewhat less predictable and tends to do better against some top threats due to more power on its priority (and is even slower for TR, too). Prima can still be very effective with the proper support, but it doesn't have the self-sufficiency of other A- mons or such devastating power when given TR help (like a Mawile) to make it a juggernaut.
NOVED: ik its usage has fallen off but i dont think this thing is necessarily that much worse in the current meta than it was before. i still think the extra power and better ability at dealing with gliscor is still valuable enough to keep it A-. fini is very often better on a team than this but i think prim will come up in metas that might call for it, especially in a tour environment where can get a feel for what your opp may bring and prims niches can shine more often.
Psynergy: I don't need to reiterate why I'm not a huge fan of Primarina I hope. I have not seen this much lately and I think that's for good reason, its niche just isn't super desirable at the moment.
Solerme: Yeah, Fini has taken over it. I'm good with B+
Theorymon: Sure, B+
Rotom-H: B+ -> A-
Hide
cant say: agree. seems to be a great meta call atm
chemcoop: Has nice defensive/offensive typing and can force mind games with the item. Scarf can pick up surprise KOs on things like Greninja, while Firium Z sets can deliver an unexpected finishing blow. Pretty good typing when threats like Fini, Koko, Mence, and Aegi are running rampant. A-
DragonWhale: B+
greilmercenary9: Wonderful check to a lot of common meta threats right now, with a great typing that frustrates some common cores, including the omnipresent Mence-Aegi-Koko-Hippo teams. This is easily the best of the Rotoms right now: great coverage, multiple status options, several different viable items. Volt Switch is also great for a glue/pivot mon to keep momentum.
NOVED: rn i think this is by far the better of the rotom bros. the fire typing makes it really good vs aegi, ferro. and its a great typing to deal with stuff like mence & thund t. and then you can use volt switch to gain back momentum after taking advantage of those mons. very solid, def deserves A-.
Psynergy: My nom again, but I've definitely seen a lot of Rotom-H lately. Electric/Fire with Levitate is a really useful niche with Ground-types being so dangerous, and Overheat hurts. Still has some awkward weaknesses offensively and defensively but it's the most common Rotom for good reason I think.
Solerme: Agree with this. Great offensive and defensive typing for this meta.
Theorymon: Sure, A-
Magnezone: B+ -> B
Hide
cant say: abstain
chemcoop: Pretty meh mon imo with the number of Lando-T and Hippo in the metagame. Fills a niche role of walling Koko and trapping stuff like Celesteela/Ferrothorn if running Magnet Pull, but its lack of speed and 4x weakness to Ground makes it inferior to Koko and Thundy-T as an electric. B
DragonWhale: B
greilmercenary9: It certainly has a niche as a trapper of annoying Steel types and has solid typing for most of what it wants to do. But as Psynergy and SoLerme noted, beyond role compression there tend to be better options.
NOVED: B+, i think magnezone is really solid. theres a ton of mons that hate dealing with celesteela & ferro and magnet pull mag is a great partner for them. the typing is also fantastic and allows it switch in on a ton of stuff like koko, lele and p2
Psynergy: I still like Magnezone but I haven't seen this much lately. Steel and Electric are both good things to be, but there's so many good Electric-types and Steel-types that Magnezone kinda falls behind. Good role compression but that's its best niche.
Solerme: Agreed, i've not seen many successful magnezone around. Sturdy or magnet pull are fantastic, and the AV set is a good call for the tapus, while it can also trap Celesteela, but there are way better electric types or checks to the ones i've written before to justify a B+ spot.
Theorymon: Sure, B
Kommo-o: UR -> C
Hide
cant say: sure. I think it's a little better than that though, maybe B-. It can function on its own unlike the others in C
chemcoop: Saw this thing in the 1700s a lot, and I think it can be pretty scary with the right team comp. Also forces your opponent to bring their fairy, which makes team preview easier. C is fine, but I'd also be good with B-
DragonWhale: C
greilmercenary9: I agree with cant say and Psynergy that C actually seems a bit low for this. While the omnipresence of Mimikyu and the Tapus certainly hurts it tremendously, the Z-move is a huge threat if teams aren't prepared for it, and Fairy switches into it tend to be predictable. It also poses unique problems for certain cores compared to other Dragons: P2 in particular doesn't like Kommo compared to pretty much any other Dragon type threat. I don't think it deserves to be above B- in a meta that is quite hostile to something 4x weak to Fairy that operates at its best when Clangorous Soulblaze isn't blocked, but I do think it belongs closer to that than to some of the other stuff in C.
NOVED: sure, i havent seen this much but it probably deserves c at least. its def not just worthless. a well played kommo can do work in certain matchups.
Psynergy: I'm also of the opinion that this is probably actually B- but it's not super incredible. Do not sleep on that Z-move though, one wrong move could end you against this thing. Being x4 weak to Fairy-types does not make it bad by any means.
Solerme: This needs a rank, i'd honestly put it in C+ if we had a C+ tier. Z Kommo and Z Belly Drum can make it sweep teams if properly supported, while it can also act as a decent supporter/lead with the combination of stealth rock and rock tomb.
Theorymon: Agree, C
Vivillon: UR -> C/B-
Hide
cant say: I already posted about this in the thread, C
chemcoop: Definite C mon. Can sweep unprepared teams or inexperienced players but the Sleep Powder/QD strategy gets shut down by the combination of the omnipresent Electric/Misty Terrains and anything that resists Hurricane.
DragonWhale: C
greilmercenary9: Definitely a threat that must be respected since Sleep Powder + QD is very difficult to stop once it gets started. But getting started is tough in a meta with Tapu Koko and Tapu Fini everywhere, and it doesn't even get a good 1v1 matchup against them like more prominent sleep users do to make up for that. Beyond that, its general frailty means that dedicated support is necessary for it to function well, which hurts it, and the payoff arguably isn't really much better than more powerful and dangerous sweepers. To compare it to the mon just above: Kommo has its own issues with Fairy types but gets a better payoff with its boosts if it gets them, isn't crippled as much by terrain (though Misty Terrain can still be annoying), and has viable coverage moves to hit Fairy-types SE even if the actual power without STAB isn't that great.
NOVED: c seems good, qd + sleep is hard as hell to deal with but its kinda slow before qd and really squishy.
Psynergy: No higher than C, but you definitely need to respect the threat of Vivillon at Team Preview. It's basically a worse Breloom but Quiver Dance Hurricane is no joke. It definitely can destroy teams that aren't well prepped for it but Breloom just does the sleep thing better as a whole.
Solerme: B-. Needs support to get rid of Koko and Fini, that can shut its powder+qd strat, but it can still setup Qds on Fini and can put a lot of pressure at team preview. If you don't have answers you lose. This to me is enough to make it jump out of the C tier, even with Koko and Fini being so popular.
Theorymon: Agree, C
Mega Blastoise: UR -> C
Hide
cant say: abstain
chemcoop: If it has to be ranked, C is fine. I personally would be fine with it staying UR, because I have almost never seen this used in 1700s+ and is a waste of a Mega slot when you have other waters like Gren or Fini that provide better speed or utility and don't use that Mega space.
DragonWhale: UR
greilmercenary9: I guess C is fine here but I'm kind of ambivalent on this one. I don't have much to say on this since I haven't seen one in months, and while it isn't terrible I don't see why I'd use it over basically any relevant Water-type.
NOVED: Sure, C
Psynergy: I really don't care where this goes, it's not bad on paper but I don't see a reason to use this over another Mega or bulky Water aside from unique coverage. I say leave it unranked but I won't object to putting it in C if others feel it's worth the rank.
Solerme: Huge fan of it, but sadly can't really call for the B tier. This would've needed more bulk (HP) or some kind of setup move to be a good call. It still deserves a rank, but not a higher one.
Theorymon: Agree, C
Reuniclus: UR -> C
Hide
cant say: abstain
chemcoop: Leave it UR imo. Not as good as other TR setters like Mimikyu and P2, and struggles in a metagame where Mimikyu exists.
DragonWhale: UR
greilmercenary9: Similar to M-Blastoise. I know SoLerme has used this well but that's one of the few times I've ever seen it; the Mimikyu infested meta is unkind to it, and TR has both better setting and attacking options.
NOVED: Sure, C
Psynergy: Another thing I can see being usable but I'm not sure it's relevant enough to rank. I feel there was a stronger case for Reuniclus in ORAS but being a TR reliant Psychic-type isn't exactly fantastic in this meta. I can be convinced but for now I'll say keep it unranked.
Solerme: I'm biased here, Reuniclus brought me to the semis in the last invitational with its Z Trick Room and Z Future Sight. Sadly there are way too much good psychic types around and better TR setter such as Mimikyu (i still don't get why this gets TR tho.) to make it climb to the B tier.
Theorymon: Agree, C
Mega Alakazam: B- -> C
Hide
cant say: disagree. this has a legit niche as a fast Trace user which allows it to check rain and sand, and is great on Psychic spam
chemcoop: Stays B-. Provides a niches support role on certain Baton Pass teams, and also gets ridiculously strong when paired with Tapu Lele.
DragonWhale: B-
greilmercenary9: B-, An extremely fast Trace user has application in this meta as a check to weather and even to (Mega) Blaze, which is interesting. It also has just enough movepool options to cause certain walls problems with Disable, Encore, Taunt etc., and can boast more power and cover up its weakness to priority on Psychic Spam.
NOVED: probably not, i feel like this has enough potential to be b-. can serve as a nice lead for stuff like glalie and eevee teams. and similar things such as that. its also super fast so it has that going for it.
Psynergy: I think Mega Alakazam has a stronger case for being moved up than moved down right now, being that fast with Trace is always worth consideration. I think it's fine where it is right now though, it dies to a light breeze and hard to rely on as your only Mega since its coverage is awkward.
Solerme: Fast and kind of powerfull. It can act as a decent gimmick most of the times, since you never know what it is going to do between its Disable + Encore / Twave strategies, or if it's going to attack you with a 4 offensive slot. Trace can be nice, specially if you consider that it can outspeed a Blaziken with it, but It doesn't skip out the gimmick tier though, since it's frail and outclassed by better psychic types that aren't even Megas.
Theorymon: Agree, C
Sharpedo: B- -> C
Hide
cant say: disagree. sash sets are really good imo
chemcoop: B-. Sash D-Bond is :sogood: and like Blaziken (but to a lesser extent) forces the 'mega or not' mind games in team preview.
DragonWhale: C
greilmercenary9: B-, Similar to M-Zam in being a fast mon that can't usually take a hit. Sash DB is a pain to play against though.
NOVED: yeah its just way to weak.
Psynergy: Also fine where it is, this isn't a super excellent mon but Sash Destiny Bond is always something you should respect. The mindgames between Sash and Mega can also make it annoying to play around if you predict wrong.
Solerme: I agree with Psyg with the fact that the mindgames between Sash and Mega can make it annoying to play around if you predict wrong. As written above on mZam, good gimmick.
Theorymon: Agree, C
Mega Sharpedo: B- -> C
Hide
cant say: yeah idk. abstain
chemcoop: Still think this should be B-. Strong Jaw + Ice Fang/Psychic Fangs/Crunch OHKOs a ton of meta relevant threats after SR.
DragonWhale: C
greilmercenary9: B-, Similar to base form but adds some more power at the cost of the Sash, so it has a better chance to do some work against moderately bulky stuff. DB can still be a problem too. Same rank as Zam seems fair.
NOVED: nah b- is good. b- is not even that great a spot and this is a pretty damn solid cleaner sometimes. i wouldnt sleep on this too hard.
Psynergy: Same deal as above, being similar Mega Gyarados is very much not a good thing for it but Strong Jaw can really mess with bulky squads since it actually has the bulk to take a weaker hit. The threat of Destiny Bond also still exists here so I definitely wouldn't sleep on the shark.
Solerme: I've been using it a little. It has a decent movepool, great abilities and nice offensive stats. I'm debating here since B- sounds too much, but C doens't sound fair to me.
Going to keep it low and vote for the C tier for now.
Theorymon: Agree, C
Milotic: B- -> C
Hide
cant say: disagree. didn't realise it was even this low, seems like more of a B rank imo. decent bulky water
chemcoop: Outclassed by defensive Fini and Suicune as a bulky Water type, although Mirror Coat and Adrenaline Orb/Competitive memes are kinda neat. C.
DragonWhale: C
greilmercenary9: I agree with SoLerme here; while Flame Orb is interesting, it's hardly a guarantee to even get it since Misty Terrain is everywhere, and beyond the Flame Orb niche to counter certain physical attackers it's just kind of mediocre. Having your wall dropping health each turn in a meta with plenty of residual damage is a bit dubious as well. It's definitely one of the best things that would be in C if it goes there, but I do think it would be fair to drop it.
NOVED: C
Psynergy: As someone who has used Milotic, I am definitely a fan of a bulky Water with reliable recovery. The pseudo immunity to Toxic with Flame Orb Marvel Scale is also really cool and probably the main reason I don't think this is just a meme pick.
Solerme: I agree with what it's been said. The combination of Flame Orb and Icy wind + scald burns can make it a good call for setup sweepers like MMence. It also has a recovery, but again even here it's hard to justify a stop in a such offensive metagame as this one. I'd vote C+, but B- is too high.
Theorymon: Agree, C
Talonflame: B- -> C
Hide
cant say: abstain
chemcoop: C. Rip birb. Priority Z-BB is neat, but good luck keeping that Gale Wings intact when Rocks and Sand are everywhere.
DragonWhale: UR
greilmercenary9: Priority Skystrike is nice I guess, but the growing prominence of residual damage, especially SR on Hippo teams, doesn't do this any favors. Without priority Roost or (usually) Brave Bird to use more consistently like in ORAS though this thing really suffers from its subpar non-speed stats, and even then it doesn't outrun stuff like Koko/M-Gar without its ability.
NOVED: C
Psynergy: Honestly yeah, I like Talonflame sometimes but this is just not relevant enough to stay in B- at this point. Priority Skystrike is definitely scary and I'd say makes it worth keeping ranked for now but C rank feels more appropriate.
Solerme: Two words: Rocks / Psychic terrain. With the raise of both i don't really think that this is a good pick.
Theorymon: Agree, C
Buzzwole: B- -> C
Hide
cant say: disagree. I still see this popping up on competent teams. being super mence / blaziken / mimikyu weak sucks but apart from those it checks physical attackers really well like non-fly z gyara / lando
chemcoop: B-. Walls Lando-T outside of z-Fly and scares away common fat mons like P2. AV can also live some special hits and pick up a surprise KO on something that expected to KO it.
DragonWhale: B-
greilmercenary9: This can run several different types of sets, although I really think AV and Bulky Roost are the main ones that really make sense compared to Heracross in particular. AV plays the role significantly better than Heracross thanks to significantly better physical bulk, a higher base attack stat, and better coverage, while Bulky Roost can leverage its high defense to check physical attackers that lack SE coverage. Buzzwole has good enough coverage to tech for your team, and it can typically take a hit and then retaliate with force--especially effective against many of the frailer mons around. Depending on moveset and spread you can surprise some stuff that really won't expect you to be able to live an attack and deal heavy damage back. Buzzwole definitely has its drawbacks: it gets trounced by three S-rank mons, is fairly slow, and without Leftovers/general healing other than Leech Life, it does get worn down pretty easily. But on balance I think it does enough good to stay in B- rather than drop.
NOVED: C
Psynergy: I still don't feel strongly about this thing but I don't see what other people see in it. This is a worse Heracross unless it's a bulky Roost set and I'm already not a huge Heracross fan. Think I'll abstain on this one.
Solerme: Good check to popular stuff like sand, Landorus (barring the Z Fly set) and p2. It gets Roost and can deal a lot of damage with its ability boosts. Not a gimmick, B-.
Theorymon: Agree, C
Umbreon: B- -> C
Hide
cant say: disagree. good bulky mon and can cheese with Z celebrate
chemcoop: B-. Stupidly bulky and access to Wish/Yawn provides nice team support.
DragonWhale: C
greilmercenary9: B-, Strong supporter with Yawn that also can mess with physical attackers with Foul Play and even BP Z-Celebrate boosts for a different and more offensive approach.
NOVED: C
Psynergy: Nah Umbreon is alright, it's not a common pick but being a hippo with Foul Play is actually a cool niche for offensive teams, especially with Salamence. I've seen this a decent amount and it can be annoying to deal with if you lack Bug-, Fairy-, or Fighting-type STAB.
Solerme: C, Worth a rank, but way too predictable. I used its Z Celebration set a lot, with decent success too, but it remains a gimmick.
Theorymon: Agree, C
Nidoking: B- -> C
Hide
cant say: completely disagree. this thing is legit lol
chemcoop: B-. Phenomenal coverage makes this guy a pretty decent anti-lead. It also switches into Koko freely and gets to fire off a huge hit, which can be really clutch. Sash/Scarf/Life Orb sets all have good merit.
DragonWhale: B-
greilmercenary9: B-, Basically having LO power thanks to Sheer Force with insane coverage while still being able to use a different item is nice, and the coverage is good enough that not much wants to take many hits from this, so slower teams can suffer against it (it also doesn't lose its Sash to sand, which can help against stuff like Hippo). Sucker Punch along with Sash can also buy some extra hits.
NOVED: nah i like this as a sash lead. the coverage combined with sheer force power can be hard to deal with for some teams. it almost has something to hit every mon in the meta. and you pretty much need something faster than it to deal with it easily. (which isnt that hard, but its down @ b- for a reason) and if you dont have two mons faster than it then it can get a lot of dmg off if it was able to ohko the fast mon that brought it to sash.
Psynergy: I don't feel strongly on this one but Nidoking is alright, I'm not convinced it needs to drop to C but I'm certainly not against it. Offensive Poison-type is definitely a useful niche but if the Sticky Web squads are falling out of favor I can see this dropping.
Solerme: Nice ability, huge movepool, weak but handy priority. If it gets support or if it's faster than the one who opposes it, it can be devastating. Not a gimmick
Theorymon: Agree, C
Clefable: B- -> C
Hide
cant say: disagree. I think it's still okay as a bulky unaware option and can use magic guard well too
chemcoop: C. Don't really like this thing outside of Baton Pass teams, and even then it's an inferior BP recipient compared to Espeon. Minimize sets get shut down by Celesteela and lack of Magic Bounce means that it can just get phazed out by Hippo and other WW/Roar users.
DragonWhale: B-
greilmercenary9: B-, I'm not a fan of Clef but it's probably the best Unaware wall with a solid Fairy typing, and Magic Guard can also be very useful in a meta with increasing residual damage or just as a way to buy an extra turn if your opponent thinks you're running Unaware and tries to Toxic. Also a decent enough BP receiver option for certain teams.
NOVED: yea i agree with this. minimize clef is not what it used to be without daddy thund. i think the existence & popularity of curse mimikyu also hurt the strat a ton as well. to a point where i wouldnt even consider it very viable of a strategy anymore. & i dont really think non minimize clefs are all that strong. the only team id maybe consider this on is eeveepass as a boost receiver.
Psynergy: This thing sucks, I don't like it. It's certainly a threat on the right squads but I don't think this is worth using outside of those obnoxious BP teams. I guess B- fits it but I just don't think it's that good.
Solerme: The Unaware + Kee Berry set can setup vs offensive teams, whereas the Magic Guard one can deal with stall. In the right situation it can close games. It also puts a decent amount of pressure at the team preview. Imo not a gimmick
Theorymon: Agree, C
Changes:
Hippowdon moves from A to A+
Primarina moves from A- to B+
Rotom-H moves from B+ to A-
Magnezone moves from B+ to B
Kommo-o moves from UR to B-
Vivillon moves from UR to C
Milotic moves from B- to C
Talonflame moves from B- to C