Disclaimer One: I am well aware that OMPL sign ups just started, but I am going to post this just for food for thought while we watch the tournament unfold.
Disclaimer Two: This is long. At the very least, please read the sections that I did not hide in tabs so that you at least get an idea of what I am saying, just without more specific points.
Now anyone who is a friend of mine knows, I have had a major issue with Regen Cores for a while now. I think that they are extremely stupid, as you can shrug off pretty much any damage you want, as soon as the opponent’s Pokémon that can pressure it are gone. Upon switching out, the user gains 33% of their HP back, and with a partner, they can continually do that, giving stall teams a massive advantage by still giving Pokémon the chance to heal without burning any PP. However, there are other issues with Regenerator, such as RegenVest. This is just a stupid concept, as if you give any pokemon with decent special defense the RegenVest combo, they become a very solid Special wall. Magearna is the threat that everyone knows, but Manaphy uses this well too, as does Muk, and even Meloetta and Jirachi can do it too. I even just got a stall team with Turtonator on it with RegenVest to give it survivability. RegenVest makes the ability so splashable and decently viable to any pokemon with the SpD stat to make use of it. Then there are other pokemon like Doublade or Ferrothorn which appreciate the passive recovery of this ability, while their specially defensive counterparts (primarily RegenVesters) appreciate the defense that they bring to the table alongside them.
Now yes, there a little bit of counterplay to Regen Cores. Hazards, for example, can help to pressure that recovery. A single layer of spikes will take off 12% of that 33% each time a pokemon comes in, but it can be really difficult to keep spikes up with the constant presence of Magic Bounce and Defog. Then there is Magnet Pull. This can be very effective at trapping Magearna, Ferrothorn, Doublade and other Steel type pokemon that run regenerator; however, this only works for Steel type Pokémon. Pursuit can also help the situation by punishing the opponent from switching out; however, this does not force the opponent to stay in the way that Mag Pull does, thus making it more difficult to eliminate these threats, and it doesn’t prevent the regenerator recovery if they manage to survive pursuit. The only other way to handle Regen Cores is to simply overpower it, but this can be difficult in itself with the support that other mons can provide for the core that slowly wear down the offensive mon rather than the defensive core.
Thus, skillful counterplay against Regen Cores is really hard to come by (and even harder to use successfully), and I think that it is definitely a major part of what makes stall so good right now in AAA. The problem is that Regenerator itself is not inherently broken, so we can’t just outright ban it, but Regen Cores are frankly uncompetitive in the metagame. Thus, when I was asking around for potential solutions to this problem, several times the idea of a
Single Ability Clause for AAA came up. I quite like this idea as it would successfully eliminate Regen Cores that aren’t good for the metagame, while also causing several other positive changes by limiting various other splashable abilities.
Poison Heal
First off, a single ability clause would help to control Poison Heal. Similarly to Regenerator, Poison Heal helps to give recovery to pokemon that naturally don’t have it outside of leftovers. However, unlike Regenerator, this ability also requires a Toxic Orb to make it consistent, and Toxic Orb does not boost defenses the way that an Assault Vest or an Eviolite would as common items for Regenerator mons. Also, protect can help improve the recovery, and is highly recommended, even though not entirely required. This ability can be put onto most pokemon that lack recovery, such as Cresselia, Snorlax, Tapu Fini, Manaphy, and our own Laxpras even made a team once abusing PH Sylveon because the ability is that good. Along with protect for constant scouting, PH cores become very good at defeating choice mons that are common on more offensive teams. Now, obviously PH is good for recovery, but it is really good especially for set up mons. I am sure all of us have lost to PH Snorlax, PH Tapu Fini, or some other PH mon of the kind because they are that good.
Adaptability
A single ability clause would also limit Adaptability. Adaptability is arguably one of the most splashable abilities in the entire game due to the fact that every single Pokemon has a Stab move of choice. We have seen how this ability can be problematic as Terrakion was banned from AAA in part because of it. Other threats like Zygarde and Mamoswine are majorly notable for the power they bring with their Adaptability sets. However, it is difficult to argue that adaptability is a broken ability considering that Tough Claws is waiting right there in the wings to provide a similar boost. Changing the Stab bonus from 1.5 to 2 means that Adaptability gives a 1.33x boost in power of Stab moves. In contrast, Tough Claws gives a 1.3x boost in power to Contact moves. There are some differences in the utility of the abilities, though. Most importantly, Adaptability also works for special mons, like Tapu Lele or Latios, which does give it the edge over Tough Claws. On the flip side though, Tough Claws can boost more than just the stab moves that a mon gets, things like Poison Jab or Iron Head which are particularly beneficial for Dragon types that aren’t commonly Poison or Steel types as they give those moves a boost to help against Fairies in a way that adaptability would not. By a implementing a single ability clause, it would force the user to choose which singular mon is the most important pokemon to have the ability, be it Mamoswine, Zygarde, Tapu Lele, etc, and thus limiting the easily spamable power boost that Adaptability can provide.
Tinted Lens
On a similar vein to adaptability, Tinted Lens is pretty splashable too, though arguably, not to the extent of Adaptability. Some coverage options, like the coveted Ghost/Fighting coverage, are perfect right now by themselves, and thus wouldn’t need the benefit that Tinted Lens could provide. However, every pokemon appreciates spamming one specific stab move more than having to switch between coverage moves, so even though things like Victini have good coverage in V-Create and Bolt Strike, it can still make use of Tinted Lens, allowing it to hit threats like Tapu Fini for strong damage with V-Create, making it less important what the user clicks.
Other Notes
Now, less on the track of splashability, but rather on a more general note, by implementing a single ability clause, it encourages a wiser use of other abilities that may not be entirely commonplace. Weather/Terrain teams would have to be more careful with their setter, as now they’d only have one to play with. The same can be said of Surge Surfer/Swift Swim/Unburden for the speed boost that Weather/Terrain teams love. However, outside of specific team comps, this also applies to generally more offensive abilities like Mold Breaker (and friends), as well as defensive ones like Unaware, Magic Bounce, and others. On the flip side, it encourages creativity with more uncommon abilities. Things like Mega Launcher and Steelworker are really good, granting a 1.5x boost in select situations just from the ability itself, but they rarely see usage because the more standard options are picked instead. Freeing up space from repeat abilities allows more of these sets to be used without harming the team the way they might by opting out of Adaptability or Tinted Lens.
In conclusion, changing to a single ability clause will definitely cause a shift in the metagame. Stall would definitely be hurt by this as now they wouldn’t be able to run double PH or Regen (even though eliminating regen cores was the original intent of the post). That will make building for stall more difficult, as threats such as Naganadel, Xurkitree, and Manaphy are still around, and it might be extremely difficult to find checks and counters to all of them, not even just for stall, but in general. However, for stall to still be strong, users will have to become more creative. Things like Grassy Surge, while severely underrated right now, might rise in usage as it helps against some ground attacks while also providing passive recovery to teammates. Stall will still be viable due to its amazing defensive abilities, though the options may be smaller than that of offensives styles of gameplay, it’s just that now other types of teams have a better chance against it. Now, this isn’t to say that offensive teams get off free either. They would be going through some significant losses too. Adaptability and Tinted Lens now have to used sparingly, and Weather/Terrain teams would have to build differently as well to accommodate only one setter and to properly protect said setter. All types of gameplay will be affected by this decision; however, I think that it would be in our best interest overall to make this change and hopefully promote a better metagame where creative teambuilders of any style of gameplay can come in and have a chance at winning.
I really think that we should implement this change; however, because it takes time for people to adjust to major shifts like those that this would cause, I am aware that this probably wouldn't happen until after OMPL, thus, I will be watching for specific replays that demonstrate this point.