Understanding the Restrictions on Gods and Followers Mashups
Gods and Followers team verification is implemented in an unusual way that prevents common mashup ingredients such as AAA from working, even when they are typically available to any other base meta. I have explained roughly why this is probably occurring to several people in the mashups chat, but especially after reading Roldski's last post, I thought it might be helpful to leave a more detailed and permanent explanation here so that interested people can understand the subtleties. But first, if you just want to know what GAF mashups you can tourbeg (at least successfully...), here is a brief summary:-
GAF mashups that work: Inverse, Little Cup (for the most part, see below for caveats), ZU or other lower tiers (again, for the most part)
GAF mashups that don't work: AAA, STAB, Ubers (i.e. Uber followers), Anything Goes, Balanced and Pure Hackmons (along with other metas that usually can't be mash ingredients in the first place like Mix and Mega)
OK, now for the explanation: GAF is quite a unique OM in that teams are a hybrid of one Uber-legal Pokemon and five OU members. Showdown doesn't currently have a general means of representing such a "hybrid format", so internally it is an Ubers-based format but with additional restrictions that require the followers to be OU legal. The way these restrictions are implemented on main is that GAF's verifier runs the first Pokemon on a team through the general Ubers verifier (a second time), and the remaining Pokemon are each run through the OU verifier (in addition to the Ubers verifier from the format). Have you ever noticed that, even in vanilla GAF, when you have something like an illegal move selected, sometimes the error message will list the problem twice, like this: "- Komala can't learn Muddy Water. - Komala can't learn Muddy Water."? That's because the verifier has literally been run on that Pokemon twice, and this moveset was found to be illegal in both Ubers and OU (or Ubers twice, for gods).
The problem for mashups is that this second, GAF-only run through the verifier isn't aware of any tour-specific rules that have been set, such as "Ignore Illegal Abilities", the rule that is used to mash AAA with the base format. The result is that
GAF mashup tours can only add new restrictions/bans, not remove any pre-existing ones as tour unbans are ignored and overruled by the hardcoded internal verifier calls (the only exception would be if vanilla GAF banned something that is normally legal in Ubers or OU for gods or followers respectively, but currently no such ban seems to exist). This means that the only possible mashups are those in which the teams allow are already a subset of something legal in Ubers/OU (for example, gods could be limited to UU or lower, but Mega Rayquaza could not be enabled as a god) or involving formats such as Inverse in which the rule effect is unrelated to team validation.
Now, here is a subtle corollary. Remember I mentioned above that Little Cup is only "for the most part" possible to mash up with GAF? This is because although LC legality seems to be a very small subset of OU, there are a few things that are legal in LC but not OU, such as trapping abilities, and therefore those things cannot be enabled in a GAF LC mashup. One example is Arena Trap from Roldski's team, which cannot be run on Trapinch as a follower (however, it
could be run if you choose to make Trapinch the team's god, due to Arena Trap being legal in Ubers). GAF's LC is a close facsimile - but not quite the real thing.
---
ZoroWarrior said:I feel like that’s a waste of a slot, given that it can abuse Agility a lot more, and you can have something like Terrakion for special walls. That actually might not be a bad core tbh. But anyway,
I very much like the idea of Gods and Followers Little Cup but 2v2 STAAABmons is a 3 way mashup, and I don’t think those should be a thing. 2v2 AAA is an astoundingly unbalanced meta, given that 2v2 pokemon are often made good because of their ability, like Koko and Pelipper, and Pre Mega Gyarados. Combined with STABmons, we would need to ban quite a lot of things, and since it’s only for this month, I don’t like the idea of that mashup. 2v2 Anything Goes or 2v2 Mix And Mega (jk) would be a lot better.
I don't think there's anything wrong with 3+ way mashups in general, but I do find STAAABmons in particular somewhat less meaningful because it tends to end up feeling like a watered-down BH rather than creating something distinctive (something like Inverse Reverse AAA would be an example of a 3-way mashup that feels like it creates something unique).
However, in this case STAAABmons was a request from somebody who was adamant that it would be the best mashup for 2v2, although I have no idea why he felt that way, LOL.
Roldski32 said:I don't know if " LC Uber ++ LC Uber " could work. If i remember correctly, ++ means you can't have a 2 pokemon on a same team.
Thank-you! I will try this out.