ChrisSweeper said:boop
Singles 6v6 Pokemon is notoriously unbalanced if left alone. There has to be some degree of testing and fine tuning to get to a point where the game can be played competitively.
For any game or sport to be considered competitive, a good player needs to be able to
consistently win against a player worse than them. The reason that sports like tennis thrive is that the sport and circuit allow you to prise apart the top players from the bottom. It is incredibly incredibly difficult for a tennis player even in the top 20 in the world to beat somebody in the top 5 (just look at win rates), and for this reason, the game is considered highly competitive. All this is the result of "fine-tuning" the sport around the edges, including introducing standard court sizes, racket sizes / materials, extending more important matches to 5 sets etc etc. These are all iterations that have made tennis one of the most competitive sports in the world.
"Unbalanced" Pokemon is like playing on a tennis court double the size - its impossible to cover all that area at once, so you have to take educated guesses every single turn. It would be significantly harder for top players to consistently win, because every time the opponent hits the ball there's a 40% chance it goes somewhere that you maybe could have reached, but you had to commit to protecting another area of the court instead. In short, long-term planning goes out of the window because your only focus would be on trying to get the ball back. Bringing too many options into a game means that you'll end up with multiple ones that are comparably good, so then there's not much skill in being able to identify good options in the first place. Top players wouldn't be anywhere near as consistent.
Obviously we aren't aiming to get anywhere close to that level with Pokemon, and none of us should be thinking that big. But ultimately, we want to make a game that is both fun and rewarding to play.
Rewarding is important - in other words, there should be enough options to pick on a given turn that winning feels like its earnt, but not so many comparable choices that the choices between them become predominantly luck. If you've put more work in and you're better than your opponent, you should win more often that not. If there is a large skill gap between you, you should be able to win much more consistently. If we don't treat this as important, then there's literally no point in hosting tournaments. There's no longevity in a game where being better doesn't give you a significant advantage. Although we're unlikely to ever get there, we should be striving to get each generation to a level where a player ranked #5 is
consistently (like >75%) able to win against a player ranked #15, for example.
As it stands, I believe dynamax is a mechanic which detracts from this. From team preview, you can probably limit the Dynamax users to ~3 Pokemon on average. However, you don't know specifically which one, you don't know when it'll happen, and there are many situations where that incorrect guess is a near auto-loss. Temporarily disabling Choice items is such an absurd mechanic that means until your opponent has used their Dynamax, there are basically no "safe" moves to make against offense. The momentum is
always with the faster offensive Pokemon even if you've managed to pivot a defensive check into a strong position. Most common example is switching Toxapex into Darmanitan / Dracovish choice-locked into a resisted attack. In every other game since Choice items have existed, the Toxapex user has
earnt an advantage state using good play and now the offensive Pokemon has to respond. Now, however, Dynamax provides the option to just blow through Toxapex by switching to a coverage move, which also gives you a stat boost! This means that these offensive Pokemon are in a position to OHKO something literally every single turn should you guess wrong, even if you get yourself into a "winning" position. This is akin to a double-sized tennis court - you can be absolutely outplaying your opponent but every single time they hit the ball, by simply guessing correctly they can position the ball somewhere that is unreachable. This is
blatantly uncompetitive.
Regarding Dive and Fly - do we even need to cover this? This is akin to saying that Double Team should be allowed because of Aerial Ace.
I think a good parallel to draw here is Gen 5 Wonder Launcher, which was a mode embedded into WiFi battles which let you use items. It was an absolute no-brainer not to allow this in competitive formats because it meant that every turn you had infinitely more options beyond just attack / switch, and with too many options, skill goes out the window. Whilst I don't think Dynamax is quite so ridiculous as Wonder Launcher, it is nearing that point. Competitive Pokemon thrives on the idea that every turn there are several options that each player can take, and a good player can pick out which of those options in most advantageous each turn - add in too many options, for example having to consider the chance and risk:reward of opposing Dynamax in the back of your head every turn, and it becomes near impossible to seperate several options which all look to be equally advantageous