Gen 1 Pokémon that are unfairly banned in Pokémon Showdown
Hi all, the other day we wanted to do a tournament of Pika Cup in Gen 1 OU and Gen 1 OU Stadium, but had to cancel them because we discovered that Showdown’s system thought that many pokémon had illegal levels (Pika Cup is a tournament that allows pokémon from levels 15 to 20). One example would be a level 15 Gyarados. At first you may think “well, Magikarp evolves into Gyarados at level 20 in the Gen 1 games, so Showdown is right for banning a level 15 Gyarados”, well, what you may don’t know is that in Pokémon Yellow you could go to Fuschia City and use the Super Rod to fish many level 15 Gyarados (which appeared 10 % of the time).
Anyway, I checked all the pokémon that can be used in the Pika Cup using legitimate methods, which means no glitches, no bugs, no cheat devices and no tradebacks. After finishing my research I discovered that 20 pokémon are unfairly banned by Showdown’s system, here is the list of those pokémon and how you can get them in the Gen 1 games:
Pokémon unfairly banned
1. Pidgeotto, levels 15 to 20: In Pokemon Yellow you can catch an underleveled Pidgeotto in Viridian Forest (a reference to the Pidgeotto that Ash captured at the beggining of the anime in the same place).
2. Raticate, levels 15 to 19: An underleveled Raticate can be caught at Route 21 in Pokemon Yellow
3. Fearow, level 19: An underleveled Fearow can be caught at Route 9 in Pokemon Yellow.
4. Parasect, levels 15 to 20: You can get an underleveled Parasect in Pokemon Yellow by doing the following: catch a level 15 Venonat in Pokemon Yellow, trasnfer it to Pokemon Red or Blue, go to the Cinnabar Island Lab and trade Venonat for Tangela with a Non Playable Character, transfer Tangela to Pokemon Yellow, finally, go to Route 18 and trade Tangela for Parasect with another Non Playable Character.
5. Dugtrio, levels 15 to 20: You can get an underleveled Dugtrio by trading across versions: first catch a level 15 Slowbro in Pokemon Yellow, transfer Slowbro to Pokemon Red or Blue, go to the Route 17 gate and trade Slowbro for Lickitung with a NPC, tranfer Lickitung to Pokemon Yellow, finally, go to Route 11 and trade Lickitung for Dugtrio with another NPC (the traded Dugtrio will be nicknamed Gurio, cute nickname! :3).
6. Golduck, levels 15 to 20: You can catch an underleveled Golduck at Route 6 in Pokemon Yellow.
7. Poliwhirl, levels 15 to 20: You can catch an underleveled Poliwhirl in Pokemon Yellow at Route 22.
8. Poliwrath, levels 15 to 20: You can get an underleveled Poliwrath in Pokemon Yellow with ease, just catch a level 15 Poliwhirl at Route 22 and then evolve it with a Water Stone.
9. Machamp, levels 16 to 20: An underleveled Machamp can be gotten in Pokemon Yellow: first catch a level 16 Cubone in the Safari Zone, then go to Route 5 and trade it for a Machoke with a NPC, the Machoke will evolve after the trade and become Machamp. It is interesting to note that Machoke’s evolution CANNOT BE STOPPED, so it will always become a Machamp, due to this, Machoke is impossible to use in the Pika Cup of Pokemon Stadium 1 despite the fact that Machop and Machamp are available. The only way to use Machoke in the Pika Cup is by cheating, using glitches or trading it from the Gen 2 games, of course, all of these methods are considered illegal in the Gen 1 games.
10. Tentacruel, level 20: You can get an underleveled Tentacruel in Pokemon Yellow by fishing on Route 20.
11. Slowbro, levels 15 – 20: In Pokemon Yellow you can catch underleveled Slowbros, they appear if you Surf on Route 12.
12. Dewgong, levels 15 – 20: To get an underleveled Dewgong you have to follow these steps: catch a level 15 Growlithe in Pokemon Red, then transfer it to Pokemon Yellow via Trade or Pokemon Stadium 1, then go to the Cinnabar Island Lab and talk to a Non Playable Character, she will trade her Dewgong for your Growlithe.
13. Haunter, level 20: You can only catch an underleveled Haunter in Pokemon Yellow, it appears in the Pokemon Tower.
14. Gengar, level 20: Catch a level 20 Haunter in the Pokemon Tower in Pokemon Yellow and then trade it to another Gen 1 game so it can evolve into Gengar.
15. Kingler, levels 15 to 20: You can catch an underleveled Kingler in Pokemon Yellow if you fish at Route 25.
16. Electrode, levels 15 to 20: You can get an underleveled Electrode in Pokemon Red or Blue if you go to the Cinnabar Island Lab, a NPC will trade his Electrode for a Raichu (the Electrode will be nickanemd Doris, lol).
17. Rhydon, levels 15 to 20: You can get an underleveled Rhydon in Pokemon Yellow with ease, just go to the Cinnabar Islan lab where a NPC will offer his Rhydon for a Golduck of yours.
18. Seadra, level 20: You can fish an underleveled Seadra in Pokemon Yellow at Route 13.
19. Gyarados, levels 15 to 19: You can fish an undereleveled Gyarados in Pokemon Yellow at Fuschia City (use the Super Rod or else it won’t appear).
20. Dragonair, levels 15 to 20: You can get an underleveled Dragonair in Pokemon Yellow by fishing at the Kanto Safari zone (use the Super Rod).
I want to ask politely to Showdown’s programmers to modify the status of these pokémon from illegal to legal so players can finally use them (we have planned to organize Pika Cup tournaments in the Ruins of Alph chatroom).
Rental pokémon that are unfairly banned
Pika Cup could also be played in the popular game Pokémon Stadium 1 (in fact, it was one of the main cups of the game). When you played the cup in Pokémon Stadium 1, you were allowed to rent pokémon in case that you didn’t have any, you could also make teams that had rental pokémon and pokémon from the cartridges (Red, Blue or Yellow). Rental pokémon had fixed levels, stats and moves, so the players were not able to change them; Rental pokémon also couldn’t be transfered to the cartridge games, in short, they could only be used when the players played the Pika Cup. Anyway, here is the list of the 27 RENTAL pokémon that are unfairly banned by Pokémon Showdown’s system:
Rental pokémon that are unfairly banned
Ponyta, Seel and Koffing
Ponyta, Seel and Koffing
If you play on Pokémon Stadium 1, use the original Pika Cup rules, and the fights are of 3 VS 3, you can also use Ponyta, Seel and Koffing in your team. These three pokémon are only available as rentals, which means that their levels, moves and stats cannot be modified in any way, still, it is a nice option if you’re a fan of them. Below are the movesets of those rental pokémon:
Ponyta
Ponyta
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Fire Blast
- Swift
- Horn Drill
- Reflect
Seel
Seel
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Surf
- Blizzard
- Headbutt
- Horn Drill
Koffing
Koffing
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Fire Blast
- Thunderbolt
- Self-Destruct
- Toxic
Special Pokémon that are only available as rentals
Special Pokémon that are only available as rentals
In Pokémon Stadium 1 you can also use some “special” pokémon if you play Pika Cup with the original rules and if the battles are of 3 VS 3. These pokémon are special because most of them are underleveled (e.g. a level 15 Tentacruel), while others have illegal moves (e.g. a Poliwrath with Double Slap, a move that it learns until level 25!). Again, since these pokémon are rentals, you can’t change their levels nor moves. Below is the list of the special pokémon and their movesets:
Pokémon List
Ivysaur
Ivysaur
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Solar Beam
- Body Slam
- Leech Seed
- Swords Dance
Note: Underleveled.
Charmeleon
Charmeleon
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Ember
- Mega Kick
- Swords Dance
- Toxic
Note: Underleveled.
Wartortle
Wartortle
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Surf
- Body Slam
- Bide
- Reflect
Note: Underleveled.
Fearow
Fearow
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Fly
- Peck
- Double Team
- Mimic
Note: Underleveled
Nidorina
Nidorina
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Ice Beam
- Take Down
- Horn Drill
- Toxic
Note: Underleveled.
Nidoqueen
Nidoqueen
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Surf
- Double Kick
- Fissure
- Reflect
Note: Underleveled.
Nidorino
Nidorino
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Ice Beam
- Horn Attack
- Double Kick
- Horn Drill
Note: Underleveled.
Nidoking
Nidoking
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Poison Sting
- Earthquake
- Bubble Beam
- Double Kick
Note: Underleveled.
Poliwrath
Poliwrath
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Surf
- Double Slap
- Hypnosis
- Metronome
Note: This special Poliwrath has Double Slap, a move that it normally learns until level 25.
Kadabra
Kadabra
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Psychic
- Seismic Toss
- Double Team
- Metronome
Note: Underleveled
Alakazam
Alakazam
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Mega Punch
- Psywave
- Metronome
- Thunder Wave
Note: Underleveled
Tentacruel
Tentacruel
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Mega Drain
- Wrap
- Supersonic
- Toxic
Note: Underleveled.
Magnemite
Magnemite
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Thunderbolt
- Swift
- Substitute
- Thunder Wave
Note: Underleveled
Cloyster
Cloyster
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Aurora Beam
- Hyper Beam
- Clamp
- Supersonic
Note: This special Cloyster has Aurora Beam, Clamp and Supersonic, three moves that it normally couldn't have at level 15. Normally Cloyster learns Supersonic at level 18, Clamp at level 23 and Aurora Beam at level 30.
Gastly
Gastly
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Psychic
- Night Shade
- Explosion
- Confuse Ray
Note: Underleveled
Haunter
Haunter
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Thunderbolt
- Night Shade
- Self-Destruct
- Confuse Ray
Note: Underleveled
Gengar
Gengar
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Mega Drain
- Night Shade
- Confuse Ray
- Metronome
Note: Underleveled
Exeggcute
Exeggcute
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Psychic
- Egg Bomb
- Double Team
- Toxic
Note: Underleveled
Exeggutor
Exeggutor
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Mega Drain
- Barrage
- Psywave
- Toxic
Note: Underleveled
Cubone
Cubone
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Earthquake
- Blizzard
- Strength
- Tail Whip
Note: Underleveled
Rhyhorn
Rhyhorn
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Earthquake
- Rock Slide
- Horn Attack
- Substitute
Note: Underleveled
Seadra
Seadra
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Bubble Beam
- Ice Beam
- Mimic
- Smokescreen
Note: Underleveled
Gyarados
Gyarados
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Hydro Pump
- Bite
- Leer
- Rest
Note: This special Gyarados has three moves that it can’t learn at level 15: Hydro Pump, Bite and Leer. You may say that Gyarados learns those moves at level 1 in Pokémon Red and Blue; however, it is impossible to get a Gyarados before level 20 in said games and when you evolve a pokémon in Gen 1 it doesn’t learn its level 1 moves again.
Porygon
Porygon
Ability: None
Level: 15
- Tri Attack
- Psychic
- Conversion
- Sharpen
Note: Underleveled
In our opinion, these pokémon should be allowed when players use the original rules because they are given by the game itself.
Pokémon Showdown’s system thinks that these pokemon are illegal since all of them are underleveled, also, in the case of Gyarados, it has three moves that it can’t learn in the games at level 15 (Hydro Pump, Bite, Leer). Since the game offers these pokémon as rentals, all of them are legal despite the reasons mentioned before; however, they should only be allowed when the players play Gen 1 OU Stadium.
Finally, since these pokémon are only offered as Rentals, players shouldn’t be able to change their movesets nor levels.
Pokémon exclusive of the japanese Gen 1 games
The following three pokemon are exclusive of the japanese games and due to that, they should still be considered illegal:
Pokémon exclusive of the japanese games
1. Golem, levels 16 to 24.
2. Muk, levels 15 to 37.
3. Kangaskhan levels 15 to 24.
Kangaskhan from levels 15 to 24 is considered legal by Showdown’s system; however, she is impossible to get in the international versions of the games at those levels, so, for the sake of playing our matches as fair as possible, she should be banned by the system or by the tournament rules at the very least.
Source
Pika Cup page in Bulbapedia:
https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Pika_Cup
Thanks in advance.
Beelzemon 2003, leader of the Gen 2 Item Clause project