Aaaalright, so this is sort of a half-formed idea, and it has nothing to do with the concept I posted previously, but I thought I might as well bring it up!
The idea for this mod is inspired by
GS Cup, a doubles-based VGC format in which players may have up to two "restricted Pokémon" (660+ BST Legendaries not named Regigigas and all of their forms and relatives) on their team, with the rest coming from the rest of the Pokédex (but still no Mythical Pokémon).
Disclaimer: I've never actually played a GS Cup format, so the similarities might end pretty quickly! I was just interested by the most basic concept of it. It doesn't necessarily have to follow VGC clauses or anything - it could be bring-6-pick-4 like VGC or it could be 6v6 like Doubles OU and it sure as heck isn't including Dynamax either way.
Anyway, I thought it would be interesting to explore that idea further, particularly in a way that was balanced carefully and from scratch. Game Freak's "Ubers" tend to embrace power creep more thoroughly than the Pokémon that are normally legal, mainly because they don't have to worry about them being balanced in any other context, and I think it's obvious that they didn't necessarily have
GS Cup specifically in mind when designing most of them, so some of them are extremely dominant in the format, some of them are totally outclassed and not worth wasting a restricted slot, and there are a few that don't really have anything more interesting to offer than a basic four-attacks (or three-attacks-and-Protect) moveset that just happens to be stronger than average.
The concept for this pet mod is as follows: a loosely GS Cup-based format in which
every restricted Pokémon is reworked from scratch in such a way that a) all of them are doubles-optimized and viable, and, much more importantly, b) each of them is focused on contributing a different form of utility to a team and is the best possible choice for that form of utility. The goal is that the restricted Pokémon become a defining centerpiece of the team not just by having the best stats and blowing things up the soonest but by working in tandem with the "normal" Pokémon on the team and bring out
their best to an extent that no ordinary Pokémon can match.
Since you can only have two restricted Pokémon, other Pokémon that provide similar forms of utility aren't invalidated - for example, if Kyurem becomes the ultimate speed control Pokémon, but you already want to use two other restricted Pokémon, you're still going to be able to incorporate all of the Icy Wind and Electroweb users that Kyurem is designed to outclass. A well-balanced team will probably want to have a lot more than just two Ubers' worth of utility. That said, different forms of utility will be more valuable to different teams, so choosing which forms of utility are worth "spending" your restricted Pokémon slots is an important layer of teambuilding.
The specific goal of the mod is
solely the revision of all existing restricted Pokémon. No new Pokémon or forms will be created, and no Pokémon that are not in that specific group will be changed. However, this revision process can include the creation of custom elements
(this will actually probably be strongly encouraged and be one of the first steps in the process for each Pokémon, since it's a way to give a unique take on utility options and make sure they're all competitive) or the alteration of existing moves and Abilities, on the condition that they are exclusive to the restricted Pokémon and no normal Pokémon can access them.
(For example: someone who's making a submission can do whatever they want to Aeroblast on Lugia's slate and Full Metal Body on Solgaleo's, but altering Sacred Fire for Ho-Oh or Pressure for Dialga would not be allowed, as those are accessible to Pokémon other than the ones that can be slated.)
Everything about the Pokémon can be changed during the process. They're essentially prompts and guidelines - while we should obviously stick to the core idea of each restricted Pokémon, stats may be changed freely, moves may be added and removed, Abilities may be added and removed, and so on. This can be seen like recreating the Pokémon from scratch and does not have to be subtle.
Admittedly, I'm personally not huge on allowing type retcons, but that's just a personal preference, so I'll most likely allow it and just vote against them, haha.
The following Pokémon are included in the scope of the project:
Hide
:mewtwo::lugia::ho-oh::kyogre::groudon::rayquaza::dialga::palkia::giratina::reshiram::zekrom::kyurem::xerneas::yveltal::zygarde::solgaleo::lunala::necrozma::zacian-crowned::zamazenta-crowned::eternatus: (and all associated forms)
* :cosmog: and :cosmoem: are also restricted Pokémon, but we are not doing that
* Depending whether we go full VGC or allow Mythical Pokémon, :hoopa-unbound: and maybe :arceus: would also qualify
* Calyrex will most likely be included once Crown Tundra comes out and we know its stats
(This will probably be Gen VIII-based and just add all of the mascots as Crown Tundra adds them, since we know they're all coming anyway! That might be nice, since it gives us a smaller selection to use from the start and hopefully time to establish them all and see how the meta develops before the rest are available.
That said, definitely no Dynamax or Gigantamax either way.)
I'm not worried about restricted Pokémon reaching a significantly higher power level than everything else (after all, every team has to
want two of them), but there's a condition on this: I would prefer for all of them to place a strong emphasis on support and utility (even if that's combined with offensive pressure!) rather than just raw sweeping power, because I think that's the best way to make sure that they're working in tandem with their non-restricted teammates. I don't want teambuilding to be "two Ubers that can win together and four filler," nor for losing your two restricted Pokémon to mean losing the game because nothing else can take a hit from your opponent's pair!
Some examples of what I understand to constitute utility in a doubles-based environment:
Hide
- status setters
- move-binding effects (Taunt, Encore, Disable, maybe Torment)
- weather and terrain
- Gravity
- Trick Room, Tailwind and speed-lowering moves
- lowering enemy stats
- raising ally stats
- screens
- Helping Hand
- trapping
- Fake Out
- priority
- redirection
- breaking protection
- Quick Guard and Wide Guard
- healing
- possibly Heal Block?
As you can see, there's a ton of variety already - there should be more than enough room for every restricted Pokémon to distinguish itself from the others in terms of what it has to offer a team. And especially with the mod being open to custom elements, there are even more ways to explore all of these - setting Gravity could mean using the move Gravity, but it could also mean having an attack that also sets Gravity as a side effect, or having an Ability that sets Gravity on entry, or even a status move that sets Gravity and something else at the same time, depending on the role and power level that specific restricted Pokémon is meant to have.
In terms of active tiering once the mod is playable, I think it should
remain possible to nerf and buff restricted Pokémon even after their respective slates have concluded, because the spirit of the mod rests on as many of them as possible being viable choices and supporting unique team constructions; I would hate to resort to banning a Pokémon or leaving one behind that never sees use just because we didn't get the balancing act right on the first try!
On the other hand, I would strongly discourage ever revising any normal Pokémon, because that's outside of the domain of the project and risks creating a greater learning curve and barrier to entry; all Pokémon other than restricted Pokémon should still be handled with tiering and bans as they would be in any other format.
Anddd... in terms of slate structure, I think it would be nice to explore this at a relatively slow pace, with each Pokémon having a multi-step slate (for example: any custom elements -> Abilities if not custom -> ideas for specific movesets they could run and moves that should be added and removed to facilitate this -> stats that are balanced with those sets in mind) and a fair bit of conversation around each of them.
There are only around 22 restricted Pokémon (optionally add some for forms), and each of them is expected to hold a great deal of significance in the meta, so I think it would be best to take it slow and make sure as many people as possible have a say in how to design them, rather than a single person making each one from scratch. This would also reduce the risk of people voting for different reasons - like, say one Solgaleo submission has it doing redirection and another has it doing Gravity, but one is also much stronger than the other in stats and movepool, so some people might be voting based on the form of utility they think is more interesting and others might be voting for the sake of balance in the meta. If the main form of utility and the moves and stat spread were all decided separately, we can have proper discussions on each one and make sure the final Pokémon is
both interesting/exciting
and well balanced. Like CAP!
Part of the reason why I think this approach would be wise for a meta like this: we also have all the way until Crown Tundra's release
(which might even be delayed, for all we know) to get through just the first ten! We have all the time we need to get them right, so while it's important to keep a brisk enough pace that interest doesn't wane and people can participate actively, trying to plow through all of them in a single step feels like an unnecessary rush and a waste of what could be a really fun process.
Anyway, that's all I have to say on this for now. Does anyone have thoughts or feedback on the idea or how it should be run? And does it sound like it could be fun and interesting?
EDIT: This is long! TL;DR version:
- doubles-based
- every team gets up to two restricted Pokémon (most version mascots + Mewtwo/Zygarde/Eternatus); the rest must be normal legal Pokémon
- the goal of the mod is to revamp all of the restricted Pokémon from scratch and balance them for this purpose
- includes custom elements
- strong emphasis on significant utility rather than raw breaking power; the restricted Pokémon are there to open up new options for teambuilding, not to steal the show and win the battle all by themselves
- no non-restricted Pokémon are modified at all (but they can always be banned if they're causing problems)
- based on Gen VIII, but will be updated with DLC (all remaining restricted Pokémon are already confirmed)