ScraftyIsTheBest said:Imo this should have at least been the case in Diamond and Pearl. It would've been nice if Palkia/Dialga (whichever one wasn't the mascot for the game) was catchable post-game after you did everything else, albeit at a higher level. DP openly acknowledges both legendaries in both games and makes it clear that they both exist in either canon of the versions, so much so that they even let you get a "seen" Pokedex entry for the non-mascot counterpart in the game! They should've gone even further than that by making that legendary downright catchable post-game.
The only two cases where the version-exclusive legendaries make sense are in BW and SwSh, because while both games do acknowledge that both legendaries exist, the one you don't get ends up in the ownership of a notable NPC (namely, N gets the non-mascot dragon in BW1, while Hop gets the wolf that you don't get in Sword and Shield). BW2 keeping Reshiram and Zekrom version exclusive also makes sense because you only see N and his dragon in that game, while the other one still belongs to Hilbert/Hilda who you never meet in BW2. But DP in particular definitely should've went the GS route because it pretty clearly acknowledges that Dialga and Palkia both exist even in DP itself.
but the criticism isn't exclusive to title legendaries. Even something like Tornadus or Thunderus are exclusive to another game. But you aren't losing out on just 1 of these legendaries, you are also losing out on Landorus because you are required to own both.
And if you go out of your way to get both versions, you get access to 2 Landorus of which you likely won't need the other.
Same problem in HGSS, with Kyogre and Groudon to get Rayquaza. Same with various legendaries in USUM like needing Raikou and Entei to get Suicune. And while you can transfer the other one just to get Suicune, you have to pay for Pokebank which may shut down in the future and you can't use the transfered Pokemon in said VGC season. Yes, it doesn't matter now because USUM season is over, but for the time it did.
You have also the Latis where you can only decide in-game which one you want if you got emerald, otherwise you have to hope the game you like more had the Dragon you desire. I know there are few events that make it easier such as South Island, but now you won't likely see people around with 3DS going around with that specific game and owns an Eon Ticket.
For B2W2, you need keys to unlock 1 Regi which doesn't require trading so it's more barable, you can get only 1 Lati and if you want therian forms and want to change forms freely, you need Pokemon Dream Radar. And the therian forms aren't even myphicals that are banned from standard tournament games.
In SM and USUM you get a Cosmog so the ability to get the other title legendary. The problem is its evolution is version exclusive too, so you can't get Lunala in Sun, Ultra Sun or Shield