My counterexample was also specifically talking about how to get Deoxys in XY, not ORAS. If you want to get Deoxys in XY, you need to buy two games.
I didn't mention XY because that's obfuscating the issue. The issue here is that GF's new method of distributing several popular Mythicals is now requiring the player to buy two games, one where the event happens and the other which simply acts as the key. NOTE, the game which "acts as the key" doesn't also give away the Mythical, it's simply a requirement to have a save file of that game to get it.
Saying "if you want Deoxys in XY you'll need to buy ORAS" ignores that Deoxys is an unlock in ORAS, it's not an event inside XY. This is like saying "if I wanted Articuno in RSE I would have to buy FRLG" or "if I wanted Raikou in DPPt I would have to buy HGSS". Yes, you would, because those Pokemon are available in those games. There's no event in RSE that'll give you an Articuno and there's not event in DPPt that'll give you a Raikou. Also, if you decide you don't want to transfer them over, well no biggie, because that still means you have an Articuno to use within FRLG and a Raikou in HGSS. Can't say the same for Darkrai (or Shaymin) in LA or Mew (and Jirachi) in BDSP; without Legends Arceus you can't get Darkrai in BDSP (outside of its distribution event) or Shaymin in SwSh; without BDSP you can't get Mew in Let's Go (outside of buying the deluxe pact or distribution event) or Jirachi in SwSh.
I admit, I mixed up your position with someone else's from the BDSP thread, which was like "Arceus in BDSP is even worse than Darkrai in LA".
Yeah, the Arceus event is "fine", as you at least can get Arceus in LA so it's not just "a key". Granted if you don't want to get LA you're locked out from getting Arceus so there is still a persisting issue... BUT LA is a great game that's been a shake-up players have been looking for in years so it's not a major issue as most players have gotten LA to play it.
Once again, opposite can't be said. Many older fans who has played the original DP or Platinum didn't like what they were doing with the DP remakes (especially when compared to how previous gen remakes were done) so want nothing to do with BDSP. They would not buy BDSP, but some who really want to get the Darkrai in LA may cave-in*. However, for those who decide it's not buying an extra game, well now that means no game gets a Darkrai cause BDSP was "just a key" (heck, BDSP would still be outta luck of not getting a Darkrai unless you got the event distribution).
* Yes, it's completely their decision to do so, yes, they're getting a full game out of if they will no doubt play and find enjoyment from, but that doesn't ignore its still a game they initially didn't want (while they'll get some enjoyment that enjoyment is tainted by the reasons of getting it which doesn't fix why they didn't want it) and for some they had to pay likely full price to get it. GE
I'm sure we both agree that save file bonus and event distribution put together would be the best outcome, however unlikely it is for Game Freak to do that. The argument is about given the choice between other-game-lock and time-lock, which one is preferable (if only one option can be chosen). My position is that an other-game-lock is always preferable:
And that's just it, we're all arguing over a decision that's out of our hands! Well, actually, all of you defending the practice are counter arguing, I and others who don't like the practice are just stating we don't like the practice (and explaining why); you're the ones jumping down our throats about it (and then acting like replying to your argument turns it into a heated debate). So, how about we ALL throw this discussion into the dumpster and try this again. Let us pretend that we're back to the very start of this discussion when we just learned about the "game locked" Mythicals:
User Against: "I don't like this. They're requiring us to get two games to unlock a a Mythical is one of them!"
User Defend: "True, but not only do you get a whole game out of it, it's better than timed events."
UA: "I agree on paper its better than timed events, but the game they want us to buy many do not want."
UD: "I can understand how that's frustrating and those who are in that situation have my sympathy, but I feel in the long term this is better as even several gens from now you can go back to those games and get the Mythical as long as you have the other games."
UA: "That too is understandable, but I'm worried how far GF may take this practice concerning making you buy another game instead of doing a distribution."
UD: "While at the moment I do not think it's that bad, I understand the concern. All we can do is watch what happens. If GF ever does start taking it too far hopefully fans can speak with their wallets. But let us also remember this is GF, they're as predictable as a random number generator and as consistent as a nuzlocke not just suddenly killing your Pokemon out of the blue. They may do this, it may become worse, or it may stay as acceptable as it is now, or they may decide to do something else."
UA: "Yes, we'll have to wait and see. Hey, did you see the new Starters? I'm picking Fuecoco."
UD: F@#$ YOU, YOUR STARTER LOOKS LIKE S%@#! QUAXLY THE BEST!