Just answering the survey
Overall enjoyment: 5 (out of 10). It's not the worst I've ever seen, but there are problems that have persisted far too long this generation (more on that at the end!)
Overall competitive and balance: 3 (out of 10). I don't think this is the worst meta I've ever seen. Just clearly flawed and there is one end-all, be-all solution to make it demonstrably better.
The following are scale 1-5 (reminder for those who either haven't taken or looked at the OU Survey yet! Remember that your voice always matters, but also be respectful of everyone else's opinions!)
:Manaphy: (3)- Honestly? I don't like it, but I think we can hold off on the QB and give it a fair suspect once we eliminate the Real Problems. More on that later.
:Roaring Moon: (4) - I kinda hated this thing pre-DLC, and now with Knock off I hate it more. I've always hated the buff to Knock Off, hated its distribution, and hated its limited counterplay once MegaSton(k)s were gone. I feel like without knock, this thing is a 2 or 3.
But with Knock Off, it cripples any defensive switch-in by removing the item, has banded/boostered sun nonsense, AND is just a pain. It's the next
:Kingambit:. High Offense Dark Stab that has... what?
:Clefable: and
:Great Tusk: as reasonable resistant switch-ins? Lose your item, and revolve a few doors, and it's back to sweep again.
:Gliscor: (2) - HIGHLY controversial opinion coming in here, maybe the most contradictory thing I've ever written: I'm actually okay with Gliscor. It's an absolute PAIN to deal with, but... I think it's the only leg stall-type strategies realistically have to stand on. It's bulky, status immune, defensive tera to beat its checks, but i think part of its degeneracy is fixed with adjustments outside of outright banning the little guy. (I say "little" but Gliscor's dex actually say it's 6 feet tall. i think most of that is tail height, but still. Anyways, I digress).
I think after some major issues are resolved, then maybe we see where this fits into the meta, and assess "how" broken it is. It is broken. But maybe not as broken in a meta I'll get to later.
:Ogerpon-Wellspring: - (4) Mega- Simipour without the Mega-Stone. Or maybe Mega Ludicolo. Honestly? I don't pay attention to this pokemon half as much as I should. It's Stab is walled by Grass and Dragons, but of course it gets Knock Off. There might be some weird or niche viable answers that arise when the dust of the survey settles. I don't know if
:Chesnaught: is viable, but I think there are things could check it. It depends what the meta looks like after corrective action (broken record, I know). I think both this and Manaphy are too much for Rain, but I'm leaning towards this one being the problem due to dual Stab and Knock Off.
:Sneasler: (2) - Average mon with an uncompetitive literal RNG move. It's like a cheekier tri-attack. Sneasler is less like Sneasel and more like King's Rock Skill(less) Link. The move is the problem, otherwise this lonnnnnng Sneasel would just be decent, maybe even UU by now.
Congrats on
:Weavile: getting Knock Off, but this thing not. Otherwise, we'd be having a different conversation and I'd lean more towards the mon being the problem.
:Kingambit: (6) - I voted 5, but I want to make it clear that this "Pokemon" is a problem, and will always be a problem. Why a 6 vote? This thing 6-0s team with hardly any effort. It's ability is miserable to play against, and there are too many places where it just outright wins. Dark Stab is only resisted by Dark, Fairy, and Fighting, and this thing has Iron Head for Fairy types, so really only fighting types can comfortably switch into that normally.
Oh and
:Kingambit: resists its own stab. That's great counterplay.
Oh and
:Kingambit: has three different speed tier benchmarks. Fun to figure out which set and speed tier it is as it Kowtow Cleaves its way through your team.
I hate this thing, but I've always hated the entire Pawniard line, so it's no surprise I'd celebrate to never see this thing's name again.
:Gholdengo: (10 out of 5): this is the moment I've been building up to. This is about to get long, so
Rant about Gholdengo
Several months ago, when i was talking about the "Stranglehold of a pokemon with 30+% usage multiple consecutive months", there was an elephant named :Great Tusk: in the room. But I was talking about :Gholdengo:. I was talking about this format-warping, three immunity, Ultimate Spin-blocking, base 133 nearly unresisted Stab abomination that has continued to absolutely and wholly warp this entire generation. I hate hazards. I accept they are fundamental to the metagame, and any action on those would be an admission that they are inherently uncompetitive. This is why. :Gholdengo: removes nearly all counterplay for hazards simply by the threat of switching in. Remove this thing, and maybe we start seeing old defoggers come back to OU. Maybe we start seeing Rapid Spinners. Sure, the distribution is terrible, but those moves DON'T WORK against this.
Let me spell this out: Hazards are up (let's say 2x spikes and Stealth Rock). You send out literally any Defogger in Gen 8, the worst punish is that the opponent might send in a setup sweeper with defiant that forces you out, but at least you got a defog off.
In this gen, they send out :Gholdengo: and now your defog fails, you lose momentum, and whatever you send out has to either have HDB or take hazard chip AND base 133 SpAttk Stab. Yeah, sure that sounds fun. And the hazards stay. Pretty much the entire game is a headache until Gholdengo is gone, and that's doubly true when there is one on each team. Distribution won't fix how :Gholdengo: has completely, inherently shaped and warped the entirity of Gen 9 into hazard stax.
This thing needed to go seven months ago, and the format is still suffering because it exists. Oh? And what resists its Stab? Kingambit. This thing basically says "use :Kingambit: to answer me" and once :Kingambit: is gone, this miserable thing will continue to thrive and dominate by removing counterplay to hazards.
By banning :Gholdengo:, this frees the meta to evolve and diversify answers to hazards, and also not devote slots to answering the :Gholdengo: that is preventing you from removing hazards in the first place. Other spin-blockers may rise, other Competitive/Defiant might show up. Who knows? Beyond that is theroy-monning. My point is that this attrocity has single-handedly been controlling how entire teams are built. If :Gholdengo: weren't around, there would be more punish to three turns of spikes being spun of defogged away. Suddenly, unbreakable wall monsters like :Gliscor: might actually have a punish when a defogger switches into an eq, Defogs the spikes away, and smiles back at the little guy.
All of the other problematic mons in the tier are harder to evaluate because the entire metagame revolves around Hazards and
:Gholdengo: blocking hazard removal. Oh and
:Gholdengo: also blocks defog from removing screens, so that's another feather in the golden cap.
It probably can fit on every style of play, due to it's good defensive typing, high SpAttk, and reasonable speed tier. It does too much, and the meta needs it gone in order to grow. OU will still have problems, first and foremost OU needs to be rid of
:Gholdengo:
As for other actionable topics:
If
:Gholdengo: stays, hazards NEED to be discussed.
That's all I've got!