Okay... we have some problems.
Calm Chansey and Gloom pass the following test:
"Earn 2 EVs, get effort ribbon" - meaning that unless you accidentally Eved the wrong stat, they're good.
Murkrow gets an effort ribbon w/o any Eving (it's probably fine, I just need to do some math. :(
The other 3, however, is where we have a real problem. I gave them 2 EVs in defense, and then tried to give them an effort ribbon. They say they still need some more EVing.
Fortunately, I clone-backed everyone to you. There are several ways to go (EV berries, for example), but I think the most efficient way to "fix" the problem is to check thier stats at level 100 (wifi battles, set to level 100) and then check their stats to see if they have the right stats (yeah, math.).
Let me know what's what when you check your copies.