The Official Glyx said:I can say I believe there was insufficient (if any) reasoning and that it was mostly based on opinions and statistics founded upon opinions that got them banned if it makes you happier. Regardless, there was a lot more bias against Deoxys and Marshadow at the time, since Deoxys' suspect came much too shortly after the banning of accuracy-lowering moves, giving the meta hardly any time to settle, resulting in accuracy-lowering Deoxys still being the set that comes to mind when you think of Deoxys.
You're right that maybe the suspect was interfered with by the ban of accuracy-reducing moves. But people still had to take time to ladder for reqs and experience the metagame in its new state. And with that being the case, obviously a no-longer-legal set wouldn't "come to mind."
As for Marshadow, I unfortunately have to repeat myself, the boon in popularity that just about any new mon gets right after they've been released pushed Marshadow way further than its actual viability would allow it. Moreover, the community wasn't even solidly certain as to whether Marshadow should be banned or not, and if they seemed like they were, it was only because of some people spreading misinformation about how it beats 70~ % of the meta.
Nothing happened "right after" it was released. Don't you remember DEG urging caution repeatedly as people were crying to ban it immediately? The metagame was given time to adapt. Unfortunately, that adaptation manifested itself in unpleasant ways, and Marshadow warped teambuilding significantly. And as far as the numbers are concerned, speak for yourself. It's unfair to characterize most voters' decision-making processes based on what you
assume they relied on to make their decisions.
Ultimately, I don't believe the dictator ban was the way to go here. These kinds of moderation should only be used for either changing mechanics/clauses/etc or obvious things like Perish Song or Mega Rayquaza, not for something that can be debated and even WAS being debated.
This is just a difference of opinion. There's plenty of precedent for quickbanning in a variety of formats. Perish Song was debated, too, and you don't seem to have a problem with that quickban. Consider that some people might see Marshadow the way you see Perish Song.
That said, you probably have your own way of running things that is likely very different from mine, which I suppose would mean we've arrived at an impasse where neither one of us will be "right". I apologize for displeasing you, but I intend on staying with my belief that we need to outline a new definitive point in which a mon or concept becomes too overcentralizing or "broken". I say a new point because we technically already have one, being half or more of the meta, but since there are already multiple other mons that have reached and surpassed this point, it likely isn't too relevant for modern day 1v1. I believe something closer to beating 60-70% of the meta would be fair for being considered broken, either way, having a point like this (and stressing how important it is) would help to provide potential suspect voters a basic idea of how they should go about deciding their votes, as well as cut back on all the arguments of "X 50/50's Y and Z, therefore X is broken".
This isn't related to your above argument about how we banned things for being annoying in the slightest, so I'm not sure why it's in this post. But I'll address it regardless:
there is not and will never be a mathematical percentage that equates to brokenness. This reminds me of something I see Gojira Poo saying a lot in the 1v1 room, which is that we have to decide how powerful we want the meta to be overall by drawing a line somewhere. Unfortunately, brokenness is a purely subjective criterion. We just have to do the best we can to reach a consensus. Mathematical solutions are problematic as well because you have to deal with, as you rightly pointed out, incorporating a Pokemon's viability into the percentage by weighting it somehow. Let's just try to stay away from this territory.
For what it's worth, I'll try to make less volatilely-worded posts in the future, but I still intend on spreading the mathematical truth where I have to, and my own two cents otherwise, as well as making my best efforts to clarify between the two when necessary.
Once again, this issue had nothing to do with mathematical truth. But I am sorry for singling you out regardless. I had seen similar reasoning from other well-respected users like Kentari and just wanted to set the record straight.
edit: I realize that the suspect philosophy contains a line about beating more than half of the metagame, as Glyx quite rightly points out. I believe that it might be worthwhile to rework the suspect philosophy a bit in the future, but also I was basing my line about percentages on the general policies of other tiers and OMs.