motherlove said:"b) usually done better elsewhere" Not really. MG Diancie needs its 4 moveslots (LoR, HJK, Flare Blitz, Head Smash) if it wants to reliably beat Ho-Oh + Regi + Slowbro + Aegi + Venusaur and still fails to deal with the quite common flash fire Aegislash, Protean can deal with all of them including ff Aegi AND have STAB priority AND still have a free moveslot for like king's Shield or something and if you think having a free moveslot isn't a big deal than... idk dude, think again. Meanwhile it's still way easier to imposterproof (Gira, Grass type, Fur coat mon...). Neither gale wing Ray or Prankster Ray are anywhere near being a decent lure to aerilate Ray and unless it's clicking superpower on the Ttar switch, contrary doesn't do nearly enough immediate damage to just kill the Ray answer. That MMY + Gengar is from a team I ran which used Yveltal as imposterproofing. That MMX loses to the most common Ho-Oh set (magic guard) and the most common giratina set (Ph) while struggling to deal with slowbros and I don't see how straight up OHKOing all of them after rocks would be considered "not dealing with it very well" by any stretch. Not to mention it's still an extremely good set on its own.
It doesn't need flare blitz at all lol.
0 Atk Life Orb Mega Diancie Head Smash vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Mega Venusaur: 199-234 (54.6 - 64.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO. It can then run either that free slot, and being walled by fur coat is a lot worse than being walled by FF aegi, especially since you deal 34-48 depending on the Aegislash.
Gale wings, Contrary, and prankster rays are great lures, idk what you mean there. Clicking CC isn't really needed either, because 252 SpA Mega Rayquaza Draco Meteor vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Mega Tyranitar: 172-204 (42.5 - 50.4%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Poison Heal. Admittedly FF steels do switch in to MRay if it doens't click Superpower, except
wait
+2 252 SpA Mega Rayquaza Draco Meteor vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Registeel: 190-224 (52.1 - 61.5%) -- 97.7% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
they aren't staying in. All three of those also hit imposter's (unlike your set) which is sweet as those can switch in on Aerilate ray. If I need to elaborate more just ask, but I think I said it pretty well.
How in the world does it struggle to deal with non magic bounce slowbros? I suppose they might get lucky with a burn, but with knock off you only need 1 3 turn sleep and they flat out lose, ntm that every 2 turn sleep has them losing health. PH tina does wall if its already poisoned, which isn't that unreasonable at all, but that doesn't make blizzard MMX anything other than complete shit (ntm that it still isn't a guaranteed ohko)
I mean you could theatrically run something else but there's absolutely no reason to since protean is just better 90% of the time. I think you're underestimating the effect of having a STAB on what is essentially a coverage move.
That's not even mentioning the purely stallbreaking protean sets, have fun switching in a STAB lo boosted v-create from a base 190 atk and then finding another switchin for play rough. Mixed protean ray sets. Mixed protean ray sets with cc-Tarrows / pixie judgement / boomburst / bolt strike for example have close to 0 reliable switchins and aren't even particularly reliant on predicts to net kills.
252+ Atk Choice Band Protean Mega Mewtwo X Play Rough vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Fur Coat Giratina: 206-246 (40.9 - 48.9%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
I get this point, but this isn't a symptom of protean, it's a symptom of BH having a million stalbreakers.
For instance, this is a thing: 252+ SpA Choice Specs Palkia Water Spout (150 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Eviolite Chansey in Heavy Rain: 313-369 (44.4 - 52.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock
I mean, yes PH tina can switch in if max spd, but it just takes one spacial rend to change that up. I'd use Char-Y because of its higher spa, but at least flash fire is viable. Stallbreaking protean is a waste of a protean slot (and this is even wallable with your own chansey, since they wont have choice specs).
Since getting passed a newly discovered counter is as simple as changing a slot, protean can also adapt to the new counters way faster than new counters can be found. My Ho-Oh already got destroyed by psystrike a bunch of times on the ladder and I wouldn't even be surprised if ppl started running spiky shield again if scarf garchomp becomes a thing.
Also MMY could beat chansey easily if nubs stopped running secret sword and ran like cc or focus blast but I feel like I've already said that before.
When you see a pokemon you can relatively know what can switch in based on its stab moves but with protean you have absolutely no idea since it literally turns a pokemon into a completely different one.
I'm just quoting that because it's a great summary of some of the points that were made. Being able to OHKO fat mons with neutral coverage is something that only protean can do.
What. First off, protean doesn't have coverage lol; that's like saying that Frosttom's boltbeam is coverage.
Secondly, every protean set has a counter. It might not have the same counters, but every set I've seen is walled by at least one set on a good stall team. There are easily a dozen mons for which that isn't true, so that's not really a good argument. Protean does have the major advantage of badly injuring offense as well, but there isn't a mon B ranked or higher that has a guaranteed counter for all its sets.
Finally, protean desn't really change what the mon is. MMY will always be a special attacker, Deoxys-A will be frail AF regardless of what type it is, Mega Latios will walways be a middling fast nuke... they do play differently depending on the types run, but its the difference between Diancie and MRay rather than PDon vs Maggron
Kingslayer2779 said:Sheddy and Imposter aren't broken by BH standards for multiple reasons. We talked about them in depth over and over and over again. I suggest you revisit some of the arguments. Flint even explains in the op how Imposter and Shed fails to meet BH's ban criteria. So the premise of your question isn't even valid. There is no precedent in BH of letting broken check broken. As for the question itself Protean isn't enough of a hindrance to -ate to justify the brokeness it brings into BH. King's Shield itself is a much bigger hindrance to -ate and King's Shield is good on non-protean sets and can still check -ate without it.
^ Basically this. As much as I like protean, keeping it in to check ate is a terrible reason to keep it. If ate gets banned because protean was banned and protean was the only thing saving it, then -ate needs to go too. It's that simple.
peaswar said:Honestly, protean shouldn't exist at all. It makes greninja, that has a wide range of attacks that can deal damage. In balanced hackmons, any pokemon can have protean, and any pokemon can use any move, and you never can plan for a pokemon properly with protean around
OK.
I'm writing this to get it off my chest, mostly, so feel free to tear it apart. That being said, here are my thoughts on protean, laid out in a reasonably clear and comprehensive manner. For a lot of this I'll be sticking with MMY, as it is hands down the best protean mon, but most of it is applicable to the other users.
First off, protean can only really be considered for the broken type of ban- it isn't rng based and is actually trying to win, so it isn't uncompetitive. It isn't overcentralizing, as its answers aren't bad by themselves in any way, nor is it overly difficult to build without. This is pretty obvious, so I'm sure you all knew this, but I want to establish that that's the only argument on this I'm dealing with. That being said, lets look at the criteria for an ablity ban:
E4 Flint said:Ability Ban
:
The power to set nearly any ability that a 'mon would prefer almost ideally, is the second most defining and important property of BH, so I will go through it next. Most of the logic will be similar to the above. An Ability should be considered for ban if:
- It can either provide an inherent skill that is so good that it can be slapped onto nearly any 'mon, regardless of role, stat spread or moveset. This is true with Shadow Tag and Wonder Guard, which can work on offensive and defensive Pokemon alike, and as Classic Hackmons have proven, can be run on any Pokemon, be it an LC mon or Rayquaza-Mega
- Or the ability can so augment the capabilities of the 'mon it is on that the set in question would be difficult or impossible to check or counter. This is similar to the last point on Pokemon ban above, but it is an important distinction, since this implies that the power originates from the ability and that the choice of 'mon, item and even moveset, is irrelevant. Pure Power/Huge Power and Parental Bond fall into this category
The first one is, again, an obvious no. Protean can only be run on specific mons- notably, those with an at least passable speed tier (>100) with (a) good attacking stat(s). If you try and run it on chansey it will suck, despite both chansey and protean being great.
The second, however, is a much closer thing. With 7 moves, protean mons kill literally everything in the tier, and with 4 they make a pretty good go at it. However, the moveset still matters. Only 1 set can beat imposter reliably (SP judgement), only one beats Shedinja (Magma Storm), and a few moves are each specifically required for a given threat, like Sludge Wave for Maudino and Psystrike for Ho-Oh. The nuetral coverage isn't that important either bar for dark types, making it only really good for Boomburst, Spooky judgement, and SE hits. Otherwise, Tinted Lens Psystrike hits just as hard, esp when you consider how its only 1 move needed. If you need to hit every bulky mon SE, that isn't a broken attacker.
As it happens, however, that isn't all protean does. Not only does it give a 50% boost to nonstab moves, it also changes your type. This allows for a bunch of neat tricks, like Kings sheilding to avoid ate or ghost judgementing to kill imposter. To me, this is where the real pro-ban argument lies- Changing types is really freaking amazing. To me, it still doesn't add up to enough for a ban, but if there is something I'm misunderstanding please let me know,