CallMeLefty said:I am going to stop answering those, because we are both repeating the same arguments over and over again.
CallMeLefty said:First off, I am sorry, but this is proving my point:you are using the word "counter" inappropriately. mRay does not counter Mega gengar. You have to be able to reliably switch into it multiple times. Countering is a purely defensive notion, that mezns you completely handle any set, and for any given time: switching into A mon when your opponent has its counter means basically giving him a free switchin into said counter
On a sidenote, there was a counter to Lando-I, Cresselia.
You are saying that usage is not important, yet it is: having a 25% chance to lose to MMY if I carry just one check to it is inacceptable, while rayquaza with close combat is extremely rare(you mit be thinking of earth power, and it leads my to my next argument). Usage also means that saying "soundproof audino counters" is not sufficient when pioison attacks on MMY are more common than soundproof on M-Audino (an extreme example of this would be that guy on YT saying unban Mega luke from ubers, volcarona checks it if it doesnt have stone edge).
That isn't proving your point at all? Countering means being able to switch in on it and beat it 100% of the time, bar hax, which MRay does. Switching in multiple times is merely a nice bonus if it happens. Look here:
http://www.smogon.com/smog/issue32/checks-and-counters
If you replace mamoswine with, say, Garchomp, or if mamoswine could live an iron head+sucker punch! then you have your example of an offensive mon countering something.
On second thought, you're all intelligent, you can read it yourself and decide weather or not you think the conclusion I have drawn is the correct one.
As it happens, I am, in fact, thinking of close combat MRay, one of its best sets. It being rare is both literally and figuratively irrelevant to the conversation at hand. If anything, commonality of soundproof MAudino is also not an issue because it just mean that MMY isn't a big enough threat to people's teams for them to find it worthwhile.
I would be interested to know how protean lets offense shine, because MMY is quite impossible to revenge kill (unless you run 2/3 specific mons aka overcentralization). This is also the difference with mega gengar: king's shield forces a 50/50, it does not completely neuter -aters. And it does not protect you from oblivion rayquaza. Both of which protean ks does.
Finally, "strive for least impact" philosophy is not an uber-like conception to me (only ban extremely broken things) but simply an extension of avoiding complex bans(which is needed in a meta where everything is possible). If BH was just like uber, I doubt we would have banned parental bond or others, who do have common checks. Also, about the question of overcentralization, there is a massive difference between chansey/shedinja, for which preparing brings creativity and isnt that hard, and protean. The formers greatly shape the metagame, yet it is, as ive said before, a bit like SR: they are not over powered, and let new pokemon shine.
Protean lets offense shine by virtue of only being runnable on offense. Even if protean was broken, it still wouldn't invalidate offense as it requires offense to use. This means the only teams that could so easily counter offense would be offense themselves. It isn't just an extension of avoiding complex bans, either- in BH, broken checks broken. This is even stated in the OP- the goal is to keep everything in the tier if we can, and to ban as little as possible if we can'. Just wanting new mons to have a chance to shine isn't enough.
To me, it simply seems that protean fits the second reason as to why an ability should be banned, "the ability can so augment the capabilities of the 'mon it is on that the set in question would be difficult or impossible to check or counter.". Protean does greatly augment the ´mon (as well demonstrated by one of the previous post), and protean is indeed both hard to counter AND to check. There is no viable revenge killer to MMY while there is to all the threats you mentionned, meaning that it is almost impossible to check.
That's only half the definition, though. The choice of item, moves, and mon has to be irrelevant. Chansey, for instance, requires a very specific combination- MMY, Secret Sword, and LO- and still isn't a guaranteed 2HKO, and still doesn't beat all Chansey sets. MMY can pick and choose what it beats, yes, but the more it deviates from what is good, the less it actually does. For instance, you can’t beat imposter and Shedinja with the same set, no matter what you do; you can’t beat imposter and FC Chans with the same set, you can’t beat Maudino and Chansey with the same set, even if you predict perfectly, without losing to just about everything else.*
The Guy Who Has Many Alts said:I am having trouble understanding why an ability with literally 0 drawbacks that can be used on literally any mon with >150 offense and essentially outshines every other abilities in terms of wall breaking power isn't broken.
The Guy Who Has Many Alts said:Here is a list of what protean can do
- 2HKO over 90% of the metagame with just Ghost/Fighting or Fairy/Ground coverage
- Can't be revenge killed by most forms of priority thanks to King's Shield
- Still has another moveslot to invalidate one of its very very few counters
- Slappable on almost any mon (such as M-Ray, and even M-Diancie) making perfect lures for their would be checks.
- Extremely easy to imposter proof with plates
- Very unpredictable and again, can be used with any mons with any moves.
Thank you :) This is well laid out, insightful, and detailed
- It can 2hko 90% of the metagame, but it misses out on the really important kills, like Chansey, Ho-Oh, Shedinja and Maudino, while at the same time missing out on important offensive OHKOs like Rayquaza (set 1) or MMY/MLati@s (set 2, plus Mlatias for set 1). Obviously not enough to make it bad or nonthreatening, but at the same time it is worth noting that it doesn't just steamroller everything. And what’s more? That all 90% status is entirely dependent on the skill of the player- a better opponent will still usually avoid that loss, or at least put it up in the air.
Can you find another ability that is as good as Protean?
No other ability gives as much flexibility, unpredictability and wallbreaking power as Protean.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/balancedhackmons-306644884
This replay shows just how flexible and unpredictable Protean is. It can be used as an amazing lure and since it gains STAB for all of its moves, even uninvested SE coverage can 2HKO bulky walls such as Giratina and Yveltal (although this replay didn't show that but trust me, with just a couple of EVs into spatk that Mewtwo can 2HKO both of them)
There definitely isn’t any given ability that is as good as protean for all the mons that can use it. –ate, Mold Breaker, Poison Heal, and tinted lens to an extent come close though. Maybe Unaware or Prankster, but idrts. The more important question imo is whether it’s enough better than every other ability to be banworthy.
MAMP said:You seem to be a bit confused as to what the difference between a check and a counter is. A counter is a Pokemon that can consistently and reliably switch into the majority of a Pokemon's sets, and beat it 1v1. A check is a Pokemon that, while it generally wins 1v1, struggles to consistently switch in or loses to a common variant of the set. You said that Mega Ray is a counter to Mega Gengar, but this is not the case. While it is true that Mega Ray can switch into Mega Gengar and not be OHKO'd and then OHKO MGar in return with Espeed, it isn't a counter because it takes like 75% to do so. It can't switch in more than once, and it can't switch in at all if its taken a bit of prior damage. An example of a counter to Mega Gengar is PH Yveltal, which can easily take even boosted hits from Mega Gengar, recover off the damage, and OHKO with Knock Off. Yveltal can deal with Mega Gengar consistently and repeatedly; this is what makes it a counter, rather than a check.
What. Like seriously, what are you saying here? If you have another, more updated source I'll withdraw this (I’m actually legitimately interested outside of this, as it offends my sensibilities to have to link to a BW source) but in the article I linked that isn't at all a requirement. Admittedly my example wasn't all that amazing because stealth rocks are a thing, but with them not up/with a slightly weaker attacker MRay can very well function as a counter.
Now that thats cleared up, I want to look at Protean Mewtwo Y. You've talked before about M2Y's supposed counters, and I want to examine that. What counters Protean M2Y? First, lets evaluate the standard and most common set, Spooky Plate Judgment/Secret Sword/King's Shield/Boomburst|Quiver Dance|occasionally Sludge Bomb. Here's a list of every somewhat viable counter I could come up with.
Mega Audino can beat many variants of this set, but it loses to Sludge Bomb and it's very shaky against Boomburst sets.
252 SpA Protean Mega Mewtwo Y Boomburst vs. 248 HP / 252+ SpD Mega Audino: 190-225 (46.4 - 55%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock
Additionally, SpDef spreads can be 2HKO'd by +1 Secret Sword.
Magic Guard SpDef Ho-Oh does generally counter this set, but it's 2HKO'd by +1 Judgment and can't OHKO M2Y in return, making it a bit shaky. In any case, SpDef Ho-oh is a fairly niche set that was literally devised specifically to beat M2Y. It would likely get very little usage if Protean M2Y weren't around, so the prevalence of this set I would argue is testament to Protean's centralisation of the meta more than anything.
Fur Coat Chansey is probably the most reliable counter to this set, but even that has to play 50/50s against Quiver Dance+Secret Sword sets. Regardless, FC Chansey is quite possibly the most passive, momentum-sucking Pokemon in the tier, and it really isn't the sort of Pokemon that most teams want to be running; the fact that so many offense and balance builds are slapping on FC Chansey just to cover Protean (and other miscellaneous threats) is honestly pretty gross and really says a lot about the sorry state of the current meta.
Shedinja does beat this, but we all know how unreliable Shed is a counter to anything.
Yveltal does decently, but depending on its spread it struggles to take Secret Sword or Boomburst, especially with Stealth Rock up.
The only decent RegenVest Pokemon that can take this on is Xerneas, as all of the others are either weak to Judgment or don't have the bulk to take Secret Sword. However, even this has to run a subpar Specially Defensive spread or it risks being 2HKOd by Judgment after rocks, and in any case this is an extremely uncommon set. And, similar to Ho-oh, this is a set that exists specifically because Protean M2Y is so prevalent, and as such I'm kinda reluctant to list it as a counter to it seeing as its a set that basically wouldn't be used if Protean weren't around.
That's it. Every other at-least-somewhat-viable Pokemon in the tier cannot stand up to Judgment + Secret Sword. That is a grand total of 6 Pokemon, all of which have to be at close to full health to avoid being 2HKO'd switching in, all of which can lose to fairly common coverage options, the majority of which are passive, defensive Pokemon that don't really fit onto most teams that well, 2 of which are used almost solely because they can counter M2Y, and one of which is Shedinja which is extremely unreliable. That is an extremely sparse and inconsistent collection of counters. And that's not even mentioning its other sets! The Life Orb set that bp scrub brought up beats basically all of these Pokemon, the Earth Plate set can beat quite a few, and the Tail Glow set that I used against InfernapeTropius11 in the BH Open here can beat most of M2Y's standard counters pretty easily too - in this replay it gets past an FC Chansey, a SpDef Ho-oh, and a MAudino, all of which were at full health.
Your replay isn't the greatest either, as you needed a crit to accomplish it (not even getting into how easily he could have messed you up with whirlwind or metal burst, or even parting shot had he carried one of them, or how sacred fire, his other fire stab option, doesn't make contact).
Now, you could argue that this is not something unique to Protean, that any offensive Pokemon in BH can beat its usual checks and counters with particular coverage moves, and you wouldn't be wrong. Mega Gengar can pack Sludge Bomb to beat MAudino, PH Kyogre can run King's Shield to avoid being revenge killed by -ates, etc. However, the difference between these examples and Protean is that these Pokemon have to sacrifice something to run these coverage options, whereas Protean - by virtue of the fact that it already beats like 95% of the tier with 3 moves - doesn't really lose any functionality when it slaps on some random coverage move. I'll use Mold Breaker Mega Gengar as an example. The standard set is Spooky Plate Judgment/Secret Sword/Pursuit/Shell Smash|Quiver Dance. If Mega Gengar wants to run Sludge Bomb to hit MAudino, it has to sacrifice an important move to do so - if it drops Pursuit then it can't trap Shed, if it drops its boosting move then it has trouble sweeping and can't break through a lot of mons that it would be able to otherwise, and if it drops Secret Sword then it loses the ability to get past Darks and Normals. There's an actual tradeoff there; MGar is sacrificing functionality in order to beat MAudino. On the other hand, M2Y doesn't sacrifice anything by slapping on Boomburst, or Sludge Bomb, or Quiver Dance, or Tail Glow, or Infestation, or Spore. It achieves what it needs to with just 3 moveslots, and the fourth is completely free, just icing on the cake. This gives Protean a truly unparalleled level of versatility, and this in my opinion is the crucial factor as to why its worthy of a ban.
This sorta belongs above as well, but I had other stuff I wanted to say there, too. If your MMY runs, for whatever reason, sludge bomb, you lose evrythign that makes MMY good- its ability to beat imposter. With sludge bomb, Chansey uses its ability to avoid the 2hko from even SE judgement and then turns to badly injure you with sludge bomb, to the point that 2 imp Chanseys will beat you (1 if it wins the ties). Face it- if you run these moves, you are sacrificing general utility, in the same way that MGar does! If there was an MMY set that didn't sacrifice utility to beat its checks and counters, it would simply be the MMY set and everything else wouldn't be worth talking about. MMY usually can achieve most of what it wants in 3 moves, but in running that fourth move it can mess up what it had before (like magma storm on spooky plate sets) or don't add much most of the time (like running tail glow is a useless slot if your opponent lacks a fc Chans to wall it unboosted, or if their Maudino is unaware like Kingslayer’s). This to me is a problem, as MMY with just its 3 moves isn’t broken.
To recap: Protean M2Y beats the vast majority of offensive Pokemon 1v1 due to its phenomenal speed tier, immense power and ability to run perfect coverage unimpeded by its typing. This forces every team to run defensive counters to it, because offensive checks are practically non-existent; yet M2Y has a pathetically small list of supposed counters, and every single one either loses to common variants, is extremely passive and thus poorly suited for most team archtypes, is mediocre outside of beating M2Y, or some combination of these. Additionally, M2Y can customise its set to effectively pick and choose its counters without hindering its ability to perform its usual roles, which overall means that teams generally have to run multiple checks and counters to M2Y to avoid just getting blown away by it (and even this is sometimes not enough). This is making the metagame extraordinarily centralised, it limits the potential for variety and creativity in teambuilding, and generally makes the tier less fun to play (I'm fully aware that that last one is a purely subjective judgement). And this isn't even to mention the other viable Protean mons: M2X, which does most of the same things as M2Y but with a worse speed tier and less ability to run anti-Imposter sets; Mega Latios and Mega Rayquaza, which are even harder to wall than M2Y at the cost of some speed; and other miscellaneous niche Protean mons which can be used to lure in specific defensive Pokemon. Protean has a stranglehold on the metagame, and tbh I can't wait to be rid of it.
I'd add a fourth category of easily pressured (FC Chans honestly only fits under this one, as even offensive teams usually need an imp proofer and it’s just that good), but tbh this is the single best argument for banning protean, and I don't really have much of a way to counter it. All I can really offer is that MMY almost always performs well, well below its theoretical potential (honestly I haven’t seen a single high ladder match where it has), and that it just doesn’t seem broken to me. I know that that’s also a bad metric, and thatobviously all the other things brought out before were worse or this would have been suspected first, but even within the current metagame banning protean is a huge departure from the mental image I have of BH. As bad as you are all saying protean is, I never have problems with it, it never annoys my teams in the slightest, and it doesn’t have the same impact as, say, chatter and assist did.
Now, some nitpicking:
Literally not one of these examples is relevant. Levitate steels are extremely uncommon and generally fairly mediocre, and they have been since the release of TArrows. PH Ho-oh is shit and nobody ever uses it - and in any case it gets clean OHKO'd by this M2Y set if rocks are up. bp scrub mentioned both Chansey and Shedinja as exceptions in his post. Max SpDef AV Regirock under sand is hardly a common threat in BH, and the fact that this mon has a very solid chance to 2HKO a fairly bulky, fully SpDef invested Pokemon at what is effectively +2 SpDef is a testament to how broken it is more than anything. Sand TTar is 2HKO'd (unless this one is AV too):
252 SpA Life Orb Protean Mega Mewtwo Y Earth Power vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Mega Tyranitar in Sand: 218-260 (53.9 - 64.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
I'm also not getting why you dislike PH Ho-Oh so much. It requires the same support as shed, allowing it to work on those teams very well, has extra utility in beating MMY, beats imposters, is a nice special switch, a decent status sponge, a good Diancie impproofer (esp if you decide to run magma storm to take on opposing sheds. I've seen it used very well, although admittedly that might just be because I don't run SR.
In what world are levitate steels mediocre? PBlades is the go-to coverage on Diancie, and most mons with ground attacks are the same (I'm looking at you MMX, MRay). Tarrows is just too weak to be common on things other than, say, PDon, who already has v-create as the only nuke it needs.
The shed and Chansey were there for completeness in my list, I did see that he had them.
AV is the only reason to use sand TTar, so yes it’s AV. Still, even, say, a CB set would work by virtue of living a hit and OHKOing back (75% to KO in a neutral form like KS, much less if they moonblasted)
Cresselia is barely a relevant Pokemon in current BH, and its 2HKO'd by Boomburst anyway. The only really common Soundproof mon is MSlowbro, which gets nearly OHKO'd by Moonblast, and there are no other Soundproof Pokemon relevant enough to be used as a true counterargument here.
Yeah, Cresselia is barely relevant; it’s just the first that came to mind. Most any prankster *does* work here, though, especially since Priority status is by no means bad (also hurts –ate when it tries to hit coverage/BB, can help setup sweeping, Priority recovery is sweet, and it gives a select few pokemon stab special priority).
I’d also argue that Soundproof Don and Maudino are also relevant, but the former doesn’t actually beat MMY and the latter is just an extension of Maudino walling.
Also, completely irrelevant aside: using decimate to mean destroy is not improper usage. Language is ultimately defined by how its speakers use it, and the vast vast majority of english speakers use the word decimate to mean 'destroy' and have done so for hundreds of years; it hasn't meant 'to remove one tenth' for a very long time. Correcting people when they say this makes you seem like a pretentious twat.
Yeah IK, it’s just a stupid pet peeve of mine. Also it is still... ok I’ll actually shut up on it
*Bar luck; I’m sure speed ties or crits or misses or what have you could allow it.
almost completely irrelevant but because I was bored
Plase don’t take this as a serious addition to the discussion, and as I said in the title of this it’s just niche garbage, but hey. We must go nicher!
If we want to get even more counters for this pokemon, there are a couple more like MPert, specifically EVd PH Ogre, FC Dialga, anything with prankster that lives a hit, Specdef MRay (puke), specdef FC arc (doesn’t even need AV woo!), Specdef Zekrom/Mampharos (very specific ev spread there)(I guss it has volt switch lol), PH/Vest Reshiram, and assault vest shaymin/Suicune/manaphy.