Quantum Tesseract said:⠀⠀While it is true that lots of things can't be trapped by Shadow Tag Gar, it doesn't have to kill the entire team. Not every Pokemon in a team can afford to run one of the aforementioned options, and it is these that are the main targets. Although this isn't as much of a problem for more offensive teams, removing just one wall from a balance or stall team can make it fall apart. For example, if the opposing team uses a Poison Heal Audino to block sleep and a Fur Coat Chansey as an Ate counter, trapping and killing either of these with Mega Gengar would let me abuse sleep or -Ate afterwards due to the hole created. The main issue I have is that there is nothing the opponent can do to stop this. I could literally switch in Mega Gar every time I see Fur Coat Chansey, and all it can do is U-turn out every time or die. Unlike other stallbreakers, there is no opportunity for the opponent to choose to sack something else instead and revenge or switch to a counter. This is why I find Shadow Tag Gengar so uncompetitive.One thing that makes me reluctant to ban manual MGar is that it gains very little. Sure it gets a better premega ability and moves, but it already had most of the moves it needed/wanted (taunt, Psong, its stabs) and everything can theoretically defeat it. In order to avoid trapping, you need one of 5 things: Shed Shell, a pivot move, a ghost typing, Soundproof, or offensive presence. The second option stops it from beating balance, the 5th from beating most offense, the 3rd from trapping 2 of the greatest bulkmons (aegislash, Giratina) who are also some of its biggest targets due to being weak to its stab. Even on other playstyles, you can escape by sacrificing a movelot, item, or ability. It might be uncompetative, but to me it seems like confuse ray in standard- unquestionably noncompetitive, but just not good enough for a ban.
⠀⠀Something interesting to note is that even Soundproof isn't a perfect counter to this strategy. Like what would have happened in the replay I posted earlier, had I not frozen and killed Steelix, you can actually deplete a Soundproof user's Recover PP using 5-6 Encores. Locking them into another move like Stealth Rock or Metal Burst can kill them as well if you carry an attacking move. I've already addressed in my previous post things like Shed Shell, pivoting, and offensive presence, but I'll reiterate them and expand a bit here.
Again
Shed Shell: As Knock Off is omnipresent in the current meta, you are forced to play extremely safely if Shadow Tag Gengar is on the opposing team, scouting for random Knock Off and being unable to come in on Knock Off users. This can be a large burden, reducing the usefulness of it in the match. (For example, Mega Audino can't counter Mega Tyranitar anymore or it will be able to be trapped.) Also things like Chansey or Poison Heal users can't afford to hold Shed Shell, and normal things greatly appreciate opening up an item slot so they can run Safety Goggles or Leftovers.
Pivot Moves: Pivots, like any other wall, still need to Recover after taking damage from attacks and hazards. It is impossible to always be using a pivot move, since pivots naturally take damage after switching in. Eventually they need to Recover, and this leaves them vulnerable to Shadow Tag Gar. Even things like Regenerator pivots become almost useless, since if they pretty much any move other than U-turn Gar can trap them. This means that Regenerator Registeel can't Metal Burst and kill Specs Mega Rayquaza, or it dies as well afterwards.
Offensive Presence: It is perfectly correct that things faster than Gengar (and Ghost types) cannot be trapped and killed. However, currently there is a large reward for using bulky attackers like Mega Tyranitar. While Gengar cannot safely switch in directly, there are ways to circumvent this using slow pivots. Even bulky attackers often like using moves like King's Shield, Stealth Rock, and Recover, so with predictions or slow pivoting Gengar can still trap and kill these. The two experimental sets I posted earlier also bypass this weakness somewhat, and I'm sure there are other unexplored ways to deal with this.
Pivot Moves: Pivots, like any other wall, still need to Recover after taking damage from attacks and hazards. It is impossible to always be using a pivot move, since pivots naturally take damage after switching in. Eventually they need to Recover, and this leaves them vulnerable to Shadow Tag Gar. Even things like Regenerator pivots become almost useless, since if they pretty much any move other than U-turn Gar can trap them. This means that Regenerator Registeel can't Metal Burst and kill Specs Mega Rayquaza, or it dies as well afterwards.
Offensive Presence: It is perfectly correct that things faster than Gengar (and Ghost types) cannot be trapped and killed. However, currently there is a large reward for using bulky attackers like Mega Tyranitar. While Gengar cannot safely switch in directly, there are ways to circumvent this using slow pivots. Even bulky attackers often like using moves like King's Shield, Stealth Rock, and Recover, so with predictions or slow pivoting Gengar can still trap and kill these. The two experimental sets I posted earlier also bypass this weakness somewhat, and I'm sure there are other unexplored ways to deal with this.






