• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

DP Tier Discussion Thread - BL and UU

Status
Not open for further replies.
According to last month's Shoddybattle statistics, Crobat would actually be extremely close to OU! His cumulative percentage of 76.31% (or 77.21% if you consider the weighted list) is just short of my cutoff point of 75% to be considered OU.
/discussion
True, true. And I didn't do LO since LO'Bat dies really hard with SR around.
 
According to last month's Shoddybattle statistics, Crobat would actually be extremely close to OU! His cumulative percentage of 76.31% (or 77.21% if you consider the weighted list) is just short of my cutoff point of 75% to be considered OU.

Might have already been mentioned but we must remember that alot of people run hypnosis with brave bird/nasty plot on Shoddy because 1. They make for great sets and you can get away with it, and 2. Some people just don't realise they're illegal.

I guarantee Crobat usage will drop once/if such movesets are banned.
 
Stats are from ladder, though, where I would imagine enough people know about it and where you can actually get a match posthumously forfeited if it's brought to attention. I'm sure it influenced it a little but I doubt illegal movesets have significant contribution to ladder usage stats.
 
I'd say it's U-turn, huge base speed, and Hypnosis alone.
Any Nasty Plot set can be walled pretty easily and Brave Bird doesn't help him if you're using him to scout the opponent's team.
 
Has primeape been moved up to BL yet? Nothing in the UU environment can counter it effectively, even the analysis states that.

I think Primeape is one of those pokemon that doesn't have a 100% counter but can be beaten by prediction (Scyther can come in on Close Combat or EQ, is faster and threatens with AA, Nidoking/queen can come in on Close Combat or Stone Edge and use EQ), in addition to being fairly fragile. Actually, Hitmonlee is just as or more worrisome than Primape in this regard (120 attack vs 105, 87 speed vs 95).
 
Wasn't Kangaskhan being discussed? Really, you're only one prediction away from being stomped on by it.
 
Alrighty, so sorry if this is a stupid question, but I'm just wondering if the tiers were going to be updated when the new site is released, it would make sense, but if not, then that's all good too. Just wondering.
 
Also, when this discussion dies (which it looks like it has) will NU be discussed?

Well, the discussion has died down quite a bit, and while we've determined the tiers of a few pokemon, there hasn't been a real conclusion on some of them. Back to the list...

UU's to be tested.
-Walrein
-Glaceon
-Pinsir
-Cacturne
-Lapras
-Ninetales
-Poliwrath
-Hitmonlee
-Leafeon
-Clefable
-Kangaskhan

From my experience, the two of those that really deserve BL are Hitmonlee and Clefable. Hitmonlee plain just hits too hard with Close Combat and has enough coverage that nothing in UU can really take it's hits. Clefable isn't as outright powerful as Hitmonlee but has a huge amount of options, and the more defensive sets are very difficult to stop without a Fighting type (in UU, all of whom are pretty frail with the exception of Top and Poliwrath, should he remain UU). I'm still of the opinion that the rest of them deserve further testing, though BL does seem likely for some (mainly Pinsir, Wrath, and Glaceon).
 
Can someone explain to me why alakazam is in the BL list...
130 attack 120 speed coupled with a monster move pool :|

Because he isn't popular right now. Popularity == OU. BL == strong pokemon. Thus, an unpopular strong pokemon goes into BL.

Well, the discussion has died down quite a bit, and while we've determined the tiers of a few pokemon, there hasn't been a real conclusion on some of them. Back to the list...

UU's to be tested.
-Walrein
-Glaceon
-Pinsir
-Cacturne
-Lapras
-Ninetales
-Poliwrath
-Hitmonlee
-Leafeon
-Clefable

From my experience, the two of those that really deserve BL are Hitmonlee and Clefable. Hitmonlee plain just hits too hard with Close Combat and has enough coverage that nothing in UU can really take it's hits. Clefable isn't as outright powerful as Hitmonlee but has a huge amount of options, and the more defensive sets are very difficult to stop without a Fighting type (in UU, all of whom are pretty frail with the exception of Top and Poliwrath, should he remain UU). I'm still of the opinion that the rest of them deserve further testing, though BL does seem likely for some (mainly Pinsir, Wrath, and Glaceon).

I can agree with Hitmonlee, but I have yet to get any experience with Clefable with UU pokemon. So my stance on clefable is neutral.
 
I think Hitmonlee should remain UU primarily because there are enough counters to it such as Fearow, Dodrio, Swellow, Crobat, Jumpluff that will be all be faster and hit for 2x damage. His defenses are relatively frail. Likewise, he is used as a reversalar most of the time and a good portion of Pokes, that will be used in this metagame, have access to Quick Attack or a priority move.
 
I think Hitmonlee should remain UU primarily because there are enough counters to it such as Fearow, Dodrio, Swellow, Crobat, Jumpluff that will be all be faster and hit for 2x damage. His defenses are relatively frail. Likewise, he is used as a reversalar most of the time and a good portion of Pokes, that will be used in this metagame, have access to Quick Attack or a priority move.

Ick, all italics, I removed it.

He's been pretty good to me as a Choice Bander in testing. Fearow, Dodrio, Swellow, Crobat and Jumpluff are OHKOed with Stone Edge and are thus not counters.
 
I think Froslass should be BL. Immunity to Rapid Spin, Destiny Bond, BoltBeam, STAB Shadow Ball... it's extremely annoying. I'm tired of facing it in UU, it's so game breaking.
 
Froslass has about 80 Base Sp.Atk lower than average. STAB won't really help it much either on damaging. Rapid Spinners such has Forry have Gyro Ball, they obliterate Froslass. The main part I love on Froslass is it's almost complete immunity from Bliss, her Ice Beam AND Seismic Toss won't help her against Froslass, and Froslass is able to set up spikes..
 
/\ Lets not use OU pokemon in this UU discussion.

Froslass has the advantage of Super-effective STAB vs Claydol (if allowed in), and super-effective T-Bolt vs Cloyster. Torkoal however has STAB overheat making Froslass an iffy switch in. I dunno if its BL material... but it is probably OU (think tentacruel, lol)
 
I apologize for going off topic from the current tangent, but I would like to bring up one Pokemon that is SERIOUSLY an absolute bitch in uu.

Shuckle, with the 252 HP / 56 Def / 200 SpDef, impish set has 244 HP / 561 Def / 541 SpDef.

The water attackers in uu, for the most part, aren't very intimidating offensively, and most of the rock attackers require setting up a swords dance or curse, which will be answered with an encore.

The basic toxic / rest / encore / knock off is enough to completely stall a UU team, especially if Shuckle is paired with Quagsire.

In fact, the only reason I was able to defeat my opponent's Shuckle today was due to a Guts boosted, Swords Danced Iron Tail from my Raticate after Stealth Rock's damage and Spikes' damage had initially taken 50% from Shuckle. That actually seems to be the only to effctively beat it...set up Stealth Rock, 3 layers of Spikes and hopefully have your opponent switch Shuckle into a swords dance.
 
I'm guessing you ran into random#s ...

Anyway Shuckle is annoying but that's about it ... it's just a matter of wearing it down. It can stall but that is about it.
 
There's nothing wrong with stall. Knocking off the opponent's items and causing them to eat half their life in spikes/SR switch-ins or Toxic is not just some parlor trick, it's real, game-winning damage.

I use SToss/Night Shade to make sure I get the 3HKO (though most of the time it's a 2HKO thanks to SR).
 
Erm I don't actually remember saying that stalling wasn't a viable strategy, rather that that is all Shuckle can do ... if you're team is designed to be able to handle stall then you've beaten Shuckle.
 
I think Froslass should be BL. Immunity to Rapid Spin, Destiny Bond, BoltBeam, STAB Shadow Ball... it's extremely annoying. I'm tired of facing it in UU, it's so game breaking.
I agree. Also STAB Ice Beam. Destiny Bond helps it as a last resort. It can also parafuse and set up Spikes, although that is seen on a lesser extent.

It's a really versatile pokémon that has many utilities. Boltbeam, Parafusing, using Spikes, and Destiny Bond really makes this Pokémon something to really consider.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top