In my opinion you are uninformed to the point where it's really irresponsible to be giving your take on this stuffI guess I'll take your word for considering I don't really keep up with police brutality in the US.
In my opinion you are uninformed to the point where it's really irresponsible to be giving your take on this stuffI guess I'll take your word for considering I don't really keep up with police brutality in the US.
Ningildo said:I didn't say it gathers sympathy for the protests, I simply quoted another guy saying that it increases the legitimacy of the protests and also gathers more attention to them. The guy also mentioned two protests that happened in two different countries so I think that you could look those up if you wanted sources.This would be fine if the actions weren't also aimed at people who aren't involved. Goes for both sides fwiw.
I said I had concerns that the small minority of "protesters" that riot would used as an excuse for further government intervention against actual protesters who were protesting peacefully...I'm kind of lost at the first two sentences.
And interesting for the rest of it, I didn't know that. Mind sourcing?
Then he would be insufficiently punished, not unpunished.
Thanks for the clarification, though!
I guess I'll take your word for considering I don't really keep up with police brutality in the US.
I agree,
This above paragraph is assuming quite a bit. For one, I never said this instilled more horror to me than violence against black americans. The point I made wasn't "this is worse than George Floyd's murder and other cases like his", it was "this will undermine the message that the protest as a whole is trying to send and will be used as an excuse for more government intervention" because attacking stores and the like that didn't have anything to do with this doesn't garner sympathy from those more moderate. It would make some sense if the burning was kept to police stations and police cars, but they aren't.
And if this wasn't aimed at me in particular...why are you bringing this up?
I doubt it, considering I don't live in the US and neither do most of my family and friends. Seeing as said people are also diverse, I fail to see the need to bring this up. But maybe you can convince me otherwise. Maybe.
As for the last sentence...a bunch of claims on topics I didn't bring up and aren't backed up by anything in the post. I don't know why you're going here, but sure?
I already kind of adressed it earlier, but how does lashing out against those who weren't involved garner sympathy?
I will admit I'm not particularly informed on the subject, which is why I'm genuinely asking for sources.
tcr said:Well said, we actually agree on something"Monks, even if bandits were to carve you up savagely, limb by limb, with a two-handled saw, he among you who let his heart get angered even at that would not be doing my bidding. Even then you should train yourselves: 'Our minds will be unaffected and we will say no evil words. We will remain sympathetic, with a mind of good will, and with no inner hate. We will keep pervading these people with an awareness imbued with good will and, beginning with them, we will keep pervading the all-encompassing world with an awareness imbued with good will — abundant, expansive, immeasurable, free from hostility, free from ill will.' That's how you should train yourselves." - Buddhist Sutta
"...the best way to assure oneself that love is disinterested is to have love for the enemy-neighbor from whom you can expect no good in return, but only hostility and persecution." - King, An Experiment in Love, 1958
"Violence as a way of achieving racial justice is both impractical and immoral. I am not unmindful of the fact that violence often brings about momentary results. Nations have frequently won their independence in battle. But in spite of temporary victories, violence never brings permanent peace.” - King 1964
“Over the past few years I have consistently preached that nonviolence demands that the means we use must be as pure as the ends we seek. I have tried to make clear that it is wrong to use immoral means to attain moral ends.” - A Letter from Birmingham Jail, King 1963
To all protesters I urge you to move, react, and stand in solidarity with those marching today. If you can take time out and can safely protest then do so. The world as of right now is watching. There are eyes on Minneapolis, D.C., Richmond, Seattle, New York City. There are sister protests in Perth, Sydney, Australia. There are sister protests in London, Copenhagen, Berlin. People are taking notice. This movement has genuine cause to change things, for the better. Regardless if you think that George Floyd, or Tamir Rice, or Trayvon Martin, or Philando Castille, or any of the other countless executed were guilty of their crimes, if you call yourself an American then you should be in support of this movement and of reform.
There is no reason that people should die in custody. There is no reason that people should die in jail. There is no reason that jail should be punitive and not rehabilitative. There is no reason that people need to senselessly die with no recourse. It defies our justice system that hinges on accountability, it defies our justice system which relies on preserving the autonomy of the individual, it defies our justice system which works to promote fairness and equality to all. There is injustice that must not go unanswered. There is injustice that has not been answered for decades, a systemic rot within the foundations of our country.
With that said please do not use this civil unrest as an opportunity to pillage or cause harm, whether direct or indirect. What justice imbalance is righted when an innocent person's car is torched? When he is now vehicle-less, in an area where the job opportunities are 20-30 minutes away? What justice is there in looting an Iranian immigrants attempt at the American Dream? What justice is there in looting a 120yo black-owned business. What message does it send, where does it resonate that it is OK to loot one of the only black-owned dentistry and pediatric care centers?
There are people who are attempting to co-opt the narrative, to justify property destruction, to pillage and cause violence and anarchy. These are not people that you want on your side. With the world's spotlight on you, millions looking in from countries all over the world and emulating, do you truly wish for anarchy to be the focus of the message? To haphazardly destroy any business or property, without any forethought to how that affects those people's livelihood and ability to provide for themselves, their families? In the middle of a pandemic, is it justified to ignore the ramifications of violent riots?
The vast, VAST majority of protesters have been nonviolent. Just in Richmond alone protests were entirely pacifist. Until 7:46 PM when RPD fired tear gas to disperse the crowd prior to curfew. and still they were nonviolent. This is the image that should be shown to the world. Do not let the media, let the police, or instigators goad you into violent antics, because that is what they want. The police and the media would love nothing more than for violence to escalate and will plant rioters in the crowds, will teargas and send rubber bullets at you, will arrest and terrorize.
When asked on his thoughts concerning the liberation of Tibet from China, the Dalai Lama stated thus: "Yes, I absolutely refuse the use of violence. For several years now I have been asked on several occasions what I would do if the despair of certain Tibetans drove them to violence, and I have always replied that if that were to happen I would give up and step back. I have reasons for thinking in this way; it is not merely a blind belief First of all, I believe that the basic nature of human beings is gentle and compassionate. It is therefore in our own interest to encourage that nature, to make it live within us, to leave room for it to develop. If on the contrary we use violence, it is as if we voluntarily obstruct the positive side of human nature and prevent its evolution. "
I urge all protesters to take action but to practice compassion in each step of the way, each chant, each act of property destruction. Know what and who is being affected and if you don't know imagine it is your own brother and let that affect your compassion. The world is watching, change is upon us and this time the revolution is indeed being televised.
Over the past few years I have consistently preached that nonviolence demands that the means we use must be as pure as the ends we seek. I have tried to make clear that it is wrong to use immoral means to attain moral ends. But now I must affirm that it is just as wrong, or perhaps even more so, to use moral means to preserve immoral ends. Perhaps Mr. Connor and his policemen have been rather nonviolent in public, as was Chief Pritchett in Albany, Georgia, but they have used the moral means of nonviolence to maintain the immoral end of racial injustice. As T. S. Eliot has said: "The last temptation is the greatest treason: To do the right deed for the wrong reason."
TheValkyries said:I obviously haven't read all of MLK's writings so it is always possible that we could be missing the full context, but your response to the handling of these quotes makes you seem overzealous, no offense. I'm assuming that you are responding to tcr quoting MLK as saying:Love the intentional misconstruing of King’s letter from a Birmingham jail. Here’s the rest of that paragraph he wrote.
You add the following paragraph for context, claiming that it demonstrates King's updated understanding of the proper use of violence and nonviolence in pursuit of social reform:"Violence as a way of achieving racial justice is both impractical and immoral. I am not unmindful of the fact that violence often brings about momentary results. Nations have frequently won their independence in battle. But in spite of temporary victories, violence never brings permanent peace.” - King 1964
These quotes, however, are entirely compatible; the later merely adds nuance to the former. In the first quote, King says that immoral means for a moral end is immoral. In the second quote, King points out that moral means for an immoral end is equally or more immoral. The only time when the second statement can be construed as overwriting the first is when a moral end can only be attained through immoral means, which is rarely the case and almost certainly not applicable today. The purpose of King's second statement is more important for acknowledging that the less violent party doesn't necessarily represent the greater moral good. Judging purely from the statements that you and tcr presented, it would appear that MLK was against violence but understood that violence or lack thereof could obscure important moral concepts, which is consistent with tcr's message.Over the past few years I have consistently preached that nonviolence demands that the means we use must be as pure as the ends we seek. I have tried to make clear that it is wrong to use immoral means to attain moral ends. But now I must affirm that it is just as wrong, or perhaps even more so, to use moral means to preserve immoral ends. Perhaps Mr. Connor and his policemen have been rather nonviolent in public, as was Chief Pritchett in Albany, Georgia, but they have used the moral means of nonviolence to maintain the immoral end of racial injustice. As T. S. Eliot has said: "The last temptation is the greatest treason: To do the right deed for the wrong reason.
TheValkyries said:First - I agree with you that MLK's views are far more complex and varied over time than just about anyone who attempts to use his quotes understands and there is practically a Godwin's Law for using MLK's quotes. Growing up in Atlanta, it was inescapable that people will argue about his intent and legacy given even his children and grandchildren fight over it constantly. If even his own family doesn't know what he would support or wouldn't support, then certainly random people on twitter have no idea. It also doesn't help that the american education system teaches only the non-violence and uses it as a contrast to Malcolm X, which is in its own way misinformation that conveniently benefits those in power who would want to suggest that violent protest is ineffective compared to nonviolence.MLK was not as one note on non-violence as white supremacy would like you to believe, and he gradually became much more radical on his views towards riots and violent protests as he grew older and saw more.
Also: it always seems worth noting as people love to conveniently forget: King for all his nonviolence was ASSASSINATED. And the country rioted in response for near a month. And before the rioting ended the civil rights act was passed.
willempju said:A big factor is that one of the biggest police trainers in America for two decades has been Dave Grossman (not to be confused with David Grossman). When police are being made to believe that something as innocuous as a traffic stop could easily escalate to a life or death situation, it's no surprise this country has a problem where someone innocent is shot and the police's excuse is "the officer felt threatened." Of course he felt threatened, a fearmonger has been preaching terror to him!You're forgetting one of the most important differences with Europe: a widespread availability of guns. The knowledge that it is likely that a random person might carry a gun makes anyone more likely to pull the trigger themselves. In Europe this is only a real risk when dealing with organised crime.
TheValkyries said:It is you who are not understanding King's message and ethos.Love the intentional misconstruing of King’s letter from a Birmingham jail. Here’s the rest of that paragraph he wrote.
MLK was not as one note on non-violence as white supremacy would like you to believe, and he gradually became much more radical on his views towards riots and violent protests as he grew older and saw more.
No one had forgotten this, King himself decried riots but recognized them as a symptom of oppression. His support for nonviolence does not mean he does not recognize the benefits of violence actions, his comments on riots do not conflict with his passion for nonviolent protest.Also: it always seems worth noting as people love to conveniently forget: King for all his nonviolence was ASSASSINATED. And the country rioted in response for near a month. And before the rioting ended the civil rights act was passed.
1967: said:Let me say as I've always said, and I will always continue to say, that riots are socially destructive and self-defeating. I'm still convinced that nonviolence is the most potent weapon available to oppressed people in their struggle for freedom and justice. I feel that violence will only create more social problems than they will solve. That in a real sense it is impracticable for the Negro to even think of mounting a violent revolution in the United States. So I will continue to condemn riots, and continue to say to my brothers and sisters that this is not the way. And continue to affirm that there is another way.
But at the same time, it is as necessary for me to be as vigorous in condemning the conditions which cause persons to feel that they must engage in riotous activities as it is for me to condemn riots. I think America must see that riots do not develop out of thin air. Certain conditions continue to exist in our society which must be condemned as vigorously as we condemn riots. But in the final analysis, a riot is the language of the unheard. And what is it that America has failed to hear? It has failed to hear that the plight of the Negro poor has worsened over the last few years. It has failed to hear that the promises of freedom and justice have not been met. And it has failed to hear that large segments of white society are more concerned about tranquility and the status quo than about justice, equality, and humanity. And so in a real sense our nation's summers of riots are caused by our nation's winters of delay. And as long as America postpones justice, we stand in the position of having these recurrences of violence and riots over and over again. Social justice and progress are the absolute guarantors of riot prevention.
tcr said:seems p obvious ppl who are protesting are doing so out of love not hate. ive bolded the part of your own quotation that you seem to simply not understand. he's saying don't hate white ppl like white ppl hate black ppl, don't just recreate hierarchies through inversion, but actually level them. Despite his nonviolent messaging King was still assassinated, and plenty of 'violent' type of direct actions are begun under the flag of nonviolence because the rhetorical bait and switch tricks some fledglings into joining the cause.It is you who are not understanding King's message and ethos.
Since you seem to require a later source for King's message on nonviolence he wrote in Where do we go from here?: "Therefore I must oppose any attempt to gain our freedom by the methods of malice, hate, and violence that have characterized our oppressors. Hate is just as injurious to the hater as it is to the hated. Like an unchecked cancer, hate corrodes the personality and eats away its vital unity. Many of our inner conflicts are rooted in hate. This is why the psychiatrists say, "Love or perish." I have seen hate expressed in the countenances of too many Mississippi and Alabama sheriffs to advise the Negro to sink to this miserable level. Hate is too great a burden to bear.
For the salvation of our nation and the salvation of mankind, we must follow another way. This does not mean that we abandon our militant efforts. With every ounce of our energy we must continue to rid our nation of the incubus of racial injustice. But we need not in the process relinquish our privilege and obligation to love." p. 66-67
brightobject said:Scroll right to the comments to find the eerie Chinese defenders at work again. The same talking points as stalin. Americans are racist, Americans imcarcerate everybody, americans colonize the world. Well, which nation instituted an ethnic cleansing program in ukraine? It's easy to not incarcerate people when you can just execute them instead (china consisted an estimated 65% of executions in 2010). African colonization etc etchttps://newbloommag.net/2020/06/22/qiao-collective-nationalism/
interesting article on western chinese disapora coalescing into statist nationalism, focusing on a specific twitter account called Qiao Collective.
brightobject said:That isn't what he said. His point was America was not the only place in the world that has committed evils, and that it's backwards that the Chinese aren't criticized or rebuked when America has been chucked in the garbage as of late by the culture. I'd add on and argue by a long shot that China is much worse. They're commiting genocide as we speak, they're placing entire subraces (i.e. Muslims) in entire internment camps, they've consistently broken international law in regards to their actions in the South China sea and revoking Hong Kong's freedoms. At least America has taken strides to live up to the values in the declaration of independence and the constitution. By no means am I saying we're perfect, but at least there's been a clear attempt to clean up our act especially in the past 50-75 years.yeah talking with your white coworkers and hearing lebron say screw hk on the news does not mean you get to decide whether or not "real life" racism against asians exists. Check yourself man, seriously.
to be clear i don't take issue with your critique of bad-faith pro-CCP arguments--but jumping from that to denying the existence of racism against asian-americans is seriously fucked up. Your immediate defensive reaction (China's the REAL racist...the REAL colonizer) also misses the entire point of the article--which is to remain critical of both the US and China and avoid getting sucked into the us-them cold war mentality--proving how much both sides mirror each other, in that regard anyway :I
Dece1t said:i am not laughing at that, i am laughing at the fact that you think america is not like that and is attempting to "clean up their act" despite the facts of mass police brutality, ICE concentration camps, the prison-industrial complex, the habitual bombing of the middle east, i could go on. i cannot explain why you give america the benefit of the doubt for matters for which you would have condemned china 10 times over, except by coming to the conclusion that you are a simplistic xenophobe. and yes, i think thats laughabletermi I don't find internment camps and steamrolling of freedoms as a whole very funny.
termi said:i cannot explain why you give america the benefit of the doubt for matters for which you would have condemned china 10 times over
termi said:I am not a xenophobe, and how dare you call me that. My argument was against the running of China, not the fucking people and citizens within China. Lets get that out of the way first off since you clearly didn't read my argument.i am not laughing at that, i am laughing at the fact that you think america is not like that and is attempting to "clean up their act" despite the facts of mass police brutality, ICE concentration camps, the prison-industrial complex, the habitual bombing of the middle east, i could go on. i cannot explain why you give america the benefit of the doubt for matters for which you would have condemned china 10 times over, except by coming to the conclusion that you are a simplistic xenophobe. and yes, i think thats laughable
No, I agree. Both regimes should be criticized for their practices. Nationalists are an extremely dangerous people no matter which country. I was spurred into making this comment when I saw this critique of the article in the comment section. It's straight out of the tankie playbook (echoing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_you_are_lynching_Negroes). I am extremely critical of the USA's authoritarian actions and in the limited online communities that I belong to, I see similar anti-american leftist sentiment, especially rising in the past 6-12 months. What I do not see in these leftist communities is a single person defending china. Unless I specifically seek out pro-china stans (which are fairly "complete" in the defense of china's actions, for example we had some guy write paragraphs on china a year ago or so in one of these politics threads and that was the only one) I do not find people in online communities "defending" china.Your immediate defensive reaction (China's the REAL racist...the REAL colonizer) also misses the entire point of the article--which is to remain critical of both the US and China and avoid getting sucked into the us-them cold war mentality--proving how much both sides mirror each other, in that regard anyway :I
I don't want to deny that anti-asian racism exists at all. While not to "quantify" racism...over the past several years, the racism that I have been exposed to against asian americans (through twitter media, news, blogging, etc) has been focused on harmful stereotypes, anti-asian comedy, asian inclusion in media, the like. In a work group chat consisting of ~60% asian americans, which has become extremely political lately, my friends have not been sharing media stories of police discrimination, assault, 'go back to china' that has occured to them or other asian americans in the country. They HAVE shared these stories against brown (code: muslim) and black americans. Brief searches (prior to 2020, where anti asian hate crime has ABSOLUTELY spiked since covid) seem to suggest that asian hate crime has fallen dramatically since 2000 (50%! https://www.washingtonpost.com/poli...declining-years-will-coronavirus-change-that/), even AFTER trump was elected to user in a new era of racism in the country.to be clear i don't take issue with your critique of bad-faith pro-CCP arguments--but jumping from that to denying the existence of racism against asian-americans is seriously fucked up.
brightobject said:To piggyback onto this......no, this is not what I said at all. When I speak ill of CHINA's practices (net censorship, HK protests, industrial espionage) to my white boomer colleagues, they are mostly ignorant to what is going on and are by large fairly pro-china--they have not really gotten any anti-china sentiment over the past several years. Granted they are upper-class, wealthy white people...but the point being, they are white americans, aren't they supposed to be the anti-chinese people that are gobbling down the authoritarian usa anti-china propaganda? Lebron saying screw hk on the news doesn't say anything about anti-ASIAN racism, but it does say something about anti-CHINA sentiment in america. No, I do not get to decide if racism exists against asians. I don't deny that it does. But I ask: from what prominent figures is the anti-china statements coming from? Even trump doesn't mention uyghurs. That's the point I was trying to make.yeah talking with your white coworkers and hearing lebron say screw hk on the news does not mean you get to decide whether or not "real life" racism against asians exists. Check yourself man, seriously.
lilyhollow said:I don't know why "does anti-China sentiment turn into hate crimes?" is a question you're even asking. The real question you want to ask is "will anti-China sentiment have any kind of net negative outcome period." And the calculus of 'tankies' is that the answer to that question is, yes, obviously it's playing right into the hands of the US for there to be western leftists who believe that China is 'equivalently bad' to the US. And they are right in that analysis.
My mind can be changed on this but I thought the article was sorta corny? A lot of it could be summarized as "qiao collective is pro-china propaganda instead of nuanced discussion of China's complexities," to which I'm like, yeah brah, like most of what's out there is propaganda, you're worried about the like 2% that's actually pro-China? The article harps on how tankies see no alternatives to China as a challenge to US hegemony, but I don't think it mentions anywhere any actual alternatives? Like at what point am I supposed to be convinced by this article that it will have positive impacts on the world to be focused on what China does wrong (often with dubious sourcing) and to spread that around, which serves US interests, when I'm literally living in the US.