First thing I want to say is, I apologize if I'm off topic and bring up STABmons, I'd like you guys to know that I have no intentions to metabash any metas.
Yes, you can say "it's bad logic" all you want, but you see, this kind of thing has happened before several times, most notably in a metagame called STABmons. Inheritance and STABmons is a very different meta, but they're similar in regards that they're intended to be broken. After Diggersby ban, there has been an endless chain of suspects and bans to the point that a new rule was created to stop the neverending bans, that leads us to the new STABmons we know today. As a result, I see complaints in PS because of the new limitations, making it less fun. That's what happens if you try to fix the meta that's intended to be broken. FUN is what attracts us to play, not balance, though balance is one of the necessary things to make it fun.
If we want to suspect or ban things, we have to consider "does the metagame REALLY benefit from this ban?" You see, Protean makes us use pokes like Alakazam, Azelf, Marowak, Rampardos, Haxorus, Tornadus Therian, as well as other pokes with badly distributed stats, (Marowak and Rampardos in this case) and pokes with good stats but underwhelming offensive typing (like Azelf and Alakazam). If we ban Protean, we basically make those pokes unviable, narrowing the variety. In this case, I'd say the metagame lose more than it gains if we ban Protean, because more variety is what makes the metagame more fun.
Ghoul King said:Alternatively, I could've paraphrased as "We shouldn't ban things so we won't ban too many things", or some other variation on the idea, but yes, this is pretty much exactly what Chopin said: "We shouldn't ban things, because we might end up banning too many things."
It's bad logic. We shouldn't be afraid to ban things for fear of banning too many things. Full stop.
No thread has ever considered it acceptable to say "We may end up chain-banning things as a consequence of this ban, so we shouldn't do it", either, so the rest of your post is kind of irrelevant.
Yes, you can say "it's bad logic" all you want, but you see, this kind of thing has happened before several times, most notably in a metagame called STABmons. Inheritance and STABmons is a very different meta, but they're similar in regards that they're intended to be broken. After Diggersby ban, there has been an endless chain of suspects and bans to the point that a new rule was created to stop the neverending bans, that leads us to the new STABmons we know today. As a result, I see complaints in PS because of the new limitations, making it less fun. That's what happens if you try to fix the meta that's intended to be broken. FUN is what attracts us to play, not balance, though balance is one of the necessary things to make it fun.
If we want to suspect or ban things, we have to consider "does the metagame REALLY benefit from this ban?" You see, Protean makes us use pokes like Alakazam, Azelf, Marowak, Rampardos, Haxorus, Tornadus Therian, as well as other pokes with badly distributed stats, (Marowak and Rampardos in this case) and pokes with good stats but underwhelming offensive typing (like Azelf and Alakazam). If we ban Protean, we basically make those pokes unviable, narrowing the variety. In this case, I'd say the metagame lose more than it gains if we ban Protean, because more variety is what makes the metagame more fun.





