I think the implication that Mega Scrafty might need a restricted version of Multiscale is very funny. As if, Multiscale might just be too much for the tier to handle. As for everything ausma said, I more or less agree with what is said. I think a lot of the customs needs to be scaled back, especially ones that don't even help it out (looking at you Hawlucha). Also, we need to axe the Uber Pokémon immediately, I am genuinely not understanding why we still have so many traditionally Uber level or at the very least OU++ Pokémon still running around in a metagame that is severely weaker than the metagame's they had to be banned from. They warp the metagame to the point where we being so so on evaluating things that we expected to be broken right off the bat, because we are too busy dealing with Ubers in our garden. I genuinely feel like Mega Diancie is in wallable crack, but who cares man Mega Metagross exists and is the perfect smack down machine. Mega Meta, Zygarde, and a Gallade nerf needs to be implemented immediately!
Now some unexpected developments...Mega Mawile is insane right now. Mega Mawile plays like it's classic Gen 6 Demon Lord SD sets. Your best bet defensively is like...Wisp Sableye. Offensively is somewhat good in Sucker Punch resists that can kill it, but hazards are easy to set and can be kept up if you play your cards well. So how much chip does a non Mach Punch Mega Lop for example need to drop to +2 Sucker?
+2 252+ Atk Huge Power Mawile-Mega Sucker Punch vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Lopunny-Mega: 151-178 (55.7 - 65.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
Lopunny can't OHKO either. Crazy world.
For comments on the item releasing. I think Choice Scarf specifically is like, extremely important right now with how lopsided speed control is in the metagame right now. As more things get banned, novelties go away and things like various traditional set up sweepers (DDance Gyarados-M, Charizard-M-X, SD Scale Shot users), the need for reliable revenge killers is definitely needed. Choice Band and Specs are not as metagame glueworthy in my opinion, but outside of a few specific Pokémon I don't see their usage of Choice Band and or Specs to be potentially problematic. If you take a look at the attacking stats of most Pokemon in the tier, and then filter out Megas....most of the big bad scary Choice item Pokémon have a lot of problems with running these items, it feels like they have to "skillfully" run these items with many notable drawbacks.
Except these two -
:hoopa-unbound::Greninja:
Hoppa Unbound is pretty nuts as a wallbreaker, but a lot of existing threats make it feel like a necessity atm. I feel once the big Ubers + a few major threats like Mega Greninja, Mega Lopunny and Mega Diancie gets gone, Hoppa will rear it's ugly head. Right now though, it's the best Choice user in the metagame right now, featuring all of the items in question.
Greninja is also a sleeper threat, and I feel like will eventually be axed as most of the extreme broken mons disappear. This metagame feels like Gen 6 in power scale, and base Greninja is better than ever before, so once the metagame scales down I truly think even base Gren will become problematic as time goes on. I think these two guys will repeat the same cycles they did in Gen 6, at least until DLC drops and completely shakes up the meta (Gren maybe can come back probably).
So to me Choice items right now feel like a necessary evil. I don't think Heavy Duty Boots is necessary in the metagame right now though. I don't think the metagame is severely limited in hazard control and outside of oddball developments I see them as being a net negative. Boots feel nice when you need to check some extreme goobers running around, but I think by like mid November a Boots vote ought to be done, on whether or not we need it in the tier. I don't think the metagame needs any of the other items either still, even though I understand the feeling of wanting things like Light Clay and such (you don't want this right now).
All in all, we have most likely two and a half months of metagame development so I do hope this metagame gets the development it deserves to be a really fun tier.
I finally wanted to do fresh pitches for abilities for the shitty new megas, I decided to challenge myself by only using abilities that exist in game.
Mega Changes
Right off the bat. I think Without a custom effect Victreebel is cooked. No non Mega Sun Setters are amuck so Chlorophyll my preferred pick is not gonna work. Corrosion Toxic spam will be a calm lower tier pick for the eventual Legends Z-A: UU that drops in November.
:Clefable:- Sheer Force
I went there. Clefable-Mega's biggest problem is a) base Clefable is a fantastic glue Pokémon that has a bunch of tools that help it be a great defensive tool, which Mega Clef lacks some of, and b) ALOT of good megas exist, and they aren't stuck competing with their very viable base form. I had to think of a reasonable way to justify Clefable wanting to run a Mega Stone and using it. Enter Sheer Force. This puts Clefable way up on the map as a powerful offensive threat due to how powerful Sheer Force boosted Moonblast and all of the coverage moves in its set. It's pretty powerful and nukes alot of shit in the tier right now.
:Meganium:- Grassy Surge
Yes, I know you guys love Flower Veil on Meganium and as of right now, it can fairly be argued it is pretty solid. But most of Meganium's success comes from it being like, really great into Zygarde specifically. I fear when Zygarde dies in two days though Meganium will fall off. Now, I know the Triage team is in the rear screaming for it's return, but I really think Grassy Surge fixes a lot of the issues that Meganium has, while helping to support teams pretty well (free base Hawlucha?).
:Hawlucha:- Stamina
Yep I am on the Stamina bandwagon. Stamina just feels like a very unique way for Hawlucha to utilize a form of set up in a way that's very different from the faced paced now or never one and done style of regular Hawlucha. Stamina makes Bulk Up or even regular Swords Dance sets be very separate from its base form. Hawl already has solid bulk so it can pivot into many things to farm Defense boosts in order to either facilitate another sweep or do offensive pivot type shit. Honestly once the metagame settles I see Hawl being ok, but I am not feeling the Custom here so this should still be tough.
:Scrafty:- Multiscale
Scrafty is weak to Fairies like no other. And it lacks Pursuit. So Mega Scrafty has to really justify why this should be your team's dedicated Dark. While it ultimately will probably never be great, Multiscale will make Scarfty be like, a really good set up sweeper. Scrafty can also do some funny shit as a fat bitch that can pivot into the most ridiculous wallbreakers in the tier and trade very comfortably with hella mons. I think it should be a great defensive pivot and/or lame game sweeper.
:Steelix-Mega:- Heatproof
Steelix-Mega deserves a good ability outside of Sand Force, so I think Heatproof does so in a way that helps carve out a real niche without outright eliminating it's counters. It can switch around and check hella mons better with these upgrades.