SkyOfSouls said:Hey, I wanted to ask a question that I had after argument I had.
So how I understand it is that gender identity isn't defined by body or mannerisms or how people perceive you, but gender goes hand in hand with your expression, by the way you present yourself, via how you look, the clothes you wear, and how you act. Like you can be AMAB and be super femme, or more masc leaning, but still be transfem, without taking HRT or bottom surgery, and be happy with a good support group. But dysphoria is a real thing that can be plaguing even if you know your gender identity, as is gender envy which makes you want to look and possess a body that you don't currently have but would really like to. Even if you pass to yourself and to others, what pushes one to pursue HRT and/or bottom surgery to align with a gender identity they are comfortable with ? Basically I'm trying to say is : why change your body to conform to your gender identity/expression, even if it leaves you better off, when your gender shouldn't be shackled by your body ?
Basically
trans person : gender is beyond the body, I am free not having to consider myself AGAB, my body will not affect how I perceive myself, I am content.
also trans person : bro the gender envy is real they're so goals I WANT TO HAVE THAT BODY SO BAAAAAAAAD
free from body changing one's perception, yet yearning to change one's body to enhance one's perception LMAO
also merry chrimmas and happy holidays with the loved ones who support you :)
Jawsome and Addison gave two good answers, i'll give another point of view.
It is
relatively easy to know the fact, the rational-logical data point, that gender transcends the physical form. It is harder to truly, deeply, internalize that truth.
Say you're a trans girl without physical transition. You know inside you're a girl, and you look in the mirror and see a face that society generally says is a boy's face. You rationally know how to resolve this contradiction – that society is mistaken in this particular case, and you are correct. Still, having the full throated confidence to shout "No, all of you are wrong!" is hard. It is especially hard because it's confidence in something you
believe about yourself, something you are in your
heart, and not something you can prove with a google search to win an argument.
When it comes to trans-ness without physical transition, I think of it similarly to a large, obvious scar that someone is insecure about. You can tell them they're beautiful the way they are, that people who react negatively to the scar are acting thoughtlessly and badly, and that it's what inside that counts anyway. And you'd be right. But that doesn't mean the person will just immediately lose all insecurity about their appearance.