banks said:It's interesting that someone brought this up. Dressing visibly 'queer' can often be a lose-lose situation for the individual.
By dressing hyper-feminine as a transgender woman, you are a caricature and mocking what it means to be a woman. By not dressing hyper-feminine, you are a predatory man who is merely a grifter at best. We can reduce this to acts such as shaving and make-up too: You are pertaining to male fantasy by shaving your legs and emasculating yourself to the best of your ability, but you're also pertaining to a male fantasy by having traditionally masculine body hair on you as a trans woman.
Not my intention to redirect a seemingly innocuous conversation into something quite depressing, but it's something I've pondered on a lot. I will say that it is unfortunate for any queer person that the way they dress will determine how palpable they appear to others. If you are a gay man who dresses very conventionally, a straight woman is likely not going to pick you out as a safe, potential friend in a social setting; likewise, most men will automatically avoid you if you shed even a tiny bit of that precious masculinity by wearing something feminine.
Maybe you're reading this thinking I'm crazy and reading too deep into this, but being able to accessorise yourself with 'queer-coded' embellishments is likely a privilege, firstly because you may be in a safe area to do so, and secondly because you're likely trying to attract other like-minded individuals that exist and occupy that space you're in. This is something that I have noticed since leaving my catholic school to go to a city university, especially with the rise of queer fashion and its use of acting as a signifier being hijacked by TikTok and depop influencers. Those pearl necklaces...
What I will say is that don't jeopardise your safety or comfort for the sake of dressing 'queer'. For more people than you'd like to think it's a matter of violent assault or not. You can take baby steps to get where you want to. And if other people your age won't look twice at you unless you're gay'd up, they're probably not worth your time.
this message and KM's response caught my interest as it's a topic i've thought about and acted upon an extraordinary amount, so I wanted to type out my experience with the line of thought and maybe be able to successfully summarize it for myself.
banks said:It's interesting that someone brought this up. Dressing visibly 'queer' can often be a lose-lose situation for the individual.
By dressing hyper-feminine as a transgender woman, you are a caricature and mocking what it means to be a woman. By not dressing hyper-feminine, you are a predatory man who is merely a grifter at best. We can reduce this to acts such as shaving and make-up too: You are pertaining to male fantasy by shaving your legs and emasculating yourself to the best of your ability, but you're also pertaining to a male fantasy by having traditionally masculine body hair on you as a trans woman.
I find this extremely accurate re: both ends of the spectrum, and they're both things I actively think about and avoid. There is little inherently wrong with either of these but both have the exact repercussions described here. For me, you don't want to try so little hard that nobody would ever think of you as a woman, and it's very important not to go overboard to the point of not appearing as someone who is desperately trying to look like a woman. What I've always strived for is a middleground that I call "Plausible Deniability" in which at a glance to almost anyone I'd appear as a girl (which is very attainable for me due to the effort i put into this and my fortunate build) but after having to communicate with anybody I could still be thought of as a cisgender boy, in perhaps a bit effeminate clothing (which is very necessary for me due to my unfortunate voice range). For example in accordance with this, I don't wear a bra even though I'm hovering at the edge of needing one, and if my mindset continues to have this plausible deniability bs requirement in the future, I will probably wear a binder. With very careful attire and accessory choices I can consistently and easily fall into this range, however as Blanks said this is the complete opposite desired outcome of the person who started this topic, and in addition, I believe the process I outlined is quite problematic and a result of internalized transphobia, which I'll get into later.
banks said:Maybe you're reading this thinking I'm crazy and reading too deep into this, but being able to accessorise yourself with 'queer-coded' embellishments is likely a privilege, firstly because you may be in a safe area to do so, and secondly because you're likely trying to attract other like-minded individuals that exist and occupy that space you're in. This is something that I have noticed since leaving my catholic school to go to a city university, especially with the rise of queer fashion and its use of acting as a signifier being hijacked by TikTok and depop influencers. Those pearl necklaces...
What I will say is that don't jeopardise your safety or comfort for the sake of dressing 'queer'. For more people than you'd like to think it's a matter of violent assault or not. You can take baby steps to get where you want to. And if other people your age won't look twice at you unless you're gay'd up, they're probably not worth your time.
No yeah this is absolutely correct and as KM goes into, not at all a superficial thing to discuss. This is certainly a privilege and an often unattainable or dangerous goal to set for yourself. Branding yourself in this way should not be thought of as the norm, and I agree that it's a mistake to think that this is necessary to form connections.
KM said:this is a really well-written summary of this, and i wanted to weigh in a little bit as someone who has dealt with this topic quite a bit academically when I was in college and in the work I do and the spaces I occupy. The crux of this idea that I wrote about is that LGBTQ aesthetics or presentation are often a sort of arithmetic or balancing act between the ideas of "safety" and "authenticity". For people who live in privileged, relatively safe spaces where being and presenting LGBTQ isn't actively criminalized, stigmatized, or dangerous, there's significantly more freedom and ability to explore one's identity, experiment with styling and presentation that doesn't align with norms of gender / sexuality, and consistently front as one's so-called "authentic self". On the other hand, people who live in areas with either significant legal or societal discrimination against LGBTQ people are more likely to value their safety over a so-called "authentic" presentation that constantly reflects their identity, and may seek liminal, often underground spaces (see: nightlife, the ballroom community, underground drag scenes, secret societies) that allow them to conduct the same kind of experimentation of identity and presentation that people in more LGBTQ-friendly areas are able to carry out in their everyday life. while the groups of people who fit into one category or the other may vary vastly depending on physical location etc, generally speaking there is a correlation with privilege (on the axes of class, race, etc) and the degree to which people are able to value their "authenticity" over their "safety".
This balancing act you describe between safety and authenticity reminds me of the plausible deniability premise that I outlined earlier, and it feels good to see that the exact train of thought that I've had on my mind for so much time and I constantly berated myself for having is a pre-existing, common(?) thing, and even somebody that I know has wrote academically on the concept apparently. I do want to clarify this by saying that the dilemma that KM talks about is a much more serious and higher stakes conflict than my own. As I am privileged enough to live in an area where it is not dangerous to be trans, my conflict is my own standards and dysphoria battling against my own shame and embarrassment.
I also wanted to mention a third variable that I'm finding myself struggle with recently, that I'm sure exists for other people.
As of the past 10 days or so I've entered my first relationship with a cis woman who is primarily attracted to other women, and in addition to holding myself to the standard of beauty I see them in(not wanting to see myself as less attractive than them in a vacuum, feeling a stronger motivation for furthering how pretty I am because I'm in a relationship, etc) I also have a new, different desire/insecurity revolving around feeling extra pressure to be explicitly and obviously a girl, for them. My subconsciousness says something along the lines of "they're attracted to girls, if you don't look enough like a girl, regardless of how often they compliment you, they won't be attracted to you. It's like I'm suffering from 2 sources of gender dysphoria, my own, and the fictional expectations I'm projecting over her. In addition to complicating physical intimacy, some examples of how this is changing my behavior include
1: buying more clothes, as normally I'm mentally fine when I'm at home in very comfortable, but explicitly masculine clothes, but now I feel pressure to be fem any time I'm around them even when relaxing
2: shaving my face with obsessive frequency, I've been on hormones for a while and my facial hair growth has slowed quite a bit, and I'd gotten into a rhythm of shaving my face and arms whenever hair is VISIBLE to a passerby, not when it's THERE. But now I'm taking time for it as much as twice a day, just because the idea of them feeling friction on/near my face/lips is absolutely mortifying to me.
This has absolutely nothing to do with the her words/actions they're constantly supportive and accepting and reassuring but this is a completely involuntary thought process. For now, as I'm not burned out, I'm really enjoying having this person as a motivation to feel so much better about myself and be prettier and more well rested and healthy, but I'm also aware that I'm being obsessive and have zero control over my actions regarding this and that isn't healthy.
Apologies for the slight tangent but it's very related to the topic imo and if anybody has any thoughts/experience on this that you think would be helpful to me let me know.
KM said:"... from the perspective of someone whose lived reality as an LGBTQ person has been focused on seeking authenticity, this may seem like a land mine of problematic stereotypes and outdated gender roles -- but for the people walking the category (most of whom are Black and Latine trans women in major cities, often working or living in situations where they are constantly interfacing with cishet people in potentially dangerous situations), realness isn't just a category to be won, its a practice round for the harsh realities of real life, where knowing how to best pass might be the difference between life or death. as a member of ballroom, i've witnessed people come in from outside the community as guests -- from more privileged situations that have allowed them to prioritize their authenticity -- and decry realness as outdated, or problematic, or harmful in the way that it enforces gender roles; while offering no solutions to the immediate, real issues of safety that the community faces."
This hit rlly close to home for me. Passing has always been a very big deal for me, I've spent thousands on clothes and laser hair removal, speedran HRT starting even before I came out, gotten my hair styled to utilize its specific length to pass best every couple months, put on foundation every day I go outside, and feel a high amount of importance and pressure doing these things. When someone once said that I was being shallow, shouldn't bend to society, should just be myself, be proud, am beautiful and "valid"(:nauseated_face:) no matter what I do, I was incredibly shocked at how massively and flamboyantly they missed the point. We don't make a choices based on how the world SHOULD be, we make them based on how it IS, and I didn't point it out at the time but I thought it was incredibly hypocritical that this person was closeted. I've even been in circles where "Passing" is discouraged or disallowed as term, which is in line with what KM said and follows the same reasoning and fallacies.
To me this is related to something i wanted to mention which is internalized transphobia and people "calling people out on", which is something I've encountered a couple times. A recent article seems to concisely narrow down what people seem to classify or think this concept of into 4 inter-related dimensions: pride in transgender identity (reverse scored), investment in passing as a cisgender person, alienation from other transgender people, and shame. These single me out extraordinarily well, as I have, as mentioned, extremely high investment in passing, and extreme disassociation from transgender identity and other queer people. The word valid makes me wince, I dislike pride, rainbows, flags, and anything to do with all of that, they remind me of the oppression that caused it to exist and those protective circles to form in the first place, I feel an inappropriate sense of embarrassment from trans people that are on either extreme ends of the balance discussed earlier as I feel they worsen the bigotry directed at me, and I feel a high amount of shame when I fail to meet the standards I have for myself.
But for much of this I feel it's unhelpful to aggressively point this out as something to put effort into changing, to reiterate what KM said, describing many of these concepts as outdated, or problematic, or harmful isn't actually doing anything to address the mental and physical issues that caused these reactions in the first place, and "no one should feel compelled or required to broadcast their identity, pronouns, gender, sex, or any other aspect of their identity in order to be an LGBTQ person, and there is no shame in choosing to remain safe (in all aspects of that word) for as long as you need to."
(if you're not following this topic or dont care enough to read all this pls read
this part
I also wanted to mention a third variable that I'm finding myself struggle with recently, that I'm sure exists for other people.
As of the past 10 days or so I've entered my first relationship with a cis woman who is primarily attracted to other women, and in addition to holding myself to the standard of beauty I see them in(not wanting to see myself as less attractive than them in a vacuum, feeling a stronger motivation for furthering how pretty I am because I'm in a relationship, etc) I also have a new, different desire/insecurity revolving around feeling extra pressure to be explicitly and obviously a girl, for them. My subconsciousness says something along the lines of "they're attracted to girls, if you don't look enough like a girl, regardless of how often they compliment you, they won't be attracted to you. It's like I'm suffering from 2 sources of gender dysphoria, my own, and the fictional expectations I'm projecting over her. In addition to complicating physical intimacy, some examples of how this is changing my behavior include
1: buying more clothes, as normally I'm mentally fine when I'm at home in very comfortable, but explicitly masculine clothes, but now I feel pressure to be fem any time I'm around them even when relaxing
2: shaving my face with obsessive frequency, I've been on hormones for a while and my facial hair growth has slowed quite a bit, and I'd gotten into a rhythm of shaving my face and arms whenever hair is VISIBLE to a passerby, not when it's THERE. But now I'm taking time for it as much as twice a day, just because the idea of them feeling friction on/near my face/lips is absolutely mortifying to me.
This has absolutely nothing to do with the her words/actions they're constantly supportive and accepting and reassuring but this is a completely involuntary thought process. For now, as I'm not burned out, I'm really enjoying having this person as a motivation to feel so much better about myself and be prettier and more well rested and healthy, but I'm also aware that I'm being obsessive and have zero control over my actions regarding this and that isn't healthy.
Apologies for the slight tangent but it's very related to the topic imo and if anybody has any thoughts/experience on this that you think would be helpful to me let me know.
cuz thats the only thing im curious abt a response for)
also re: the catalyst of this discussion:
Strife64 I feel like being in the middle of Ohio might be the biggest and hardest to overcome issue you described, sorry.