Blame Game said:The fact is, we're in a metagame with Stealth Rock in it. We know now whether or not the metagame we're currently playing in is broken (it isn't).
The poll results beg to differ. In the end, though, I'm sure the test will show that you're right.
Blame Game said:There are a bunch of things that irritate some people about DP/Pt that result from Stealth Rock directly, and theoretically a SRless metagame might be "better" than the one we're currently playing in. These are all things that will cause people to vote for a test or for a ban on Stealth Rock, but none of them show that Stealth Rock is actually broken, or even particularly unhealthy for the metagame on any level ("Sacrificing a pokemon just to set up Stealth Rock"? ok cool, so when did that become inherently a bad thing somehow?).
Using theorymon to say that Stealth Rock is broken doesn't make sense to me, either. That's why I want to test it.
Blame Game said:So yes, there isn't any agreement as to Stealth Rock's placement right now- but because we already disagree in the first place as to when anything should be tested. Under your reasoning, anything that bothers enough people for any reason should be turned into a suspect. This is fine because testing stuff doesn't by itself hurt anyone, but it does when we already have so much on our plates, and are currently operating under a system that arguably supports bans. If everyone was really willing to put Stealth Rock on the backburner then that'd be great, but I find that hard to believe; this entire discussion shouldn't even be taking place if we all agreed that Stealth Rock should only be tested after, say, every single untested Uber. Or, for that matter, just all of the other clauses and suspects we currently have listed- I distinctly remember initial pushes for Stealth Rock being tested before Garchomp, and that disturbs me.
That brings up a good question: why DON'T we wait until everything else is settled before testing this? Am I mistaken that it isn't a top priority? Are time constraints the only reason that people would want to test it right now?
Look, it makes no difference to me whether Stealth Rock is ultimately tested or not. Quite frankly, I'm just really interested in seeing the results of such a test. If it turns out that more Pokemon become viable as a result of banning it, then maybe that will be grounds for banning it--who knows? If nothing really changes as a result, then it won't be a problem
if we wait until everything else has been tested.
Could someone tell me why we have to test this now?