Skiddle said:If Stealth Rock does a stupidly high amount of damage per match, say upwards of 300%, then we should ban it. Being able to kill off half a team with just one move is ridiculous.
This is super misleading and just wrong in general. First of all, doing 300% damage is in no way equal to killing 3 pokemon for "free," since that's not how damage works and there is a huge difference between doing 50% damage to two pokemon, and just OHKOing something. Secondly, even if it did do 300% damage on average, since we're in a non-broken metagame right now all that would prove is that "300% damage on average" is an acceptable number. Again, if you want to prove we're currently in a broken metagame, you have to... actually explain why. Numbers and statistics don't say anything by themselves-- if we suddenly discovered that Lopunny had 8 times the damage output of everything else in OU, but absolutely nothing changed since then and we didn't find the metagame at all broken before, what reason would we have to test Lopunny? All it has is a statistic that
looks broken. I'd call that a confirmation that "8x the damage output of everything in OU =/= instantly broken," not "evidence that our previous metagame was broken" when we already know for a fact that it wasn't.
Skiddle said:If it's lower, like say ~200% then we should consider voting on it's ban, but if it's around 300% then there definitely should be a vote.
Wait, so you're not even arguing for a SR Suspect Test? Just, count up the amount of damage it does on average and base everything entirely on that?
darknessmalice said:This is similar to the Garchomp has a guaranteed KO argument, except SR probably does more damage in a match but the damage is spread out across the team.
Yeah, if Stealth Rock was some kind of delayed OHKO move that just slaughtered whatever happened to switch in, maybe there'd be an argument here. But it isn't, and that's why most reasonable people don't cite damage output as an element that could prove Stealth Rock broken, instead bringing up the fact that it can significantly ease offensive setups, or cripple certain individual pokemon (not that either of these arguments are valid either in my mind).