Seven Deadly Sins said:Tentacruel is almost omnipresent on Hail teams, and it can spin the rocks away.
Hmmmmm, I wonder why that might be.
Edit: @ DarknessMalice
DarknessMalice
However, we should try to use facts and especially battling experience to accurately predict what would happen if there is no SR. Otherwise, we are wasting all the knowledge we have about pokemon.
It is impossible to have experience in a metagame which you have never played before. Prediction is never100% accaurate and should be avoided if we want to get the best meetagame possible.
Only for debates in which there is a large amount of discussion and argument in which a pokemon is uber or not should we have a test.
There is a large amount of discussion whether SR is uber or not. I don't see the problem.
I believe there are two ways of identifying suspects. The first is for suspects that are known, from facts and battling experience, to be overcentralising or powerful to the extent of broken, such as Garchomp and Deoxys-S (Stealth Rock may or may not fit this criteria). We are very familiar with these suspects, as they have been around for a while, so most smogon members' facts and gaming experience are generally accurate.
However, despite this familiarity, Garchomp and Deoxys were still tested in a suspect environment.
Testing every pokemon and move for 6 months each is... you know.
I find 6 months (Possily 4 or 5) to be a decent time for testing suspects (not everything, dunno where you got that from) as it ensures the metagame is more stable compared to say, a month. This gives the players plenty of time to come to grips with the pokemon and the environment, which should help give a more accuarate verdict. Personally, I'd prefer to have each pokemon tested throughly the first time instead of currently retesting unless there is a massive shift in the metagame.