Pehu said:@domk275: it is blacklistable, that's all there is to it. There are some actions that we at Smogon consider over the line. I, myself, think that if you do it for one spread, because you don't want to start a new game, you will do it whenever you want to catch a different poke. I find it unfair with all the folks who DID go thru the trouble of starting a new game just to have nicer shiny spreads. So yeah, don't want to start a new game? Stick to the ID/SID you got randomly when you started the game. Will not do it, and rather hack your ID/SID? Don't complain if you are blacklisted later. I'm no moderator myself, but I would certainly try to get anyone who hacked his ID/SID to be blacklisted, because I didn't need to do that, and I won't be confortable with anyone who can get any shiny spread they want just being able to trade here and "steal" trades from other, honest traders.
Why? If they clearly stated it in the trade thread, how on earth does it affect you in the slightest?
If I pokésav'd my ID/SID to make the Bold flawless HP Electric 70 spread shiny, and got myself a shiny Suicune out of it, and cleary stated that I'd done so, then if someone wants it, what does it matter how I got it? YOU might not like trade for a Suicune that has been made shiny through ID/SID hacking, but if someone else does, then why should you be allowed to force your opinions onto them?
And the thing about "honest" traders is also crap. There is nothing dishonest about using AR, so long as you admit to doing so, and detail exactly how it was used.
Again, just because you personally disagree with hacking an ID/SID, that doesn't give you the right to force everyone else to do the same. That, my friend, is called fascism.