Gonna reply to some of these posts. Too lazy to do proper quotes, soz
D2TheW
jc's post is really good and covers most of the issues with golbat. I think you undersell Golbats defensive and offensive capabilities. From a defensive standpoint, there is very little that can boast switching into offensive physical and np sets. You mentioned steels but they lose to np wave. Likewise, setup mons can lose to taunt roost sets because of golbats incredible speed stat. Similar to Gligar, the versatility of Golbat is what would make it busted and set it apart from everything else imo. You can run stallbreaker sets, bulky np sets, offensive z move np sets, physically offnesive sets, bulky sets, curse etc. Reliable longevity on a mon like this, plus toxic immunity p, is massive. Idt theres naything in the tier capable of keeping it in check.
Its defensive typing is also ridiculously good in NFE. There are only 4 types which hit it for SE damage in elec, psy, rock and ice. Ice types outright do not exist here, there isnt a single ice type on pur current vr, the closest we have to one is protean frog. Likewise, Lairon and Alolan Graveler are the only rock types on vr and again, both low ranking and tough to casually slap on a team. Elec and psys are more common but even so, theres about 9-10 pokemon on VR which hit it for STAB SE damage. However, this is where calcs come in.
Calcs
252 SpA Kadabra Psychic vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Eviolite Golbat: 162-192 (45.7 - 54.2%) -- 47.3% chance to 2HKO
Possible damage amounts: (162, 164, 164, 168, 168, 170, 174, 174, 176, 180, 180, 182, 186, 186, 188, 192)
252 SpA Kadabra Psychic vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Eviolite Golbat: 236-278 (66.6 - 78.5%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
Possible damage amounts: (236, 236, 240, 242, 246, 248, 252, 254, 258, 260, 264, 266, 270, 272, 276, 278)
This is specs damage too.
252 SpA Choice Specs Electabuzz Thunderbolt vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Eviolite Golbat: 206-246 (58.1 - 69.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
Possible damage amounts: (206, 210, 212, 216, 216, 218, 222, 224, 228, 230, 230, 234, 236, 240, 242, 246)
252 SpA Choice Specs Electabuzz Thunderbolt vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Eviolite Golbat: 302-356 (85.3 - 100.5%) -- 6.3% chance to OHKO
Possible damage amounts: (302, 306, 308, 312, 314, 320, 324, 326, 330, 332, 338, 342, 344, 348, 350, 356)
Those were kad and buzz calcs but you could probably do the same with some other potential checks. You could argue that max hp max spdef might be an arbitrary set but golbat reminds me of gligar in the sense of you can make it whatever set you want. In higher tiers, these mons are bound to specific sets because those sets fulfill the niches it needs to fill. In NFE, it would run the tier and therefore, can be whatever you want it to be. Overall, I do think Golbat would be very busted. I think, if you want to freed, you would need to argue why it doesn't fit the tiering polciy definitions of a broken pokemon in the meta.
This is a bit of a side point but NFE isn't as new as this forum may make it seem, the metagame has been around for atleast a year and a half, it only received a forum on Smogon this March. ServRose meta has been around for 5 months I think.
Cheese5555
I made a point about physical slig in my post on April, gonna cp that and add a bit
Similar story with slig, takes a knock which severely hinders its ability to set up with curse later in the game. It can't set up curse early game unless the curse slig mu is 90/10 or better, can't lock itself into outrage early or midgame because it can be revenged or heavily chipped by the slig check and uninvested non stab iron tail does not hit hard at all. In addition, servs so bulky that it can easily stay in on slig once, scout whether or not its phys or special and glare, which even makes doubling out again risky. Slig is a lot more useful than toge in a non-serv matchup but again, if I want a mon which checks serv, far easier to use rose/ivy since they immediately put more pressure on opposing teams with knock/spikes. I don't think slig can really be called a servine counter, it's better imo to describe it as a bulky setup mon which doesn't lose to serv. As a serv check, all phys slig does is lose its evio and bleed momentum, its not a serv check.
I'll cover Glare when I respond to Crystal.
For your last point, calling it a mistake might've been harsh, rushed is probably a better word. If you care enough, you can go to the old nfe forums and see what the reasoning was for freeing piloglig but only viper and fille used the tiering policy. There's nothing wrong with testing and freeing Ubers, but considering how much I've had to write just for a serv suspect, I think any freeing would need similar levels of evidence and tiering policy arguments.
Crystal
I think mentioning Zubat gives value to my argument. That mon has 245 BST lol. It's the literal definition of
- These also include elements whose only counters or checks are extraordinarily niche Pokemon that would put the team at a large disadvantage elsewhere.
which is present in the tiering policy. You'd never use Zubat if Rose and Serv weren't so restrictive.
Revenge killing Serv is not nearly as easy as it sounds, my previous post calcs highlight that. If you have multiple offensive means of revenging serv, you most likely have no defensive counterplay and cannot switch into it well at all. If you have multiple offensive and defensive means of dealing with serv, you're heavily prepping for it in builder. Limiting setup shouldn't be a valid argument for keeping Serv. If banning Serv makes sth else too much, you relate that mon to tiering policy and suspect it.
Talking about your takes on tiering policy
1) Skill - Again, the mention of Zubat discredits your point here. Zubat should never be a valid mon to use in our meta. Being creative in a very limited way is what stops teambuilding skill, your using slightly edited sets of similar mons.
2) Uncompetitive - Yh I use Glare because it overloads Serv's toolkit. If it didnt have Glare, Scarfers and offensive counterplay would be much better, you could safely switch star or scarf fires in on a pinch, take like 40 from storm and force it out. Glare makes this much harder to do but, on top of that, it gives Serv a Hail Mary chance to bullshit through checks lategame or give switchins free turns if para comes through.
3) This point is fair. Personal opinions will be different on whether or not Serv's broken relative to the rest of the meta but Rose being so good and splashable makes Serv feel less broken imo. It's only when you build without Rose and test vs competent players with Serv, you realise how difficult it is to prep for and deal with.
Replays
Third thing vipers requested from me. I'll dump some replays which give evidence to some of my arguments. These are all tournament replays too, not test games.
Replays
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-894661936
Serv glared and knocked a toge, proceeded to Storm up and got 3 kiils. More importantly, it ate a Z Outrage from Fraxure. Fraxure has 117 base Attack, one of the highest in the tier. Highlights how dangerous Serv can be when its not against Rose and how difficult it is to revenge kill.
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-887036423
This is a quality game which highlights how stupid Glare can be. You can make judgements about how the early game was played, fair enough, but turn 24 onwards is what I want to highlight. Marj has a full hp evio metang as a serv check. Most tangs have massive 4mss and can't even beat serv unless they get lucky with mash boosts, but marj is able to fit toxic on hers, which should beat Serv. Turn 33 serv knocks tang. Turn 38 serv starts. Two paras and a miss later Serv wins. On top of Glare hax, Serv also consistently provided incredible defensive utility by constantly switching into Buzz Vswitch thoughout the game.
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-890127280
This ones interesting. Servine didnt click a single attacking move here. This one highlights how incredible its defensive utility is. It constantly switched into Marshtomp and Electabuzz while keeping itself healthy. No other Pokemon in the tier can do this while having incredible offensive presence.
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7nu-888886896
5 kills.
Too lazy to find more, could probs look through No Johns too if I wanted too. I think these replays highlight all facets of Serv which together combine to make it ridiculous.
Aight
vooper have fun :) You got two and a half posts worth of shit to counter.