I don't think rain is broken. In response to some of the arguments I've seen (most of which are FlareBlitz's just because he outlined them in an easy-to-read format):
FlareBlitz said:1) Centralizes the metagame heavily and unduly. Proof: look at toxicroak/poliwrath usage before/after rain surge. Also consider that this was a metagame with Cresselia in it. Yes, Toxicroak usage spiking during a metagame with a fucking cresselia is a big deal. Also check stats on jolly v. adamant on kabutops, and hell, kabutops stats in general. Also leafeon. Also tangrowth. Now you might say "so what, the metagame should adapt, blah blah" because we're talking about every team need 3+ water resists or a water immunity and a couple of resists. What the fuck is that?
There is no way to prove that rain has a direct correlation with a Pokemon's usage.
First of all, Toxicroak usage didn't spike that much while Cresselia was in UU. It was an increase, but it wasn't that major - although I guess that's up to interpretation.
Series of Toxicroak Usage Stats
December 2009 (Cresselia was still banned)
| 34 | Toxicroak | 5279 | 4.86 |
January 2010 (Cresselia enters UU)
| 39 | Toxicroak | 6920 | 5.33 |
February 2010
| 35 | Toxicroak | 6995 | 6.43 |
March 2010 (Cresselia had been banned)
| 26 | Toxicroak | 9730 | 7.82 |
As for Poliwrath, it spiked in usage several times before rain became controversial. I'm not going to deny that Poliwrath probably spiked in part due to rain because it could have. However, it could have as easily increased in usage for some other reason. What were the reasons for the other spikes in Poliwrath usage, back when rain was hardly a contributing factor?
Leafeon and Tangrowth have even weaker correlations to rain. Leafeon is not a strong rain counter, and its first and foremost purpose is as a sweeper; Tangrowth checks more than just Ludicolo / Kabutops and is used as a multi-purpose counter on more defensive teams.
As for Kabutops, I'm not sure what's supposed to be gleaned from the Jolly vs. Adamant stats. Kabutops has ran Adamant forever. If anything, the 34.9% who run Rapid Spin are evidence of the fact that Kabutops is not exclusively run on rain teams.
2) Causes matches to be predicated around team-matchups instead of skill This one is pretty obvious. Remember heysup's team? That one based around swellow/moltres and froslass spikes rape. He basically had a 0% chance of winning against any competent rain user. Not because of his skill, but because his team, which peaked leaderboard, fared horribly against the playstyle. You simply cannot "properly" prepare for rain while also preparing for everything that you need to prepare for in order to be successful in the metagame.
Rain is well-known for decimating offensive teams. Heysup is well-known for his use of offensive teams. To go further in-depth, Heysup's team struggles against rain because it relies heavily on switching in on resistances and taking advantage of higher speed and power to address opposing threats. Rain nullifies both of these advantages. I may be wrong, but I don't think Heysup's team is a good example of the norm. Most other teams are able to cover rain better than his does (that team is outdated anyway).
As for the whole idea behind team match-up: if we are to assume that one cannot prepare for rain and everything else, then it logically follows that one cannot prepare for any type of team and everything else. I do not think that rain forces matches to be any more or less based on team match-up
than any other team does. Rather, this is our perception because rain is a common banner for several Pokemon. Say both UUPlayer123's team and a rain team have favorable match-ups against my team. While I can't evaluate UUPlayer123's team in the context of suspect characteristics, I can do so for rain/Damp Rock. Also note that I can take steps to prepare for both UUPlayer123's team and rain teams; in fact, I can create a team that outright beats both of theirs. Basically, team match-up applies to every team; it just so happens that one team can be nominated.
That's not the full extent of the argument, though. Why is preparing for rain any different than preparing for six other Pokemon? Firstly, rain sweepers are faster than nearly anything; secondly, Water-type moves are boosted by the rain; and finally, to counter rain, one must adopt suboptimal Pokemon, sets, or play styles. Please correct me if I left anything out.
I will address the first and second points simultaneously. Rain sweepers still have counters and checks, most of which have already been mentioned before, so I won't go into much depth here.
As for the assertion that these Pokemon are suboptimal. Most rain sweepers are just as suboptimal. Their usefulness happens to be accentuated during rain; well, their counters' usefulness does too. Rain teams abuse normally suboptimal Pokemon to take advantage of the so-called optimal Pokemon. Considering that many so-called optimal Pokemon can also handle the rain sweepers, I would say that's a fair trade-off.
I also want to address the idea of a "suboptimal playstyle". Rain apparently beats the so-called dominant playstyle; if it's considered an optimal playstyle, then why is a playstyle that beats the playstyle that beats the optimal playstyle considered suboptimal?
Plus, who deems playstyles optimal and suboptimal? Why cater to a single designated playstyle?
3) It's easy to play, hard to beat. This ties back in with the other points somewhat. I know I say "rain in the hands of a a competent user", and that's exactly what I mean: competent. Not good. Not amazing. Competent. While I may not win as much using rain as I do with a regular team (and I will say right now that I don't) the fact is I built my rain team in SEVEN MINUTES and do little more than make obvious switches and spam waterfall whenever necessary. My bulky offense team, by comparison, took well over three days to properly build and test, and requires substantial thought on my part because I don't have sweepers on steroids that can plow through resists with the same attack. Seriously, have you guys done any calcs? Kabutops 2hkos Venusaur and fucking Feraligatr with unboosted Waterfall! This cannot be okay!
Rain is undoubtedly easy to play; however, it's rather easy to play with any hyper offensive team (see: BlizzSpam). You don't need to make as many defensive predictions; make the offensive ones and pressure your opponent. The main difference I see is that rain buffs up your sweepers more, which all goes back to the "I believe that there are a sufficient amount of rain checks and counters, etc." argument.
a lot of people said:[citations of ladder experiences / battles]
Okay, I know it's hard to express arguments pertaining to rain clearly and concisely because we're talking about multiple Pokemon, arguing multiple points, and looking at the whole thing from several different viewpoints. But first of all, it's the ladder. It's not exactly the pinnacle of player quality there. Secondly, logs without thoughts aren't indicative of much.
For the record I am currently #1, and I have had no significant problems with rain teams, so if you're going to use anything pertaining to the ladder as fuel to your argument, you're going to have to find some way to justify this first!