Restarted my Nuzlocke challenge for SoulSilver, after my abysmal
first run (fuck you Kakuna!). First the rules:
The Rules
The Big Rules
-If a Pokemon in your party faints, you must release it.
-Every time you reach a new route, cave, etc., you must catch the very first Pokemon you see, regardless of your current number of party members. The Pokemon may sit within the box for an indeterminate amount of time as a backup.
-Duplicate clause: If your first wild Pokemon is a species you have already captured, you may ignore it.
-If you fail to catch the first Pokemon you see, either via it fleeing, knocking it out, or having no Pokeballs, you may not catch another. Tough shit.
-This means you can not catch a pokemon in a route you were in before you could catch pokemon, if you fought one. So no route 29 and 30, you were there before you had pokeballs.
-You are, under no circumstance, allowed to get a second pokemon from any given area.
-You must nickname your pokemon so there is some sort of attachment. Each pokemon is a best friend to you, to see them die is heartbreaking.
-If your entire party faints, they all must be thrown away. If you have a pokemon left in a box somewhere, you may continue, otherwise you must start your game over.
-You are not allowed to switch out before the enemy trainer sends in a new Pokemon.
-You are not allowed to use legendaries in battle.
Some nitpicky rules. This is to cover those pesky "what-if" and "can I?" scenarios that people ask a lot.
-Usage of the following is forbidden: Mystery Gift, Daycare, Pokewalker, out-of-game Trades
-In-game Trades with NPCs are allowed, but you must follow the above rules (no catching Pokemon in routes you've already had a chance in).
-You may not use the Game Corner to acquire any Pokemon.
-The Safari Zone counts as one whole area/route, not 6-12 separate areas/routes (you may catch a Geodude and Sandshrew for Baoba's test before you enforce this rule, however if you attempt to catch any other Pokemon this rule is automatically enforced)
-Non-wild Pokemon do not count against an area (ie: Bill's Eevee, the Togepi Egg, Primo eggs in Violet Town).
-Storyline wild pokemon (Red Gyarados, Sudowoodo, Snorlax) DO count against an area. So if you fight a Magikarp in the Lake of Rage before you talk to the Red Gyarados, you may not capture the Red Gyarados.
-If by some miracle you make it through Routes 29 or 30 and get your first Pokeballs without fighting a wild Pokemon, those routes are fair game. -National Park Contest is the same area as the National Park. Meaning if you fight a poke in the park, you cannot capture one in the contest.
-Anything not covered by the rules is fair game.
Some general observations before I get to my story so far. I'm probably going to up the difficulty if I do another Nuzlocke challenge in the future.
Observations
Duplicate Pokemon clause definitely makes the game loads easier. That way you don't get stuck with like 5 Rattata, 3 Hoothoot, or what have you. It comes down to "Do you want forced diversity, or do you want a chance at screwing yourself?" Personally I'm all about diversity with my Pokemans.
Unlimited item availability basically means the only thing that's going to kill your Pokemon is carelessness, running out of money, or bad luck, which definitely makes it easy mode. No item usage at all is pretty nutso, and takes a lot of balls to pull off (and I don't mean Poke Balls either). No buying items (and only using items you find) means you have to rely on item drops and/or Pickup, and is probably a more balanced approach. Not sure about growing Berries, but unlike in DPPt Berry availability isn't as much (as you can only grow 4 Berry plants at a time and you have to rely on Mom buying them and delivering them to the Pokemart).
If you're into limited Poke Balls, HG/SS has a serious lack of Poke Balls of any kind later in the game unless you have a Pokemon with Pickup. Could also use Kurt's Apricorn Balls, but since you can theoretically unload 99 Apricorns on him and pick them up the next day, it greatly increases the availability. Then again so does Pickup. Perhaps limiting yourself to only one Apricorn Ball a day and no more (since technically you aren't buying them, and there's a time delay). If you're a purist, the worst Apricorn Balls are Moon Ball (unless capturing a Clefairy, Jigglypuff, or a Nidoran) and Friend Ball (unless you're capturing a Pokemon that evolves by Happiness).
Unfortunately few Pokemon in HG/SS have Pickup, and with a Nuzlocke challenge you're very unlikely to encounter them. Even less likely to find a Pokemon with pickup in HG because Meowth isn't available at all. Aipom you'll have to wait until you get Headbutt and pray they pop out of trees in Route 33 or Azalea Town, and again pray it has Pickup instead of Technician.
No capture in Route 29 and 30 pretty much fucks you if you want a Sentret, which is an awesome HM slave when it evolves into Furret.
As I just recently discovered, getting 3 gift Pokemon from Primo in Violet City is pretty fucking nuts, especially since one of them is a Mareep. I might recommend limiting to one Pokemon only (or even none if you want to strictly interpret one Pokemon/Area and you want to use Togepi). This run I've already gotten all 3 Pokemon integrated into my team (and I'm too lazy to restart again), so no backing out now, but for future runs...
Goes without saying, buying Pokemon from the Goldenrod and Celadon Game Corners pretty much lets you defeat the purpose of a Nuzlocke challenge. Then again you could always limit yourself to how many you can buy (one total, one each, none at all). Keep in mind for Goldenrod, you also get an Eevee later in the game from Bill, so if you're strict about 1 Pokemon/Area, and you want to use Eevee, no Game Corner at all.
If you use the Pokewalker, you can pretty much break the game's difficulty curve if you get a few select Pokemon real early in the game (like Beldum, Munchlax, Kangaskhan, Dratini). But you could adapt it for usage in a Nuzlocke run if you want.
Setting battle type to SET definitely ups the difficulty, makes it harder to level some Pokes against some trainers too.
Enough of that nonsense. Lets get down to business.
Alpha's Pokemon career began like every other Pokemon trainer that began in New Bark Town, or Pallet Town, or what have you, so I'll skip the unimportant details. Alpha had an easy decision: Pick the starter Pokemon Cyndaquil (M) and name it
BetaMax, say bye to Mom, and pray to god that she doesn't run into any Pokemon in Routes 29 and 30 before getting any Poke Balls. Unfortunately a wild Sentret in Route 29 and a wild Pidgey in Route 30 ensured it would be a while before getting another Pokemon for this trainer. The douchebag red head
Gamma tried to stop Alpha with a stolen Totodile, but Cyndaquil's bad assery proved to be too much.
After receiving the first 5 Pokeballs from Ethan, Alpha proceeded to Route 46 and captured the first Pokemon in sight, a level 2 Rattata (F) that was named
DeltaFlyer. DeltaFlyer had Guts, meaning she wouldn't suck so bad in stress-inducing fights. BetaMax and DeltaFlyer plowed through the bug trainers of Route 30 and 31.
Before plowing through Route 31, a quick trip to the Dark Cave was necessary. Our spelunking heroes happened upon a surprised Level 2 Zubat (F). She was quickly captured and named
Epsilon 9. The team returned to Route 31, and told Bug Catcher Wade where to shove his Caterpies. Also in Route 31 was the newest member of the team, a level 4 Pidgey (F) named
Zeta. Zeta had the fortune of having a Keen Eye ability.
A quick trip to Route 36 to pick up HM06 followed by a visit to Route 32 led our heroine Alpha to the ultimate anti-Falkner weapon: the Level 6 Mareep (F) named
Eta Meson.
Alpha, BetaMax, DeltaFlyer, Epsilon 9, Zeta, and Eta Meson quickly bonded into a team. They enjoy long walks on the beach, delicious food, and kicking the tar out of Bellsprouts in the Sprout Tower. Although they bumped into a few Rattata along the way, no new friends made their acquaintance.
Finally the time came to challenge the bird brained gym leader Falkner and his two Bird Keeper lackeys Abe and Rod. Eta Meson scoffed at the ill-equipped minions, and with a couple bursts of electricity sent them crying to their mamas. Falkner was not amused, and opened his assault on Alpha and Eta Meson with a Pidgey. The Pidgey must have been retarded because it used Sand Attack instead of a useful attack. A thundershock was all it took to cook that goose.
Angered, Falkner sent his secret weapon: Pidgeotto. This bird charges at Eta Meson, hurting the pink sheep. However it counter-attacks with a strong ThunderShock. Pidgeotto charges again, striking home, but this time static electricity paralyzes the oversized rat with wings. Eta Meson unleashes another ThunderShock, scoring a critical hit, and turning Falkner's dreams into lunch meat.
Alpha leaves the Gym with Zephyr Badge in hand. Professor Elm calls says to pick up an egg in the Poke Mart. Alpha also uses this opportunity to verbally assail some lunatic TV guy in the Pokemon Center for three more eggs.
Night falls and a return trip to the Sprout Tower is in order. At night wild Gastly haunt the place, and as luck would have it one would attack our heroine. Unphased by the Level 5 Gastly (M), the team weakens the ghost, the Poke Ball finds its mark, and
Thetality joins the ranks.
It's not long until the four eggs hatch, giving rise to the next four members of the team:
Togepi (M) named
Iota. Delightful egg Pokemon, but it has a worthless Hustle ability. Being born with Extrasensory makes it a powerful force even at level 1.
Wooper (F) named
KappaKappa. It's ability is quite Damp.
Another Mareep (M) which is named
Lambda.
Finally a Slugma (F) named
Mu Mu Milk.
Lambda and Eta Meson don't get along at all (Eta Meson is the Alpha Female), so Lambda goes into stasis for another day as a permanent backup. It's unlikely it will be needed anytime soon, if ever. Thetality isn't a good fit to the party either, and is relegated to backup status.
Route 32 is fairly uneventful, although Fisherman Henry's Poliwag is a pain due to Hypnosis. Now our Heroine Alpha rests in the Pokemon center, and her Pokemon are enjoying a good night's rest too.
Current Party
BetaMax: Level 11 Cyndaquil (M)
Epsilon 9: Level 11 Zubat (F)
Iota: Level 10 Togepi (M)
Zeta: Level 11 Pidgey (F)
DeltaFlyer: Level 11 Rattata (F)
KappaKappa: Level 8 Wooper (F)
In Stasis
Lambda: Level 1 Mareep (M)
Mu Mu Milk: Level 8 Slugma (F)
Thetality: Level 5 Gastly
Eta Meson: Level 13 Mareep
Deceased
None (yet)
*edit* honestly, I might just toss out this attempt on account of Primo's eggs (Togepi is much sexier than Slugma anyway).