bludz said:TDK brought up Alomomola to B- (woops typoed at first) as a potential move, citing Zapdos as a pokemon that isn't particularly more viable. I'm not sure how I feel about it but I think there's merit to this argument. Alomomola is pretty solid for a stallmon, and it helps that SubCM Keldeo (one of the former biggest threats to stall, and a mon that sets up on Alomo easily) is basically not used now. Many semistalls can rely on things without reliable recovery and having a solid wishpasser is pretty imperative to that.
Anyway guess what I wanna know is your guys' thoughts on this. Obvious traits aside, what analysis would bring you to either conclusion (rise or stay)?
i think it should move up. being a check to keldeo and switching into several common attackers like garchomp, azumarill, diancie, lando, and lopunny for the most part, confortably is pretty great. scald to fish for burns (no pun intended), knock off for utility, and toxic to cripple walls, massive wish support (which is rather easy for it to use) with regenerator, and defensive stats that allow it to act as a solid mixed wall.
its defenses + regenerator + good defensive typing make it stupidly hard to wear down and defeat. i think we all know from experience how annoying amoonguss and slowbro can be.
it's physical bulk is pretty decent compared to slowbro
252+ Atk Tough Claws Mega Charizard X Dragon Claw vs. 36 HP / 220 Def Alomomola: 177-208 (36.8 - 43.3%) -- 98.9% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
252+ Atk Tough Claws Mega Charizard X Dragon Claw vs. 252 HP / 232+ Def Slowbro: 127-151 (32.2 - 38.3%) -- 1.5% chance to 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
it's special defenses are pretty neat too, taking stuff like grass knot from mega metagross better than suicune and slowbro can.
not being able to twave threats like charizard x is kind of a bummer, but it has plenty of other things going for it.
- wish support with its large hp stat can really be useful and having regenerator means that it doesn't always need to use wish on itself.
- regenerator and its bulk allows it to defensively pivot into threats like keldeo and attempt to cripple them, similar to slowbro
niches over other bulky waters:
- unlike slowbro, it's not weak to knock off and pursuit
- in comparison to slowking, it's access to wish, lack of dark type weakness and better physical bulk set them apart.
- wish + regenerator give it something over suicune, slowbro and slowking
the combination of those unique traits make it a pretty respectable bulky water type. and altogether, i think its niche is bigger and more relevant than the pokemon in C+ and a fine choice for stall and balance. yeah, im not against it rising
p2 said:i saw that mega aero is up for discussion down to b+ and after playing around with it im against it dropping. its speed tier is probably the best thing about it outpacing everything up to +1 gyara which is pretty incredible. aero is really great on offense right now outspeeding many key threats like keld zam torn serp and lop which a lot of these teams struggle with is honestly amazing because it relieves a ton of pressure off building. it isn't the hardest hitting mon but that's why it excels at cleaning because it hits hard enough to pick off nearly anything offensive. to be honest i think people take the wrong approach to using aero, trying to break walls with aqua tail and ice fang and shit but its far more effective at generating momentum and cleaning and by that i feel its best set is stone edge|aerial ace|roost|taunt which shuts off a ton of mons that would try to setup on aero and helps prevent clef aids from being too trigger happy with thunder wave. it also functions as an alright stallbreaker but its pretty limited to what it can check but preventing skarm hippo and ferro getting rocks up is huge for the teams aero fits on so yeah a fast taunt can be extremely useful in a lot of situations and i encourage everybody to try it on aero because i think 4 atk is a waste and tries to turn aero into something it isn't.
it's got its weaknesses but nah it doesn't need to drop yet. its really slept on right now.
i think the main problem ive always had with aerodactyl is the opportunity cost. there are times when teambuilding or in battle when i wish i had a potentially better mega, since aerodactyl struggles to do much against common defensive mons. back when tankchomp was more common, aerodactyl struggled a lot more than it probably does now. those were my problems with it anyway. ill have to play with it again to see if things have changed
that stallbreaker set looks cool though. stopping tankchomp, lando, skarm, hippo, and suicide leads like azelf from getting up rocks is great. taunt somewhat patching up its bad matchup against defensive pokemon like clefable that love to twave and it completely stopping gliscor also sounds pretty neat.
i can't say much else till i try the set myself (
p2 do you have replays by any chance?)