Here are some of the noms I don’t agree with :
Azumarill to A
I get that Volcanion existing makes Azumarill’s life worse, and that it can’t threaten offense as muich as it could, but you have to remember that Azumarill was already one of the best A+ ranks prior to Volcanion’s release, and even bordered on being S rank worthy. Obviously, that’s no longer the case, but it’s still a very splashable and threatening Pokemon, and quite clearly better than everything in A, and I’d argue a handful of A+ ranks too. Keep it where it is.
Jirachi to A+
As great as Scarf Jirachi is for balance and bulky offense (trust me, I use it on like, half my teams), it’s still extremely vulnerable to a lot of very common Pokemon, such as Garchomp, Rocky Helmet Landorus-T, Rotom-W, Ferrothorn, Excadrill, and yes, Volcanion. Because of this, it has a really hard time outlasting its checks, and you need to make sure stuff like Gardevoir doesn’t switch in more than once or twice if Jirachi is your only good check to it. So yeah, as much as I like Jirachi at the moment, it’s really not A+ material.
Metagross to B+
Not sure why this is getting hype now of all times, given that its 2 biggest competitors, Tyranitar and Jirachi, are pretty much at the peak of their effectiveness. And yeah, I guess that Metagross combines their two roles of Pursuit trapper and Fairy check, and it does it pretty well. But really, it does literally nothing else. It’s extremely one-dimensional (or I guess two-dimensional, since it does exactly two things), and is pretty much deadweight outside of its specific niches. TTar and Jirachi, on the other hand, are capable of providing a lot more than just Pursuit and Fairy checking respectively. Usually, even if you do specifically need both these roles filled on your team, you’re better off using either one of these and finding another way to fix your other weakness.
Doublade to D
The problem with Doublade is how heavily it relies on Rest. While in theory, it walls a variety of dangerous threats and that’s cool, in practice, it’s usually going to fail to do so because its only recovery is so shitty, and because it doesn’t even get Leftovers recovery to make up for it either.
It’s often going to be forced to Rest immediately after being sent out, since otherwise, it’ll be at too low health to switch in again. And once it does Rest, you need to get a Heal Bell off to actually switch into Gardevoir or Heracross or w/e again. Either that, or you can atempt to Wishpass to it, which a competent player won’t let you do, at least not over and over again.
It’s almost impossible to keep this thing healthy without giving free turns to the opponent, and it’s going to be a burden more often than not, and it’s going to inevitably be a burden vs players who actually know what they’re doing.
Not to mention that if the opponent isn’t using one of the 3 megas or one BL mon it walls, using it is basically pointless. Doublade simply isn’t worth it unless you want to be gimmicky and use XY stall or SD doublade offense or something. It shouldn’t be ranked, and honestly, the fact that it can be considered better than ranked stuff like Shuckle and Mienshao says more about the shittiness of said mons than Doublade’s viability.
Here are some of the noms I do agree with :
Goodra to C+
Yeah, this thing is pretty neat. Decent power with excellent coverage and surprisingly ok speed, nice defensive applications in being able to wall Serperior which really is a huge pain for a lot of teams, as well as dealing with Electrics and YZard. And of course, being a Volcanion switchin which is neither Pursuit bait nor completely passive is a great perk. It’s definitely more viable than the trash in C rank.
Amoonguss to B+
I actually kinda agree with this honestly. My biggest problem with Amoonguss is that once it’s gotten its Spore off, it kinda just sits there. It is admittedly very good at “just sitting there”, thanks to its bulk and Regen, it can keep switching in and out over and over again.
But what this does is severely elongate the battle, and unless you’re using hard stall, that’s not really a good thing. Even balance teams don’t want things lasting too long, since their offensive stuff will eventually get worn down, and their defensive stuff runs a higher and higher risk of getting haxed the more the battle goes on. And unless you can ensure hazards advantage or constant chip damage, repeatidely switching Amoonguss in and out will eventually cause problems.
It’s the same reason I don’t think Chansey should be B+ : it might stay alive, but that won’t prevent everything around it from dying. And although Amoonguss is definitely better since it doesn’t have to waste even more turns healing, it’s still a huge battle-extender, and ultimately, can be a liability on too many teams to be A- imo.
Gengar to A-
This was offhandedly brought up by ben gay, I’d like to talk about it more though, since it turns out most of the ranking team supports this move. I personally think Gengar should’ve dropped a while ago, I just never got round to suggesting it. And now that Chople and Scarf TTar builds are more popular than ever, it’s starting to seriously struggle.
Despite having probably the best STAB in the tier, Gengar is only really that threatening to balanced teams. Offense has no real excuse for letting it come in, Bulky Offense can also prevent it from switching in most of the time, and even if it doesn’t, it has stuff like Torn-T, Raikou and various faster threats to switch in at least once. Stall usually has a Pursuiter that can check it, and even when it doesn’t, the combination of Chansey and Sableye can usually handle it okay. And with the popularity of Scarf TTar on balance, being Pursuitable is a huge disadvantage for any wallbreaker, hence why Hoopa-C is only C+ rank despite having literally no counters. It has a few nice utility moves, but lacks the bulk to use them well, and forgoing Icy Wind makes fast stuff even more of a pain.
It’s just hard to fit on teams atm since it barely provides anything defensively as opposed to other wallbreakers, and although its speed is a pretty big advantage all things considered, it’s not really enough to keep it A rank imo, I really don’t think it’s better than Starmie atm.
That being said, I’m really unsure about it being 2 whole ranks below Thundurus, which IMO is comparable to it in many ways, and below Kyurem-B, which also has similar problems. I’ve also been playing around with a Specs set, which has been doing surprisingly well due to how spammable Shadow Ball is, and how many things can just barley take one or two from the LO set, and thus, get smashed by Specs. That being said, Specs still suffers from the same problems LO does for the most part, and honestly, I don’t see Gengar as a truly meta-defining threat anymore.
And here are my own suggestions :
Emboar to Unranked
I’ve probably said this before but this thing is just completely terrible, I honestly don’t know why it wasn’t unranked alongside Salamence and Haxorus tbh. I guess there are other questionable ranked mons that I could point out, such as like Mienshao, Krookodile, Meloetta, Shuckle and Froslass, but at least they have legitimate, albeit very minor niches. This really doesn’t. The only reason you’d ever use this over Infernape (which is faster, wallbreaks better thanks to its ability to go mixed, and has reliable recovery making it also better defensively), or even over one of the plethora of way better wallbreakers avalible in OU, is as a Dark resist on Trick Room. And even then, there are way better choices such as Crawdaunt, Azumarill, and TTar, which are much less reliant on TR, less vulnerable to common stuff like Talonflame, Garchomp, Latios, and more importantly, don’t kill themselves while attacking.
Emboar should probably never have been ranked in the first place, and removing it from the list is long overdue.
MVenu to A-
I’m actually really unsure about this one, and to be fair, Gary2346 was the one who originally brought it up, before saying he doesn’t really see MVenu in the same rank as MAlt or MAero.
Personally, I’m completely fine with MVenu and MAlt sharing the same rank, MAero less so, though I have never used/seen it so I can’t comment. MVenu being in the same rank as Amoonguss I really don’t agree with though, but as I said, I want it to drop so w/e.
But yeah, I do think MVenu isn’t too great anymore. Its main selling point is being able to beat a large portion of the metagame at once, including 2 S rank threats (namely Keldeo and Clefable), while also maintaining a good amount of offensive presence. Thing is, it doesn’t do that. It doesn’t beat Keldeo, because it’s eventually going to get burnt, at which point it’s hard pressed to switch into anything. It doesn’t beat Clefable, becuase it’s just going to get TWaved and set up on. This means that, if you use MVenusaur, you still need to find a secondary check to both of these, which kinda defeats the point of using MVenu in the first place.
That’s the problem with MVenu : it’s so prone to chip damage from burns and hazards and sand that it ends up struggling against stuff it should be able to beat. You can run more bulk to take them on more easily, but that just makes you more prone to beaing beaten by stuff like Talonflame or Latios.
Speaking of which, Mega Latias is defenitely better as Mega Venusaur imo : it also acts as a catch-all check to things, and while it’s not as threatening offensively, its extra speed gives it much more flexibility when facing stuff like Keldeo and YZard. MVenu, on the other hand, needs to stay healthy at all times and is constantly pressured, making it pretty easy to overwhelm. It’s not really that good atm, especially with Azumarill becoming slightly less of a threat, and while it’s still a great glue, it’s more on par with MAltaria than MLatias.
Torn-T to A+
Controversial nom time! I actually don’t know how I feel about this one either tbh, and this is less of an actual nom and more of a general discussion point. But I do think Torn-T has gotten worse recently, mainly due to the rise of Sand, and conversely, of Rotom-W, as well as other trends like Scarf Jirachi, Rocky Helmet Landorus-T, Chople TTar and Banded Pursuit Weavile all becoming more popular as of late.
LO is IMO the best set and the set that makes it S rank, it can really break apart defensive teams, but it struggles a bit vs more offensive teams since it can’t really switch in on much, especially the many bulky offense teams that use Rotom-W as a pivot. AV is honestly pretty overrated imo, it tends to struggle vs more bulky teams and is pretty limited in what it can do, although it’s pretty good vs offense.
Overral, I think Torn-T isn’t quite as splashable, consistent, or meta-defining as either of the other current S ranks, and that recent metagame trends have made it less effective. Not sure if this really warrants a drop since it’s still better than almost all of A+, but it’s still something I think should be discussed.