Xephyr said:It's not about interesting and educational. We're trying to make the best possible mono water team. That includes Politoed.
I'd argue that while yes, we are trying to make the "best possible" Mono-Water team, we are also trying to learn something about the team-building process - that is, learning to tailor Pokemon to fill specific roles that may not be covered in their on-site analysis. So, yes, it is about being educational.
As far as being interesting goes, maybe making the obvious Politoed/Quagsire/Rotom-W/Gyarados/Empoleon/Jellicent is interesting to you, but I'd think that at least attempting to give the less-used Waters, like Floatzel and Poliwrath, a shot at this. That's a much more challenging prospect than slapping the blatantly obvious choices together and calling it a night.
Edit:
Both of you kind of miss the point. It is perfectly fine to break rocks down into sand on a Drizzletoed team. This isn't progressive jazz, there's a way to make a palatable, original mono-Water team by using some bog standards.
You're right that some bog standards are going to wind up on this team; it's pretty much unavoidable. I was just saying that putting Politoed on a Mono-Water team is so blindingly obvious that it would be much more educational to at least try and be successful at the concept without him.
Edit 2:
To further clarify my point now that it's morning and I'm a little more awake, I just think it's silly to automatically declare Politoed required when there's such a massive pool of fully-evolved Water types to pull from. Wasn't the huge amount of options Water provides one of the main selling points? Yes, you still have five more team slots if you feel Politoed is required but...it just seems like a really boring option to me.