I see, I misunderstood what they meant. I don't have too much of an opinion on whether or not the meta is healthy, but I do think Tauros is the hardest one to drop.
_________________________________________________________________
I've been running around with this:
:Starmie::Gyarados::Golem::Zapdos::Chansey::Tauros:
Team Explanation
The idea being that you switch Golem into :Snorlax: to encourage it to click Reflect, Ice Beam, or Earthquake, then switch in Zapdos or Gyarados to hit Snorlax on the special side. Golem flat out counters Zapdos and Jolteon so that that Gyarados and Zapdos don't have to deal with them. Against Rhydon, Golem at least provides a potential switch into it as it may Rock Slide or Body Slam. If Tauros comes in early against Golem, you might have to just blow up.
Anyway, I feel like Golem replaces Snorlax well on this team since you now have answers to Cloyster, Slowbro, Rhydon, Zapdos, and Jolteon. And Zapdos does pretty well against triple Psychic imo, as a wall breaker or a sweeper, if possible. Snorlax gets walled by stuff like Cloyster, Gengar, opposing Snorlax, Chansey if it has Counter (and Lax doesn't have EQ) or Reflect. Zapdos and Gyarados don't really mind Snorlax's Reflect set, since they both hit on the special side, while also making it harder to switch stuff in because they hit on the Physical side as well. Chansey is mandatory as a status absorber, wall, paralysis spreader, and sleep inducer.
I know Gyara isn't ranked at least E1 currently, but I prefer it over Lapras on this team. Its Tbolt weakness does not really bother me, more so the Hydro Pump misses do. I don't see Gyarados as being outclassed on this particular team by any mon due to its Attack and Speed stats, immunity to EQ and resistance to water type attacks (Clamp and Surf). Not sure if Snorlax would be a good replacement. B/C we have it at E2 in the Jank discussion I feel like I can get away with bringing it up.
I've seen the post about the 5% Chansey thing before. I'm not thoroughly convinced Chansey is more droppable than Lax, but that may just come with experience. Maybe it's Snorlax's staying power that I'm not considering. When it comes to versatility I am pretty sure I am aware of the possibilities. Though, I'll try to use them more to update my perspective.
____________________________________________
:y/Snorlax:
Something I have wanted to do is talk about the different Snorlax sets. Hyper Beam from Snorlax is insane.
I see lax as mandatory on triple Psychic teams due to it being a switch into Tauros and opposing Snorlax, as well as providing Physical power.
My personal rankings of Snorlax Sets (there are too many to include them all)
Snorlax Set Rankings
S
1. Reflect + Rest + Selfdestruct: I really like self-destruct as an option to potentially go 2 for 1, break through a team, or as a last resort to prevent a sweep. Negatives are that it gets walled by Rock and Ghost types.
2. Reflect + Rest + Hyper Beam: Hyper Beam is incredibly helpful for getting rid of things that just won't die. Negatives are that it gets walled by Rock and ghost types.
3. Body Slam + EQ + Hyper Beam + Self Destruct: This is probably my favorite Snorlax set, but it requires you to run mons that are considered less consistent, i.e. :Cloyster::Porygon::Gengar::Rhydon::Articuno::Moltres::Omastar:. But it's really good at wall breaking, then blowing up. It unfortunately still gets walled by Cloyster, but Cloyster doesn't want to get paralyzed. Because Reflect Lax is so common, opponents may let you Hyper Beam them, if you reveal EQ, just b/c they don't expect it.
4. Reflect + Rest + Ice Beam: A lax that specializes in beating other lax. It has issues getting over things like Counter Chansey, but it does beat Rhydon and other Rock types. If Rhydon is being favored, this may be a good option. The mirror seems lame. I see beating opposing Snorlax more important than not being stopped by the likes of Gengar.
5. Bolt Beam Amnesia + Selfdestruct: Great for forcing in Chansey, and maybe tricking :Starmie:. Not much walls it outside of :Chansey: and it still has a chance to remove it before attempting to blow up. Being able to remove Chansey can make way for special attackers such as :Moltres: and :Articuno:. Not really sure how it fairs against Cloyster. Though, when I used this set on a Triple Psychic team, I felt that I was at a disadvantage.
6. Reflect + Rest + Earthquake: I feel that most people know it for not getting stopped by Gengar, but I think its ability to get over Counter Chansey is the important bit, to me. It also can beat Rhydon and Golem. I'm just not really a fan of Reflect+EQ lax since it lacks the power that Hyper Beam provides. I suppose not getting halted by specific threats may be better than I think it is, but it can still be stopped by unparalyzed Chansey and opposing Lax. If I run into Counter a lot, and I need Reflect Lax, I am definitely using this set.
A
7. Body Slam + Counter + Hyper Beam/Earthquake + Self Destruct: Might be able to run this on triple Psychic teams due to Counter. I tend to avoid Counter since it feels inconsistent, but I can't deny its power. Missing EQ or Beam can kind of suck.
8. Body Slam + Reflect + Hyper Beam/Earthquake + Self Destruct: Arguably a trick set, instead of Rest, you have Self Destruct. Showing Relfect and EQ/Beam may make it more likely to blow up on the right mon.
9. Body Slam + Blizzard + Amensia + Self Destruct: I probably prefer Self Destruct over rest as a "things went wrong, I want an out" button. Has some wall breaking capabilities, and its ability to ignore opposing Snorlax's Reflect is nice.
B
10. Body Slam + Blizzard + Rest + Amnesia: One of the first sets I started out with. Amnesia is very alluring. I've fallen out of favor of this set, b/c Cloyster makes me sad. A potential sweeper I suppose.
11. Body Slam + Blizzard + Hyper Beam/Earthquake + Self Destruct: Not sure how I feel about this one, but it appears to be aiming to hit Rhydon hard, while also masking its set.
B-
12. Bide + Relfect + Rest: The one that I won't be able to convince anyone that it isn't just jank. It's an anti, anti Snorlax, as in, it out damages opposing Reflect+Ice Beam lax. In order for it to get Bide off, you need to paralyze the opposing Chansey and Snorlax, or just the Chansey and pray to win a speed tie against the opposing lax later, and have Reflect up for protection. A tiny, single, dink from a Body Slam against +2 Def Lax can turn into like 400 damage. Most mons can't take that, (though Substitutes can protect them). The time when Bide fires off is unpredictable, so it makes it hard to time Rest. Bide also makes players do weird stuff like spam Reflect or Rest, allowing you to get a free switch to something else (you can freely switch in gen 1). :Starmie:, in particular, likes free switches into weakened Snorlax. Bide is a tool only to be used against opposing Snorlax, and maybe Chansey under some circumstances. This one ranks higher than a lot of the Amnesia sets in C b/c it still has Body Slam, and b/c of its uses.
To me the suggestion that Counter + Reflect Lax is viable, makes me feel that Bide lax has the potential to also be viable. Since Bide is like a Counter but it works on Ice Beam.
13. Toxic + Reflect: I know some may just see Toxic+Relfect as a meme, but it makes Reflect Chansey switch instead of making your lax switch. And Poison is not so bad against Chansey (depending on your team) since Poison increases the amount of times Chansey is going to use up Softboileds. It also aids your partial trappers. I'm putting this one lower b/c it may rely on running partial trappers, which are probably considered inconsistent. Toxic can also deal damage to opposing Lax as Snorlax Rests. You have to be careful not to poison the wrong mon, but I wouldn't be that too afraid of the possibility to not consider the potential uses of Toxic.
15. Reflect + Counter: A trick set. I've probably only seen this run once, maybe. Not sure how viable it is, but it's cool. Misses out on coverage, a way to bypass Counter, etc. The dex entry calls this a viable option, which is why I bring it up. If Slash users become popular, this set seems quite good. I am still trying to figure out this one's uses, I would need experience with it.
16. Amnesia + Body Slam + Reflect + Rest: If Reflect+Counter has some merit, then mono Normal has merit. A very stally set, but very hard to kill. The dex entry beings this one up, which I am surprised by. I find game ender sets fun, but have been too afraid to use them/not really thought about using them. I originally had this one lower, but I am wondering how it fairs against Ice Beam Lax.
C
17. Amnesia +Thunderbolt + Reflect + Rest: I find Tbolt superior to Ice beam when using Amnesia + Reflect as a game ender. Tbolt has more PP than Ice beam and is capable of demolishing Starmie. I've seen a player that goes by MewtwoSaki use Toxic Zapdos which allows you to lure in Rhydon, pray that it does not have Rest (Rhydon likes Body Slam over Rest for Starmie, it may even run Tail Whip), and poison it so that Snorlax can stall it out. It also appreciates Chansey being poisoned, to make it use up Softboileds.
18. Body Slam + Thunderbolt + Rest/Seldestruct + Amnesia: Never ran this, it's mentioned in the dex entry, but I do like bolt/beam, so I might like this as well.
19. Amnesia + Reflect + Blizzard + Body Slam: A potential game ender set, it lacks Rest, but still has staying power.
20. Amnesia + Ice Beam + Reflect + Rest: This is a freeze fishing set. You can't be too greedy when using it, and you may need to undo all your set up at times. I'm personally not a big fan of this one, but I've seen replays of it used in tournament.
D
20. Lv85 + Seismic Toss: Seems more for fun and outclassed by other options. The person I saw use it had high Elo, which makes me curious if it's better than I think it is, But I've seen High Elo players use unusual things that I don't think work, like Lead Arcanine, which I beat, Agility+Sharpen Porygon, which didn't do anything, and Porygon that just paralyzes something rather than walling Snorlax. I've also run into Lickitung, which I could have beat if Tentacruel didn't miss Hydro Pump.
??? There are still more options like Fish Lax. Not sure how I feel about coverage like Rock Slide or Psychic. Surf + Amnesia sounds not so good to me. Mega Kick and Double Edge seem like weird techs, but if you can find uses for them that's cool.
_____________________________________________________
Feel free to poke holes in my logic or tell me some sets are better or worse than I think they are. I may change my opinion now, or some day in the future. I haven't used Amnesia Lax too much outside of the bolt beam one, so that might be why my opinion on the Amnesia sets are not higher.
Questions
1. How do you feel about single attacking Reflect + Amnesia + Rest sets? Are they viable or just memes?
2. I've noticed that the new sample teams seem to have phased out Amnesia sets, does this say anything about their viability?
3. Is Toxic + Reflect really all that bad? It's mentioned in the dex entry, I've used it and have liked it. I'm convinced that Toxic has its uses and that it's just not spammable like it is in future gens. Snorlax runs Toxic better than Chansey imo.
4. Do you still see Bide lax as Jank? My argument for it not being all that bad is that it allows you to gain free switches, out damage Ice Beam Lax, and it only using up 1 moveslot, I'm not convinced it's that bad, but I will play with more standard teams to try to understand why more standard Snorlax stuff is seen as so good.
____________________________________
Edit: Ran into a situation where running mono normal lax was very bad, when running a sample team. Player used Chansey as the sleep sack of Gengar, which I'm not used to. Kind of was spacy at the time, but I'm wondering if I was too harsh on EQ Lax.
Edit: I surprised TehTayTay with Bide, I think it really is just underrated...
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen1ou-2020858805