-
Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
smogoff amoonguss — end
- Thread starter az
- Start date
I haven't said this before because I was afraid of looking sus but to be honest I am almost always in favor of voting for someone rather than doing nothing and skip voting. Yes, we have a higher chance at hitting a scientist but I think the benefits of lynching someone outweigh the costs. Like if we vote someone out, we're getting at least some kind of information out of the game based off which way they flip when they die. And even if we don't get that information we'll at least have posts to look back on to see who was in favor vs. who was opposed, like we can read into who was trying to steer the discussion in a certain direction as to whether we should kill the person or not. Overall, I just think it's much better to not skip, we should get rid of someone.
As for who, I haven't really decided who I would vote for yet. One of the only things I'm kind of certain of is that I believe monkfish since no one has counterclaimed his role as project leader
As for who, I haven't really decided who I would vote for yet. One of the only things I'm kind of certain of is that I believe monkfish since no one has counterclaimed his role as project leader
If no one is going to counterclaim mf, then I'll just assume that he's telling the truth. This would leave bb skarm and cityscape to be the other two who claim to have been alone. In my opinion, it would be best to vote one of them out if we do choose to do that.
cityscapes and bb skarm, do you have anything to defend yourself with?
cityscapes and bb skarm, do you have anything to defend yourself with?
For the sake of argument, coming out as a Mayor archetype puts a target on your ass, especially so soon. I wouldn't be shocked if mf is killed the first chance the imposters get if it's true.
Maybe we will find out if birds are real...
anyway bb skarm sus
Either that or Scarf/ total Clefairy were lead and he’s been playing us all along, which is a massive ball play and honestly earns my respect.
Furthermore, it would make sense to place town reads with mf , to minimize the chance of possible 50/50's
Personally nominating shadowpeashooter since he's basically confirmed, unless we want to place more people.
Personally nominating shadowpeashooter since he's basically confirmed, unless we want to place more people.
Good catch. az, do the impostors know if they kill the project lead? If they do, then we can keep mf on the radar.
I believe the old man is sleeping
I think that dematerializing someone from one of the pairs of 2 is best. It's 99% likely that the pairs share the same alignment, so killing one gets us info on the other.
Right now I think that's the best method town has of getting concrete info - I think any other dematerializations are essentially crapshoots that have a meaningful chance of doing nothing, and I think town can't afford to do nothing (even if there is a small chance we get lucky and get an impostor).
Right now I think that's the best method town has of getting concrete info - I think any other dematerializations are essentially crapshoots that have a meaningful chance of doing nothing, and I think town can't afford to do nothing (even if there is a small chance we get lucky and get an impostor).
9 because we want a scientist majority in that room if 4 impostors go to it
Wouldn't the people that were in the rooms that the impostors were supposed to go to know that they weren't there
You mean if we split into multiple groups of 3/4? You're definitely right about that, didn't think of that before.
The only concerns there would be if multiple impostors were assigned to a group of 3/4. They could then leave the group and pin blame on the crewmate all while getting kills, making it a bit difficult.
Here are all the groups of 2 btw:
Storage: shadowpeashooter, M24
Security: Hulavuta, Mace
Dematerialization: phoopes, zxgzxg
i personally town read shadowpeashooter and to a lesser extent mace. i think dematerializing someone from dematerialization (
) is best, but would also be fine with a security person getting thrown off the ship
night plan:
we need to stack utilities with everyone tonight, at least 13 people (4 impostors, 4 victims, 4+1 leftover scientists to tell us what happened) so it might as well be all of us. we have safety in numbers!
day plan:
Sijih and zorbees pointed out that we can get some valuable information by dematerialising anyone who was in a room of 2. if they turn out to be a scientist then their partner was almost certainly a scientist too, and if they are an impostor then their partner was almost certainly an impostor.
we need to stack utilities with everyone tonight, at least 13 people (4 impostors, 4 victims, 4+1 leftover scientists to tell us what happened) so it might as well be all of us. we have safety in numbers!
day plan:
Sijih and zorbees pointed out that we can get some valuable information by dematerialising anyone who was in a room of 2. if they turn out to be a scientist then their partner was almost certainly a scientist too, and if they are an impostor then their partner was almost certainly an impostor.
impostors don't receive role pms on kill
but th first night check doesnt count for anything, i dont think anyone would bother lying
Flipping a 2 room team makes a lot of sense to me, I have also said they are likely to have made this kill.
The only 2 room team i feel comfortable voting is Dematerialization based on today.
The 4 other people have given me every reason to believe they're town with activity and genuine conversation, and zxgzxg's reaction reads as lurking until they see their own name.
The only 2 room team i feel comfortable voting is Dematerialization based on today.
The 4 other people have given me every reason to believe they're town with activity and genuine conversation, and zxgzxg's reaction reads as lurking until they see their own name.
Imo bb skarm is the most sus here so voting him is logical. Also, we can't exactly risk a scientist dying or else we have 13 scientists left.
Also, I don't think killing someone in security is the best move, as I'm getting a town read on Hula. Also when he is looking in the cams there is no reason Mace couldn't have killed him, and he couldn't have killed Mace because he was looking in cams. And I'm leaning towards scientist on Mace anyway.
If we are talking about killing someone in dematerialization then I suggest killing zxgzxg because he didn't say anything until he saw his name (like Blazade said) and when he did talk he just said that no don't vote today just stick together. I mean the imps wouldn't want scientists sticking together but that just looked like trying to save himself. We'll most likely find out phoopes's alignment afterward and he seems more trustworthy anyway.
Also, I don't think killing someone in security is the best move, as I'm getting a town read on Hula. Also when he is looking in the cams there is no reason Mace couldn't have killed him, and he couldn't have killed Mace because he was looking in cams. And I'm leaning towards scientist on Mace anyway.
If we are talking about killing someone in dematerialization then I suggest killing zxgzxg because he didn't say anything until he saw his name (like Blazade said) and when he did talk he just said that no don't vote today just stick together. I mean the imps wouldn't want scientists sticking together but that just looked like trying to save himself. We'll most likely find out phoopes's alignment afterward and he seems more trustworthy anyway.
if anyone else wants to livechat this then hit up the mf discord for a dedicated channel - quite a lot of theorising going on there atm
Homework will have to wait for my vote: zxgzxg (it looks like bb skarm gets to live to see another day)
Edit: maybe we shouldn't tag who we are voting. Otherwise zxgzxg will get like 10 tags and I get how annoyed you get when you get tagged repeatedly for the exact same thing. Edited my post accordingly too.
Edit: maybe we shouldn't tag who we are voting. Otherwise zxgzxg will get like 10 tags and I get how annoyed you get when you get tagged repeatedly for the exact same thing. Edited my post accordingly too.