• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

Smogon's Top Video Games List - Stage 2 (Current topic - REDEMPTIONS)

I suggest we create a thread to list characteristics, what should be rated (mechanics, setting, sound, graphics, replay value, etc.) and then we can proceed to how to properly use them.
 
999: 9 persons 9 hours 9 doors ABSTAIN
Ace Attorney Investigations ABSTAIN
Ace of Spades ABSTAIN
Actraiser ABSTAIN
Advance Wars 2: Black Hole Rising ABSTAIN
Advance Wars: Dual Strike ABSTAIN
Age of Empires YES
Age of Empires 3 ABSTAIN
Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings ABSTAIN
Age of Mythlogy: The Titans ABSTAIN
Age of Mythology ABSTAIN
Amnesia: The Dark Descent ABSTAIN
Angry Birds NO
Animal Crossing YES
Animal Crossing: City Folk ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing: Wild World ABSTAIN
Ape Escape ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed 2 ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood ABSTAIN
Banjo-Kazooie ABSTAIN
Banjo-Tooie ABSTAIN
Bastion ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos Origins ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean ABSTAIN
 
Corka said:
I suggest we create a thread to list characteristics, what should be rated (mechanics, setting, sound, graphics, replay value, etc.) and then we can proceed to how to properly use them.
Click to expand...

Jesus fuck, if this gets anything like tiering i am out.
 
999: 9 persons 9 hours 9 doors ABSTAIN
Ace Attorney Investigations ABSTAIN
Ace of Spades ABSTAIN
Actraiser ABSTAIN
Advance Wars 2: Black Hole Rising ABSTAIN
Advance Wars: Dual Strike ABSTAIN
Age of Empires YES
Age of Empires 3 NO
Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings YES
Age of Mythlogy: The Titans ABSTAIN
Age of Mythology ABSTAIN
Amnesia: The Dark Descent YES
Angry Birds YES
Animal Crossing ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing: City Folk ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing: Wild World ABSTAIN
Ape Escape ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed 2 ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood ABSTAIN
Banjo-Kazooie ABSTAIN
Banjo-Tooie ABSTAIN
Bastion YES
Baten Kaitos Origins ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean ABSTAIN

Whoever keeps voting for AoE III stop it that was a terrible game.
 
Abstain on everything but:
999: yes
Ace attourney: yes
AoE 3: no
AoE 2 Age of kings: no
Amnesia: yes
Angry Birds: yes
 
999: 9 persons 9 hours 9 doors ABSTAIN
Ace Attorney Investigations NO
Ace of Spades ABSTAIN
Actraiser NO
Advance Wars 2: Black Hole Rising ABSTAIN
Advance Wars: Dual Strike ABSTAIN
Age of Empires ABSTAIN
Age of Empires 3 ABSTAIN
Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings ABSTAIN
Age of Mythlogy: The Titans ABSTAIN
Age of Mythology ABSTAIN
Amnesia: The Dark Descent ABSTAIN
Angry Birds ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing: City Folk ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing: Wild World ABSTAIN
Ape Escape ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed 2 NO
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood ABSTAIN
Banjo-Kazooie NO
Banjo-Tooie ABSTAIN
Bastion ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos Origins ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean ABSTAIN

We should just write in titles we're voting 'yes' or 'no' for imo.
 
999: 9 persons 9 hours 9 doors ABSTAIN
Ace Attorney Investigations ABSTAIN
Ace of Spades ABSTAIN
Actraiser ABSTAIN
Advance Wars 2: Black Hole Rising YES
Advance Wars: Dual Strike YES
Age of Empires ABSTAIN
Age of Empires 3 ABSTAIN
Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings ABSTAIN
Age of Mythlogy: The Titans ABSTAIN
Age of Mythology ABSTAIN
Amnesia: The Dark Descent ABSTAIN
Angry Birds ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing YES
Animal Crossing: City Folk ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing: Wild World ABSTAIN
Ape Escape ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed 2 ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood ABSTAIN
Banjo-Kazooie YES
Banjo-Tooie ABSTAIN
Bastion ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos Origins YES
Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean YES
 
999: 9 persons 9 hours 9 doors ABSTAIN
Ace Attorney Investigations ABSTAIN
Ace of Spades ABSTAIN
Actraiser ABSTAIN
Advance Wars 2: Black Hole Rising ABSTAIN
Advance Wars: Dual Strike ABSTAIN
Age of Empires ABSTAIN
Age of Empires 3 ABSTAIN
Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings YES
Age of Mythlogy: The Titans ABSTAIN
Age of Mythology ABSTAIN
Amnesia: The Dark Descent ABSTAIN
Angry Birds (FUCK) YES
Animal Crossing ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing: City Folk ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing: Wild World YES
Ape Escape ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed NO
Assassin's Creed 2 NO
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood NO
Banjo-Kazooie ABSTAIN
Banjo-Tooie ABSTAIN
Bastion ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos Origins ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean ABSTAIN
 
999: 9 persons 9 hours 9 doors ABSTAIN
Ace Attorney Investigations NO
Ace of Spades ABSTAIN
Actraiser ABSTAIN
Advance Wars 2: Black Hole Rising ABSTAIN
Advance Wars: Dual Strike YES
Age of Empires ABSTAIN
Age of Empires 3 ABSTAIN
Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings ABSTAIN
Age of Mythlogy: The Titans NO
Age of Mythology NO
Amnesia: The Dark Descent ABSTAIN
Angry Birds NO
Animal Crossing NO
Animal Crossing: City Folk NO
Animal Crossing: Wild World YES
Ape Escape NO
Assassin's Creed YES
Assassin's Creed 2 ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood ABSTAIN
Banjo-Kazooie ABSTAIN
Banjo-Tooie ABSTAIN
Bastion ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos Origins ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean ABSTAIN
 
999: 9 persons 9 hours 9 doors YES
Ace Attorney Investigations ABSTAIN
Ace of Spades ABSTAIN
Actraiser ABSTAIN
Advance Wars 2: Black Hole Rising ABSTAIN
Advance Wars: Dual Strike ABSTAIN
Age of Empires ABSTAIN
Age of Empires 3 ABSTAIN
Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings ABSTAIN
Age of Mythlogy: The Titans ABSTAIN
Age of Mythology ABSTAIN
Amnesia: The Dark Descent ABSTAIN
Angry Birds NO
Animal Crossing YES
Animal Crossing: City Folk ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing: Wild World ABSTAIN
Ape Escape ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed 2 ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood ABSTAIN
Banjo-Kazooie YES
Banjo-Tooie YES
Bastion YES
Baten Kaitos Origins ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean ABSTAIN
 
I think for now I'm going to just say that if a game receives more YES votes than NO votes, it can remain on the list (for the time being). If it receives equal or less YES votes than NO votes, it will be removed. As the list gets smaller, if we discover we'll need more rounds of voting to eliminate more games, the requirements will get stiffer. This initial process is really just to weed out the obvious unworthies in the list. I know some of you will be unhappy with some removals, but as has been stated before this list is not going to be perfect, and I promise once we're down to 100 games there WILL be discussion and a well-built rating system to rank the games #1-100 in a way that most of us can be happy with.

Also, can someone help me find a place where I can post a poll like this one for free that DOESN'T limit me to 50 responses? That'd be great for the next round, since keeping track by hand is a hueg pain in the ass.
 
999: 9 persons 9 hours 9 doors ABSTAIN
Ace Attorney Investigations ABSTAIN
Ace of Spades ABSTAIN
Actraiser YES
Advance Wars 2: Black Hole Rising ABSTAIN
Advance Wars: Dual Strike ABSTAIN
Age of Empires ABSTAIN
Age of Empires 3 NO
Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings YES
Age of Mythlogy: The Titans ABSTAIN
Age of Mythology ABSTAIN
Amnesia: The Dark Descent NO
Angry Birds NO
Animal Crossing ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing: City Folk ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing: Wild World ABSTAIN
Ape Escape ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed NO
Assassin's Creed 2 NO
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood NO
Banjo-Kazooie YES
Banjo-Tooie YES
Bastion NO
Baten Kaitos Origins YES
Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean ABSTAIN
 
pool7.jpg
 
999: 9 persons 9 hours 9 doors ABSTAIN
Ace Attorney Investigations ABSTAIN
Ace of Spades ABSTAIN
Actraiser ABSTAIN
Advance Wars 2: Black Hole Rising YES
Advance Wars: Dual Strike NO
Age of Empires ABSTAIN
Age of Empires 3 ABSTAIN
Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings ABSTAIN
Age of Mythlogy: The Titans ABSTAIN
Age of Mythology ABSTAIN
Amnesia: The Dark Descent ABSTAIN
Angry Birds NO
Animal Crossing NO
Animal Crossing: City Folk ABSTAIN
Animal Crossing: Wild World ABSTAIN
Ape Escape ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed NO
Assassin's Creed 2 YES
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood NO
Banjo-Kazooie ABSTAIN
Banjo-Tooie ABSTAIN
Bastion ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos Origins ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean ABSTAIN

Edit: The Pool Has Elder Scrolls Morrowind twice, but one is "The Elder Scrolls III" and the other is with the rest of the Elder Scrolls Games. Also is there supposed to be a difference between "Little Big Planet" and "LittleBigPlanet"?
 
Ok folks! Group 1 has completed voting, and the following games were eliminated:

Ace of Spades
Age of Empires 3
Actraiser
Age of Mythlogy: The Titans
Age of Mythology
Animal Crossing: City Folk
Animal Crossing: Wild World
Angry Birds
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood
Baten Kaitos Origins


Also, the next group has been posted and is ready for voting. Please visit the link on the first post to complete the survey and cast your votes!
 
999: 9 persons 9 hours 9 doors ABSTAIN
Ace Attorney Investigations ABSTAIN
Ace of Spades ABSTAIN
Actraiser ABSTAIN
Advance Wars 2: Black Hole Rising ABSTAIN
Advance Wars: Dual Strike YES
Age of Empires ABSTAIN
Age of Empires 3 ABSTAIN
Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings YES
Age of Mythlogy: The Titans ABSTAIN
Age of Mythology ABSTAIN
Amnesia: The Dark Descent ABSTAIN
Angry Birds YES
Animal Crossing YES
Animal Crossing: City Folk YES
Animal Crossing: Wild World YES
Ape Escape ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed 2 ABSTAIN
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood ABSTAIN
Banjo-Kazooie YES
Banjo-Tooie ABSTAIN
Bastion ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos Origins ABSTAIN
Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean ABSTAIN
 
Question, are you going by the survey alone for votes or are you also reading the posts in the thread?

Either way, I cast my votes in the survey. Too many FPS games, ick! >.<
 
Well the first group began by counting votes in the thread, but it got to be too much work so I switched to the survey midway. The first round results were a combination of thread and survey votes, but from now on it'll just be the survey.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top