Divine Retribution said:This is a nonsensical question to ask given the context of the previous information. The answer is Dems and leftist don't have any opinion on the "DEI movement" because it's an overblown made-up phenomenon that doesn't mean what Republicans are desperately trying to make it mean. It's the same thing as CRT, really. I don't really get why you'd ask what we're looking for in a DEI politician if you acknowledge that people like Harris aren't just DEI politicians.
Excellent point. This knowledge of DEI- what it actually means, that is- this has been news to me so far. Now things are starting to make a bit more sense. Which, again, I have you to thank for because I wanted to learn and you were happy enough to answer my question. Now to actually answer why I wanted your opinions if I'm willing to acknowledge what you pointed out: there are three reasons:
- Apparently DEI didn't mean what I thought it did before writing my initial post, so I'll admit that's on me for being unaware despite still not wanting to be biased or offensive.
- From what I can tell, most of the people in this thread are at least slightly Democrat-leaning on average; this is perfectly fine by me, it's moreso that what I've grown up hearing and what I hear from this thread tends to not match up
- That second point wouldn't be a factor for me, if it wasn't for the fact that I haven't heard any Democrats going crazy about this compared to the Republican side. I would imagine that not all Republicans are like this, but the difference between parties in regards to whether or not this is a sensitive comment to make is night and day. Going back to my first point, what I thought going into this conversation was that DEI was just a way to describe a minority group, not unlike how many neurodiverse people, particularly kids/students (this is an area I have far more experience with than politics, hence the example) tend to have the "special ed" label slapped onto them by the schools they're attending. In other words, using that same logic, I can see why DEI is a sensitive and disrespectful term, both in general and towards these people.
Do I recognize now that this was a nonsensical question? Absolutely. Does this change my perspective on things? Even though it was such a sudden turn of events from my point of view, yes, I would say. It helps me a lot when I can try and explain things to myself in relating ways I can understand, too. Thanks again for your help, I really appreciate it.
TheMantyke said:My man, using the term "DEI president" "DEI Candidate" etc at all is wholesale swallowing right wing propaganda. It is the most recent trend this year to discredit minorities in any position by calling them a DEI hire, that they are incompitent at their job and only on board because of their race. It is the next brick on a long road of hateful dogwhistles. "Are you for or against the DEI movement?" is just such an incredibly broken question; where did you even hear people talking about a "DEI movement"?
Edit: Oops, late to reply. Keeping this up because I am genuinely interested how that question came into existence.
I was first "introduced" to the term DEI on the news at work the other day; I was working the front counter at my fast food job, and from where I stand I can see the TVs. I can't remember what day it was specifically, only that they were talking about the breaking news of Biden dropping out of the 2024 presidential race and that somehow the discussion shifted to why Harris isn't a qualified candidate. I wanted to pay more attention to what kind of nonsense they must have been spouting, but it was hard to do so given I had a job to do and the TV volume wasn't on very loud (no subtitles, either). My initial question had come into existence because I wanted other people's opinions that I knew wouldn't be so blatantly biased against Kamala Harris and the people who do support her work.
In other words, pretty much everything you just said checks out with what actually happened.
Chou Toshio said:Is it fair to assume that you believe in racial equality in civil society?
If so, your definition of DEI as stated would be meaningless, carry no connotation. It would just be a blank observation that the individual has a historically un(der)represented background— irrespective of qualifications. In an egalitarian society, such an observation would never carry a negative connotation.
But, we know that on the Republican side, in their media, from the lips of their loudest voices— DEI is ALWAYS embued with an extremely negative connotation.
That’s why those who believe in any sort of egalitarian society, civil society, genuine commitment to those virtues—
—will probably see it for what it is; just a veiled slur used by folks who really wish they could just say the n-slur.
Especially after the conversation that is ongoing, I do not believe I am in the right position to say what I necessarily believe in compared to what is morally and ethically right. It should, in theory, go without saying that being racist is a bad thing, but as we see time and time again, apparently this common sense has lost the "common" part. I would like to say that I believe in what is right for everyone depending on what they deserve, regardless of ethnicity or other factors, but what someone "deserves" is up to opinion much of the time. Do I
deserve to be making more money at my fast food job in the year 2024? Do I
deserve to have grown up listening to a pretty heavily conservative family not always say the most intelligent or respectful comments at family gatherings? At their core, bipartisan political conversations and debates are largely that- contrasting opinions that can have major effects on the good will of the country and its citizens. My point I'm trying to make is, I don't really know how to answer that question or what to believe. I feel like it's up to me to do my own research and form my own opinion after having looked at as many sides of the conversation as possible. I would like to push my old definition of DEI out the window and acknowledge the truth, if at all possible. No matter what ethnicity, background et cetera, someone is, that should not influence how I treat them. I don't think my family necessarily had the intention of raising me to be disrespectful, but I suppose there could always be more to that story behind the scenes that I haven't seen.