Rights groups want some hero banned from this forum
Alright, I was gonna refrain from posting in this thread, but fuck it, I'm drunk, so diving in.
Back in college, I was at a party with several friends. There was a totally regular guy there (a bit obnoxious, but otherwise, normal enough) that, out of the blue, began molesting a female friend of mine. She was, quite clearly, telling him to stop. Thing is, he was "that goofy guy", and everyone else there was laughing it off and saying shit like "oh, him".
I told the prick to stop. He looked me in the eyes, laughed, and proceeded to squeeze her tits. She looked at me, genuinely scared. So, I grabbed his hand, told him more firmly to stop, he grabbed at her thigh as everyone else laughed, and I broke his fucking hand, grabbed the motherfucker, and threw him into a wall (I was heavier/stronger then >.>)
I was the guy who was asked to leave. Actually, they demanded I apologize to the little fuck to boot. Instead, I chilled with my friend in the bathroom as she cried. On the other side of the door, he was taunting. No one else there fucking cared at all. Note, these were her close friends.
We left. At another party, we happened to run into him again. He pulled the same shit, with a completely different crowd. Once again, it was laughed off. This time, I pummeled the shit out of him. When asked why by some dude, I explained and he seemed to understand and be okay with it.
A few weeks later, at a pizza place, that same dude I had talked to came up to me and told me his girlfriend had been raped, multiple times, by the same fucking guy. She was afraid to testify alone against him, though. So, my friend and I went to testify with her. I was interrogated, for several hours, and accused of everything from heavy drug use (nope) to just making shit up (also, hey, nope). It wasn't until I flat out turned myself in for assault and asked that they at least look into the case that they said it was enough and stopped. One of the three detectives high fived me, saying he wished he could beat the shit out of a rapist. My statement as a whole was dismissed.
Instead, they made the girl that was raped multiple times call him up and ask about the entire ordeal on a taped recording. When he finally admitted, on a taped phone call, to raping her, they arrested him, and he was promptly bailed out. He then proceeded to taunt and harass both the girl he had raped and my friend that he molested. When the girl that he raped told the cops, he quickly moved out of state and they, once again, dismissed it.
He's still out there. He seems like just a regular guy. Nothing was done to actually stop him from continuing to rape and molest girls. His friends still stand by him, and excommunicated my friend and me, calling her humorless and me a crazed freak. This is, quite sadly, not the only case of a friend of mine being molested/raped that I've been informed of. It's just the only one where they were even willing to bring it to the police (and even then, only because a different girl that had been raped was too scared to do so by herself).
Rape is definitely out there, and it's way more accepted than you would think. It's not just the creepy guy in the alley. It's that goofy guy in your class. It's the hipster kid you know with awesome taste in music. It's your good friend's father. It's your other good friend's ex. And it's not taken seriously by law enforcement, society as a whole, and direct witnesses.
More on the topic of the OP: I'm actually opposed to censorship, and comedians should be allowed to say whatever fucked up stuff they want to if it's funny. That said, rape itself isn't funny, and a good comedian will know that the joke better be damn good if he's gonna try to pull it off. Tosh, quite clearly, didn't have the material to back it up. Audience members shouldn't interrupt a comic's schtick. Comedians should know that if their audience is genuinely, vocally opposed to their jokes, it's not really "funny" to talk about how funny it would be if they were then gang raped.
If you find rape to be funny, you probably don't realize that people that you know, people that you love, have been raped. Also, you probably don't realize that people that you know and love are rapists. Yes, there are rape victims and rapists on Smogon and in your real life. Do you think I'm being crazy and that you'd aware of that if it were true? Odds are, you really, really wouldn't if you think rape is funny.
Don't put words into my mouth. It matters because I can hardly imagine 1/30 of the male population going out at night and raping women in the bushes. There is a difference between that and, say, date rape or statutory rape.
A+++++ post, needs more attention.
There was no 'rape faq' in that link (wtf), she writes about what thoughts go through her mind in a situation where an acquaintance makes a rape joke, from her perspective as someone who was raped. I actually had no intention of making it seem like I was linking to a scholarly article, that was poor word choice, my bad next time I'll call it a narrative.
Also seriously fuck off, why are you talking on these forums if 'maybe we can't even be certain of anything, and we should all make sure all our posts are peer reviewed.' Like really, are you serious? I was trying to contribute something that I think is relevant to this. You know what else isn't peer reviewed? The New York Times. You're just asserting some vain elitism about trustability of sources. People respond to this blog in the exact same sense that they respond to other forms of journalism. I don't feel the need at this time to link to rape statistics, other people can handle that (it won't matter because it'll dismissed by the adolescent males on this forum a la confirmation bias)
There are other examples of situations that have been labeled as "rape" by our society that I would disagree with. Let's say Myzozoa and Oglemi are out on a date. They're in the car, gazing at the starry night sky, when Myzozoa starts to rub Oglemi's leg. Oglemi is uncomfortable with this and asks Myzozoa to stop, but Myzozoa says "but baby, I know you want it!" and starts getting friskier. Now, some would argue that rape has already taken place at this point, but I would disagree. I would say that what happens after this point will determine whether it's rape or not. If Oglemi were to get upset and the two were to have an argument, resulting in Oglemi walking away or Myzozoa grumpily taking Oglemi home in silence, then rape did not happen. If Myzozoa continues to forcefully touch and molest Oglemi and he does not try to resist him, then rape did not occur. If Oglemi resists and Myzozoa overpowers and continues to molest Oglemi, only then does it become rape. To me, the key word here is overpowers, meaning the line into rape is only crossed when one person overpowers another despite their resistance.
That being said, Tosh really should have his show canceled just because he's not funny, not because he made a rape joke. He's almost as un-funny as Chelsea Handler...
Also how dare you Chelsea Handler is a visionary and a saint! lol (I'm actually a really big fan, she has been fighting for and promotes gay rights all the time, and she's hilarious on top of it) :3
Here in Britain, we have a comedian called Franky Boyle, he makes outright racist jokes, rape jokes and a few holocaust jokes (I think), he seems very similar to this Tosh man, you either love him or hate him. The point in case being, while it is wholly unacceptable to make fun of rape, censoring him and all of his shows seems like a step to far, that petiton at the top of the page seems to show that most Americans (not the rape victims) are to sensitive to edgy humor. That is not an anti american statement just an observation.
A warning or something seems like enough to deter him from doing this again, cancelling his show is pretty much censorship.
But would it be funny if this girl got gang raped right this moment, like right now right now? That’s not a joke. It’s an invitation. It’s a celebration of a violent crime, which is itself another violation. It’s not a way to cope. It’s a “this is something we can do and then laugh about it, no big deal.” When you reiterate these half-truths (there are girls in the world getting raped by like five guys right now), they authenticate themselves, as if by magic. To promote the insidious—“rape is hilarious”—is to join the crime at its own filthy level.
lol your post is so far offbase that it's kind of ridiculous
I decided to actually look into the woman who wrote the blog that you linked to. If you click on "Home" she states that her blog has moved, and if you click on the corresponding link it brings you to her new homepage where she includes a Rape FAQ. In my resulting research on the author is when I found out the blog is simply that, a blog.
What I find interesting about her Rape FAQ is that not only does she not link to any statistics, but she also fails to link to any rape helplines or victim resources, or even any educational programs like PAVE. PAVE by the way is a nation-wide college campus rape victim and educational resource.
Also, of course The New York Times isn't peer reviewed lol. It's a journalistic production with the sole intent on making money. You can't trust anything in the newspaper more than you can anything on the Internet. Is most of what goes through in the newspaper actually true? Probably, just the same as it probably is on the Internet.
Also your fuck off to me is kind of unnecessary and makes you look like a bad poster. I was simply showing that your link can't be taken as true hard facts, but instead as, you pointed out, a narrative on a subject of personal experience. Am I saying what she writes about didn't happen or can't help some people? No, but the possibility that she is a fake or fraud is there.
Yes, but I don't feel it should be considered the 'norm'.
Not discounting Jellicent at all because I love the guy, but we must remember this story is being told from his perspective. None of us witnessed this event, so we don't know exactly what transpired. For the record, I believe that he is telling the truth, but an experience as traumatic as that one makes it difficult to describe the event in an unemotional, objective manner.
That being said, I think the biggest issue we face is that the definition of rape has become so broad, and the line so blurred, that we can reasonably come up with such convicting statistics as "1 in 4 women have been raped". I know all of our opinions differ on what we consider to be 'rape', but I have an EXTREMELY hard time believing that 1 in 4 of the women I know have been raped.
I think the mistake we're making is that we're attributing the word 'rape' to so many incidents that we're taking emphasis off the more violent and intentional rape. To me, if another person physically forced you to perform a sexual act with them (either by brute force or by threatening/using a weapon), or if they physically drugged you against your will and did sexual things with you that you were unable to stop, that's rape. If you got piss drunk at a party and some other person took advantage of your impaired judgment to convince you to have sex with them, that's not rape.
All too often we treat each of these situations as the same, which detracts from the attention that SHOULD be paid to the real rape cases. When Person A takes advantage of Person B at a party because Person B is drunk off their ass and can't make decisions rationally, is Person A a douchebag? Yes. Is Person A a rapist? No. Person B has a choice to indulge in alcohol or not, and when they do they are taking responsibility for what they are doing. I don't think there is a single person out there who doesn't know that alcohol impairs judgment, so they can't claim ignorance for that.
There are other examples of situations that have been labeled as "rape" by our society that I would disagree with. Let's say Myzozoa and Oglemi are out on a date. They're in the car, gazing at the starry night sky, when Myzozoa starts to rub Oglemi's leg. Oglemi is uncomfortable with this and asks Myzozoa to stop, but Myzozoa says "but baby, I know you want it!" and starts getting friskier. Now, some would argue that rape has already taken place at this point, but I would disagree. I would say that what happens after this point will determine whether it's rape or not. If Oglemi were to get upset and the two were to have an argument, resulting in Oglemi walking away or Myzozoa grumpily taking Oglemi home in silence, then rape did not happen. If Myzozoa continues to forcefully touch and molest Oglemi and he does not try to resist him, then rape did not occur. If Oglemi resists and Myzozoa overpowers and continues to molest Oglemi, only then does it become rape. To me, the key word here is overpowers, meaning the line into rape is only crossed when one person overpowers another despite their resistance.
Another example is when a person takes advantage of another emotionally, convincing them to consent to sex. Perhaps Person A just had a nasty breakup and are emotionally vulnerable, and Person B capitalizes and talks Person A into having sex with them. Many in our society would call this rape, but I once again disagree. Taking advantage of another's emotional weakness is a dick move to be sure, but it is not rape. Emotional weakness of Person A is not the fault of Person B, nor is it even guaranteed that Person B knows the situation of Person A. Perhaps Person B just decided they were going to hit on Person A, and didn't know they were vulnerable. All too often people attribute the word 'rape' to a situation that is more just 'douchebaggery', which is morally reprehensible but in no way illegal.
The real crime is that true rape victims have been completely drowned out by the multitude of angry exes, gold diggers and retarded alcoholic college students who care more about the attention than real justice for the alleged "crime". More often than not, true rape victims don't even come forward out of embarrassment or fear, which is a real tragedy.
Rape is a horrible and disgusting thing, but I don't think real rape is nearly as common as we're led to believe.
You're also posting on a forum that's almost exclusively male, where basically all of the people replying who aren't particularly bothered by this sort of thing don't have much respect for women and are more likely to be the your sister's boyfriend or the other dude in that story than you.
So, here is my challenge for those who want to tell rape jokes:
Ask every woman in your life if she has been sexually assaulted. Ask her to tell you her story. This means your mother, your sister, your girlfriend, your grandma.
Once you have heard all their stories, go watch a movie with a rape scene in it. One you didn’t mind before. One you thought people were overly offended by.
Now tell me a joke.
If nothing else you guys may have a point about the rape culture that self-perpetuates. See guys like the one who raped my sister when she was a child, they then get raped by bigger men in prison. And that's hilarious.So, here is my challenge for those who want to tell rape jokes:
Ask every woman in your life if she has been sexually assaulted. Ask her to tell you her story. This means your mother, your sister, your girlfriend, your grandma.
Once you have heard all their stories, go watch a movie with a rape scene in it. One you didn’t mind before. One you thought people were overly offended by.
Now tell me a joke.
Did someone take advantage of your drunken/inebriated state to have sex with you?
Rape.
I'm not going to really dig into this post, but I only want to point out something that I find to be ironic. Here in this thread there seems to be a debate about what counts as rape. And this is exactly what happens to many rape victims or if you prefer, victims of sexual assault. And yes, nothing should go uncontested, but the level of minimizing and discrediting that goes on in sexual assault cases is unbelievable. Their accusations are contested by figures meant to be trustworthy and protective in the most ridiculous and insensitive ways. Recall Jelli's story of being told he was on drugs at the time, or some shit. And he wasn't even the one being assaulted. One of the reasons that I dislike rape jokes is that usually the joke is that 1. 'Haha it wasn't rape because x' or 2. 'haha rape'. This isn't a joke, this is real life. It sucks.
Side note: Even your lovely story about me and Oglemi invokes stereotypes about rape victims, so lol.
Male privilege is hearing about something that is violent and violating and terrifying and traumatizing, something that doesn’t happen to you, but happens to women all the time, something that is caused by you and members of your gender, something that happens to 1 in 5 women, something that could be done by anybody and you never know when it’s going to happen, something that is often a repeat offense or done by someone you trust… and laughing about it.