jjoshcja said:A few flaws in your logic
A: Getting a lucario burned if you can HW it off later in order to beat through your opponents luke counter is 100% good play, at the worst you have a +4 burned luke and they're looking to feed sableye or half their team to it in order to "nullify" the threat. Yes it breaks conventional logic but it does so to win the game quickly and efficiently. There's really no faster way to remove an offensive mons best check or soft counter than to simply sacrifice the offensive mon to break the check or soft counter. You want to stay in, they want to stay in because hell, its their counter to x threat and they don't need it for anything else.
B: Shamin muscles through bliss on its own, though yes it does so at the cost of a good chunk of seed flare PP, still, at the worst bliss runs off and you kill/maim another mon, it has like 3 reliable counters in the tier. Things like hydra and ape require prediction (though yes these mons are amazing). Min requires click flare. Click coverage for quad resist. Furthermore ape has absurdly low sustain and is laughable weak unboosted while also beign frail as all hell. Hydra has bulk, sustain in roost...and is setup fodder to some very nasty mons the second it clicks draco. Both Nape and hydra are also prone to giving up free turns despite their raw power. Hydra has 4mss with LO, nape gives chandy and victini all the free turns ever, both are also revenged by anything that revenges shamin.
C: 100/100/100 bulk on a grass type in a tier where bulky grounds waters and some electrics are common even on offensive teams gives min an abundance of swapin opportunities. Yes its easily RKed though admittedly that's applicable to every single non scarfed attacker in the tier not named tornadus-T or alakazam, however anything not a dedicated hard counter or special wall gets shredded swapping in and special walls are often forced out by that 37% DIE chance.
D: Saying an offensive support set requires support is um, wut? I'm arguing shamin for A+/borderline S based on its functionality as a stand alone offensive hose that can assist other mons in "forcing" a sweep overload HO style while still maintaining a varied offensive presence and even freeing up spots for defensive pivots on HO. HWMin requires you at the most to run the huge sacrifice of fire and flying resists, last I checked things like rotom-H and MAmpheros see use on heavy offense thanks to their ability to soak those types and maintain momentum. Hell min even comes in on their weaknesses and proceeds to click abuse button.
TL:DR: Running an effective 2 copies of your strongest sweeper along with an under prepared for sustainable wallbreaker that offers excellent synergy with the best offensive threats in the tier on any offensive team is pretty close to, though probably not quite S tier if you can fit it all into 1 mon slot. If your doubtful give it a try.
I literally can't even understand you man, I just can't. No, getting your Luc burnt is not a good idea when there are
better ways to get through Sableye. Its just ridiculously stupid to have this as your Sableye plan since there are other pokemon that can take care of Sableye for Luc.
As for your specs Shaymin calcs you brought up before, you've given a seriously skewed situation that plays perfectly into specs Shaymin's hands. You're coming in on something you force out and hitting your opponent's switch in with rocks up and perfect prediction, and on the Blissey calc you even threw on the -2 drop which is a 34% chance when factoring in the possibility to miss Seed Flare. The fact is lot of these pokes can come in without rocks up if they have to and then KO, or come in and revenge kill easily.
Hey, here's another possibility, what if you mispredict? Mispredictions can hurt like absolute hell on choice locked pokes, what if you try and Psychic a Crobat switch in and your opponent decides to let their Suicune faint so they can revenge it afterwards? Have fun running away for a bit because you just got forced out by exactly what you want to KO. By the way you just lost all of that momentum that your set supposedly gives you by being forced out, have fun losing all the momentum that HO needs.
I'm not going to restate my arguments again, Shaymin is good for taking out bulky water types, and is a decent grass pokemon overall. Its LO and subseed sets are good at what they do, but suggesting that Shaymin should be S-ranked because of a subpar set is wrong. You're point is ridiculous in the first place and the evidence you've given to support it is literally the perfect situation for the set you've suggested, further taking away from your piss-poor credibility. Saying a Shaymin set works well in perfect conditions just doesn't justify it being put on the same level as top pokemon like Infernape, Blissey, Alakazam, and Slowbro, and if you can't understand that then you're not prepared to suggest viability rankings.