leafgreen386 said:Mill... heh. I haven't seen one of these in a while. I used to play a mean mill back when tsukuyomi was still legal. I miss that card... lol
Anyway, however much I like the card, I just can't see drastic drop off being that helpful here. You're already forcing them to draw with dark bribe, defender, card destruction, morphing jar, and hand destruction, and they still get their normal draw phase plus whatever draw cards they use. You aren't stopping that much from happening, really, especially considering they get to choose which card to toss when they draw more than one.
I also can't say I like offerings to the doomed much, as weakening your own draw power is never a good thing.
Then you've got gravekeeper's servant. If they're attacking... aren't you... dying? I can't see that card ever depriving your foe of too many cards in a duel, and by that time you would be dead, and that's assuming you get it out first turn. I understand that it punishes them for attacking your flip effect monsters, but it seems like you would just get swarmed if you're not actually stopping their attacks.
I was gonna say something about defender in here, but now I can actually see it working fairly well.
Nightmare's steel cage only stalls for so long. I'd much rather block with something that lasts, such as messenger of peace. Even though monsters with 1400 or less atk can still get through, there aren't too many of those out there nowadays, it seems, given the more aggro nature of the metagame, with a lower reliance on flip and field to graveyard effects.
Here's what I would probably do with that deck:
-2 Gravekeeper's Servant
-2 Offerings to the Doomed
-3 Nightmare's Steel Cage
-1 Stumbling
-2 Drastic Drop Off
+1 Night Assailant
+1 Sangan
+1 Des Lacooda
+2 My Body as a Shield
+2 Hammer Shot
+3 Messenger of Peace
Night Assailant should help you get back those flip effect monsters once they get sent to the graveyard, and sangan can fetch any monster in your deck. My Body as a Shield is great for stopping effects that would destroy your monsters before you can flip them, and one can even take down a dark armed dragon if it's stupid enough to go for your monsters first, and it should also help with zaborg, too, not to mention turning defender into a nearly untouchable fortress with one of the block attack cards down. Hammer shot should make up for the lost removal from offerings to the doomed. Des Lacooda should help with your draw power a bit, unfortunately it needs to be flip summoned, so no desert sunlight tricks. It's not a quickplay, but at least it's removal. I opted for a third messenger over a third stumbling, but there are probably a few other cards you could take out instead. I also would've liked to include a couple penguin soldiers for reusing already flipped monsters (although it's probably too slow in this format, anyway... not saying that this deck in general isn't slow >_>). I'm personally not a big fan of snipe hunter, but I understand why people like it, so I left it alone.
You're gonna need a bigger sidedeck than that, but I really suck at building sidedecks, so I'm not gonna even try to make suggestions.
Well, I wasn't exaclty looking for any rate/fixes. lol But I'll just in general explain why some of the fixes you mentioned weren't included. See, almost all of your suggestions have been offered before (Barring Hammer Shot. Offerings to the Doomed is just so much faster. You can hit DAD or Jinzo the minute they show up, not a turn later. Speed is the key.) First is Des Lacooda. I originally had des lacooda in here, but I never got him when I needed him. First turn and with little stall to back him up he is a useless monster. Mid-Late game when I've milled away most of my opponents' (and my) deck, he becomes useless draw, as I'm just reusing all of my monsters. Night Assailant would have been added, except the deck runs marginally faster as it is. If I really need to reuse my flip effects, then desert sunlight with morphing jar is the key. Playtesting with Night Assailant early on showed that when I did need a flip effect monster back, I usually needed more than one and couldn't get them all. My Beef with Messenger of Peace is the three slots it takes up and it can't even stop searchers, who can still just ram through my terribly small defensed monsters. D-Heo Defender was mainly included to add mill and become a meat shield with Stumbling. Stumbling also protects my life points by letting monsters summoned for their effect be switched into defense position. Snip Hunter is in there to abuse this. Summon him, he goes to defense, and I can discard any extra cards to clear their field.
I suppose I'm just rambling on, so I'll sum it up like this: All of your changes have been suggested before. They have been used, and thoroughly tested. This version just runs a lot more smoothly as it currently is. Sorry if I just seemed to be ranting or whatnot. Just wanted to clarify that your changes have been noted in the past. =]
EDIT: Also, as a sidenote. I would run My Body as a Shield if I had any, but I do not. The moment I get two of them out the DDO goes.