As I touched on
here, the SV OU tiering council are seriously discussing
Roaring Moon and
Gliscor!
:Roaring Moon: Roaring Moon
:Roaring Moon: was previously banned for the brute strength of the then-standard Tera Flying Dragon Dance variants. 3 attacks sets with Acrobatics, Knock Off, and one of Earthquake or Brick Break had very limited counterplay and that counterplay was dwarfed by the occasional Taunt variants. Roaring Moon then returned to OU with the release of DLC2 and was seen as good, but not broken, for a number of months. At times, calls to include it in tiering discussions were met with responses labeling it as "Roaring Mid" as the old tricks were capped by various revenge killing mechanisms and soft defensive counterplay.
However, a recent shift in set mix has catapulted Roaring Moon back into the forefront of tiering discussions.
Bulky Roost variants are perhaps the largest development, but
Tera Blast Fairy sets is in the equation as well. Starting with the former, Roaring Moon is able to ditch some speed and even attack investment to go bulkier. This in conjunction with a defensive Tera type like Fairy or Ghost can give you a lot more set-up opportunity and make you less susceptible to priority than standard 3 attacks variants. Tera Blast Fairy is more simple, giving you the ability to flip the match-up into Zamazenta, Great Tusk, Iron Valiant, Raging Bolt, and various others while remaining resistant to Sucker Punch and becoming neutral to Ice Shard. You still are going to be vulnerable to Dragonite Extreme Speed and defensive stalwarts like Dondozo, but it has huge match-up swaying potential into opposing offense at a bare minimum.
These two sets now being common make playing around Roaring Moon, especially when you factor in the classic variants of it, challenging at best and guesswork at worst. There is counterplay to every variant of Roaring Moon and some overlap can exist, but most of it is archetype specific and all of it needs to remain healthy throughout a game despite being needed for common Roaring Moon partners on offensive teams. This dynamic puts a strain on teambuilding and has been met with many Roaring Moon sweeps throughout high ladder and tournament play. Numerous council members have expressed support for a suspect test.
Recent tournament games where Roaring Moon popped off from the last 3 weeks alone:
:Gliscor: Gliscor
:Gliscor: is another ex-Uber that has been dancing in-and-out of tiering talks. The tier's most durable swordsman has drawn the ire of many players due to it being a potent bulky win condition that is hard to pin down, especially with Tera options nullifying weaknesses like Ice and Water type attacks. The general sense is that Roaring Moon is closer to a suspect test right now, but Gliscor is hard to ignore with how common it is and how many resources it demands from opposing teams to contain.
Swords Dance Gliscor has been at the forefront of tiering talks, but it is worth noting that at least one council member sees Toxic variants as even more problematic as it is able to force incrimental progress without being threatened imminently enough in return at times. As for Swords Dance Gliscor, the best and most common variant is Swords Dance, Facade, Knock Off, and Protect. Earthquake is still a fine option, but being walled by specific Flying types or Air Balloon Gholdengo can prove costly. Tera Normal is a great option to tank attacks from Kyurem, Ogerpon-Wellspring, and other threats with coverage like Ice Spinner Great Tusk or Ice Beam Darkrai; the bonus of boosting Facade's power and immunizing Hex from Dragapult helps matters even more. Tera Water and Fairy are also great options for a plethora of possible match-ups depending upon your team.
We have noticed a lot of teams either need to run a combination of Pokemon like a Kyurem/Ogerpon-Wellspring/Great Tusk with initially effective attacks and then also something to take advantage of Normal type Gliscor like Zamazenta or Encore+Close Combat Iron Valiant, which can even fail to OHKO Gliscor from full. This is an enormous strain on team construction for archetypes like bulky-offensse as is, but it can get even more nuanced for bulky teams. Corviknight with Iron Defense is a great 1-on-1 stop, but it is possible for it to run out of Roost PP well before Gliscor is out of attacking PP, and things like Dondozo lack longevity once they lose Heavy-Duty Boots as well. This has meant Pokemon like Salt Cure + Ice Punch Garganacl, Weezing-Galar to flip Poison Heal into a major self-hit, or Big Stall favorite Knock Off + Sticky Barb Clefable cores to keep Gliscor's from recovering can check Gliscor, but many teams have to go off the beaten path to assure it does not threaten a sweep. Counterplay very much does exist, but is it convenient enough and numerous enough within the confines of our metagame for Gliscor to be balanced? That is what it boils down to!
Recent tournament games where Gliscor popped off from the last 3 weeks alone:
Both of these Pokemon are performing at elite levels consistently, threatening to end or at least derail games despite facing some semblance of counterplay. It is possible we proceed with a public suspect test without a formal, public survey depending upon support in this thread and the council. Please voice your thoughts on Roaring Moon and Gliscor in this thread in the immediate future!