Scuba Stevee said:I get the reasoning of banning auto-hail but I still think uu still needs some way to access hail. Using weather+theweatherrock combo works well with all the other weather effects except hail. rain dance and sunny day doesn't hurt pokemon so it can work. Sandstorm has three types that are not affected so it is more versatile. But hail has only ice and for that combo to be really effective is to have a team full of ice types which is stupid to do. So banning auto-hail from uu means not even having hail in uu which i personally think is a bad move. I don't get when people say hail is not effective in OU but is too effective in UU. What, it should just be in BL???
I really don't agree with putting snover in bl, aboma yes, but snover no. Your banning for it's ability; I have always thought that pokemon are but in their tiers based on a combination of thier usage, stats, movepool, and ability, not just one thing.
I don't mean to offend you, but that is about the most stupidest thing I had ever heard:\
El, Oh, El.
Firstly, UU can access Hail by using the move Hail. 5 Turn hail would be legitimate, being unkillable for 5 turns is pretty good dont you think?
Secondly, i cant beleive people are using the reasoning "But hail isnt good in OU(Due to Tyranitar/Hippo everywhere), so where can we use hail if its banned!?!?!?". The point is,
if something is broken in a tier, it must be banned regardless if there is no tier to effectively play it. This applies to so many pokemon(for example, Beedrill or any of the "old UU/NU" pokemon).
And lastly, the the bolded part......wow. If you happened to read the OP in the nomination forums(which you didnt i guess :/) it says:
Originally Posted by Fat
Jumpman16 MODIFIED!
Offensive Characteristic
A Pokémon is BL if, in common battle conditions, it is capable of sweeping through a significant portion of teams in the metagame with little effort.
Defensive Characteristic
A Pokémon is BL if, in common battle conditions, it is able to wall and stall out a significant portion of the metagame.
Support Characteristic
A Pokémon is BL if, in common battle conditions, it can consistently set up a situation in which it makes it substantially easier for other pokemon to sweep.
Those are the criteria for BL. Not its usage. Its based on: if ANYTHING, being any one or more move or any ability(or combinations of them), makes a pokemon fit these definition, they are BL.
And you missed Chou's Point :(......
Veedrock said:While I do agree that hail makes certain pokemon go beyond UU limits, what we should be doing is banning the culprit. That culprit is Abomasnow or what he makes broken. Snover is nowhere in this equation.
What evidence is there to suggest that Snover is "broken" though? Sure, people don't like auto-hail, I get that. Maybe Snover is broken. Who knows. But banning Snover is completely theory based by associating it with it's evolution. There is zero evidence to show that it would be "broken" if he was still available. So yes, it is a theory ban if it happens.
Are you saying that Snow Warning Metapod, Sunkern, or hell, Ditto, would be banned (hypothetically speaking)?
Some people have tested it other than me im sure.
But banning a pokemon for the ability Snow Warning, means Snover leaves too, its common sense really.
Theory banning would be me saying, "lets ban (for example) Swellow, because with (for example) Steelix and Registeel gone, it will be broken!". This is what we are doing: "Auto-Hail has proven to be broken, therefor all pokemon with this ability should be banned".
Seven Deadly Sins said:Abomasnow's big thing is that it's able to freely switch into the STABs of the major weather abusers of each weather type. It resists both Water and Grass, which not only makes it top-notch against the dangerous Ludicolo, but also gives it an edge when switching into Chlorophyll users (especially if you get in on the Solarbeam charge turn and rape them with STAB Blizzard). Snover's lower defenses and much lower Speed means that it's a lot harder for people to use it to counter weather with Snover than Abomasnow.
I remember when I ran Hail Stall that Abomasnow absolutely rapes most weather teams due to the fact that only Sunny Day-boosted fire attacks can beat it and even then it's kinda iffy.
The arguement isnt that Snover is just as good as Abomasnow, it's that they are both broken for their abilties.